Dicarlos Downtown Pizza

DiCarlos is truly a gem and an absolute staple of the Ohio Valley! Whenever I'm in the downtown area, I can't resist stopping by for a slice.

Place is really good and handmade. Note to my fellow young women: Pizzeria is staffed with handsome young men that I'm pretty sure are available! I'm taken but if you are single and a fairly attractive woman (under 45, lol) it's boyfriend city! Ladies, you would have zero competition as their customer base is boomers! Lol. Only drawback is occasionally they will close early in the winter

DiCarlo's is now a small chain with restaurants in and around the WV, OH, PA area and even located down in Myrtle Beach, SC. However, you just can't beat the DiCarlo's Pizza in the Mid-Ohio Valley...the birthplace of the original DiCarlo's Pizza. Be aware that the majority of them in these neck of the woods only accept cash. There is an ATM on the premise, but it's going to come with a fee. This DiCarlo's is clean, the service was friendly and the food was made perfectly! There is no eating in; it's a grab and go establishment, so I ordered 3 to go with pepperoni, mushroom and extra cheese; that is my favorite combination. They were not skimpy with the toppings and the combination of the hot pizza, cold cheese melted in my mouth. Although not a huge menu to choose from (keeping it simple is the way to go), they do offer hoagies and sodas as well. I give this one 5 stars, which it deserves in every way!

The fam and I stopped in after Christmasing at the Steubenville Nutcracker Festival on a frosty Saturday night and DiCarlo's was jumpin'! The pricing here, although cash only, compared to the quality of the pizza is an extraordinary value. The classic Ohio Valley style cheese and pepperoni and the high quality, slightly sweet sauce are delightful. I could eat a tray by myself. Maybe one day...

My favorite pizza anywhere. Strictly takeout. I've only ever gotten the slices, but looks like there is new specialty pizzas by the tray.Best bet is to call ahead, else you'll wait for a little while.

Where do I start. Horrible service. I called in to order pizza and specified half pepperoni and half banana pepper. I don't eat pork. Once i got there, they gave it to me in all one box and said i would have to pay for a whole new pizza if they made me another one. Then. They don't take cash. They have an atm in side that charges 8$ to take money out. What in the old fashioned stuff is this? Being in the food industry myself, I am no softie when it comes to service. I'll never give this place another dollar of my money. Gianamorres it is when I come back to town and I suggest you save yourself the headache

Amazing pizza. Loved it. Really like that you can buy it by the slice. Extra cheesy and mild pepper rings.

9-27-23 , visited the newly reopened store downtown today, when home I put the slices in the garbage, very disappointed, crust was blackened, and tasted burnt, I used to buy here before and pizza was very good, they can close it back up , I can buy frozen pizza better than what they are serving now.

I give it 4 stars for the taste and the crunch. Now that my favorite pizza joint in Steubenville is no longer cooking pizzas, this is my go to.Service is always good here. If u visit Steubenville, this is the place to order for square pizza

The everything also mushroom extra cheese anchovies hope they open downtown back up ,Downtown Dicarlos did a lot of business for many of years