Benny Fierro's

Let me tell you anytime I go here I'm never not satisfied(even when I order two slices) The pie is good and the size of it is MASSIVE but if you're in town or out near the bars definitely grab a slice

Amazing generous sized New York slices and whole pies. The Two youngsters were behind the counter were absolute legends, Very nice. Genuinely best pizza in Pittsburgh. Has a very cool vibe, idk what the kids would call it, grunge? I just eat pizza man. Seems great for friends and families.

First time here, saw it on Barstool before. Unassuming space on Carson Street that had a steady stream of customers. The slices are enormous. I took the advice of the person taking my order and selected the cheese steak slice as it was almost gone and wouldn't be back for a while. They had several types of slice to choose from. The price was decent too for how big the slice was. I can eat and I only ordered one and went home satisfied.I want to go back and try some other offerings soon.

Everyone has to experience a slice of Benny's pizza at some point. One slice is all you need. It's huge! And only $5!! They are open all the time. You can run in a grab a slice. Or an entire pie. If you think the box can fit in your car!

Got two huge 28-inch pizzas. Delicious New York style thin-crust. Great flavored crust, a little crispy underneath, a little thicker around the edge, foldable slices. The sauce was mellow and slightly sweet. We got classics, one plain and one pepperoni. You can order by-the-slice, too, I think. They also had a couple of interesting-sounding specialty options that change every few weeks. We had over a dozen people, and two of their huge pizza's were plenty, with seconds for several of us. We called in and picked it up. I dont think anyone delivers from this South Side Flats Carson St. location. Great pizza, done on time. We'll be back!

Delicious!! It's a huge pizza slice for about 6$. One slice was actually enough for 2 but depends on appetite as well! Sauce and cheese taste delicious. Fast service as well. Would recommend to make the trip to the south side for this!

Looking to load up on yummy pizza while in Pittsburgh? Then look no further then Benny Fierro's on Southside. After 2 flights to partake in the Pittsburgh 5K/Half-Marathon, Benny's saved my family and I from hunger. And it helped with loading up on the carbs to burn the next day. The slices are HUGE! Huge enough that my Sister and I ended up sharing two slices. I recommend the mushroom one if you're a mushroom lover like me. The staff was down-to-Earth. It was our first time and they answered all our questions. Fast service. Cool spot in a cool area in Pittsburgh!

One slice is a meal. Two slices are if you are high. Three slices are if you completely hate yourself and actively desire to throw up. I usually eat 1.5 slices, so figure it out. Staff is consistently good at their job. Limited seating. Only canned/bottled beverages, so don't expect a big gulp level soda.

Tried for first time as part of "pizza passport." Freaking huge slice. Full after one!!! Really tasty.

LOVE this place!!! Won't find a cheaper or better slice of pizza! My friend Paul is Italian and even HE approves!