Dicarlo's Original Pizza Crust

Best pizza I've ever eaten! The crisp crust and the cold cheese!.......best piece is eaten when you go back to your car L

My favorite pizza of all time! I love the family feeling when I go here! Best pizza ever! Love that the cheese is still melting as you eat it!

This is the best pizza in Steubinville. To be honest with all the pizza snobs in Pittsburgh, Dicarlo's is Beto's with the cheese melted. Great flavor, excellent crust, DeCarlo's is worth the drive to the Burb of the Burgh! Who came up with that $#|+?

Best on planet at making fresh pizza mouth is literally watering to the thought of their pizza

I don't understand the "best" rating. I have eaten DiCarlo's 100 times (always when going with friends) and the sprinkled on cold cheese and scant pepperoni is not that good. The square crust is tasty, and they are cheap but that's it. I think it is a case of public brain washing that "local" + different (cold, scant ingredients)= best pizza. Weird.

This is for the DiCarlos on Sunset Blvd. ,Steubenville, Ohio,,,the one I loved.I grew up eating DiCarlos pizza and it was the greatest tasting pizza anywhere, but in the last 8 months, the sauce is terrible, not the same taste it always had, sometimes the crust is over done, or raw....there was a blonde young girl that really should not have been working with the public...she was rude.This is for the DiCarlos on Sunset Blvd. ,Steubenville, Ohio,,,the one I loved.

Picture yourself back in time 10 years....we don't take credit card they said. In fact I'm not sure if they knew what a check card was. They have weird sizes too. No small med or large.? We got a sheet he says...is this a bakery or a pizza shop.? We hopped in a Delorean to 2014 and went to Pizza Butt.

Obviously its an opinion, but I love the unmelted (less greasy) cheese. Their other locations aren't the greatest, so I'd recommend the original in Stooby. I've always liked it for a local franchise. The pizza has always been great and filling. "Scant" ingredients aren't the words I'd use to describe this pizza. The sauce has tiny pepper chunks in it, which I usually don't like, but it compliments DiCarlos pizza. If you haven't tried it, you don't know what your missing. Hands down one of the best local pizzas there is.

I used to really love DiCarlo's til their horrid customer service started pissing me off everytime I went in. The pizza isn't the same as it used to be either. Not sure about other locations but avoid this one!