Aiello's Pizza

An interesting comparison to Mineo's--perhaps a higher level of craft, but not aa distinct Pittsburgh style. I would recommend locals try it to see what they like, but if you're a tourist and want something Burgh-ish, go to Mineo's or Shelly Pie.The pluses of Aiellos: the crust was cooked nicely and crispy on the bottom, the sauce wasn't overwhelming, and the toppings all slid in place without sliding around. The toppings were symmetrical and well-distributed, and the pizza was cooked perfectly.The minus of Aiellos, to me, is that the pizza is much closer to NY-style than to Pgh-style. The crust is thin, the cheese doesn't blanket it, and there's shockingly little grease. To many, this would be a plus. But if I'm visiting and want a taste of home, I want my pizza to be lopsided and swimming in grease, which just isn't the Aiello's way.

Service was fast and friendly. Lots of seating available. Pizza was good. They have already prepared options and you can order by the slice. We selected our choices and I believe they placed them in the oven to heat up. We ordered the veggie stuffed pizza and a slice of the cheese. Wish the veggie came with a side of a marinara but just personal preference. They crust is good. The only downside was no parking and cash only.

Love the thin crust pizza, the bottom was cooked to perfection! Bottom was crispy but not burnt. Prices are very reasonable but heads up, it's CASH ONLY.Our food came out quickly and staff was helpful.The restaurant was very clean!

Stopped in while window shopping in Squirrel Hill. I'd heard good things about the pizza and was pretty pleased with the chewiness of the crust. Staff were friendly too. This restaurant is cash only, so plan in advance. For one slice of pepperoni and one slice of cheese, it was $5.50. Price wasn't terrible, but the size of the slices wasn't large and so it feels a little steep comparatively.

Fast food like pizza restaurant with a friendly staff. The fries were good and work well with ranch dressing. The pizza roll was ok but the inner gooey dough was great. The pizza was nice and crispy and extra salty because of the anchovies. Cash only!

This was really really good food, they are a cash only business so be aware but they do let place an over the phone order. The chicken cutlet is a real chicken breast which I appreciated but I wish I ate the food fresh out of the oven the cheese got stiff.

I stumbled upon Aiello's Pizza while walking around Squirrel Hill and was able to try their pizza slices. The people were friendly and the space with clean with a person hand making the pizza in the corner. Their pizza slices are customizable and you can add whatever topping you want on each slice, which I really like. I got two slices of the cheese pizza and added pepperoni and onions. The texture of the pizza itself is a perfect mixture of crisp and soft, which I personally like a lot, but the pizza was bland and lacked flavor even with the pepperoni slices. Overall, this place was good for a quick snack with customizable toppings per slice, but I wish it had more flavor.

Fantastic place with great food and fast service. Would definitely go there again. Pizza was the best

So I grew up in Massachusetts where bar pies rule. Thin, well done, great cheese and toppings. I haven't found it here in Pittsburgh yet but this pie is amazing. Cash only, limited seating but great vibe. You can watch them create your pie and enjoy a conversation with staff about the Steelers. I order thin pepperoni and sausage. Insanely great! Love this place and go as much as I can. Cannot recommend more!

Pizza is meh at best. Overpriced for sure. Cuts are small. A small pizza with toppings.. $30?? BTW, toppings were sparse. Definitely not good enough to justify the price. $75 for 2 small and 1 large pizza ( one pizza was plain). I expected some pretty special pie. Didn't happen and won't happen again.