Pinckney Cookie Cafe

I loved the customer experience and the cookies! I got brown butter bourbon, double chocolate espresso, and molasses and they were all out of this world delicious. I'm visiting from atlanta and will be ordering cookies online to share with my family back home, they're that good.

I discovered Pinckney Cookie Cafe through Yelp's recommendation for Black-Owned Businesses that deliver. Who wouldn't be curious about a 5-star Cookie Cafe that also offered plant-based/vegan and gluten-free options?I placed my online order on Monday and received the cookies Friday, nicely packaged in an adorable giftbox and carefully nestled into a larger corrugated box for shipping. Everything arrived quickly and in perfect shape for eating! I ordered a custom box, one of each variety of the "Miracle Cookie" line, which are all vegan and gluten-free. 1. Original2. Chocolate Oatmeal3. Bing Bling4. Classic Chocolate Chip5. Double Chocolate Espresso6. Apple PieSome of the cookies had a moist, almost cake-like texture, chewy and super tasty! The others were simply chewy and ultra soft-baked and too easy to eat!! Their style of cookies are a smidge on the sweet side for my taste (but most cookies are when I'm not the one doing the baking). Part of the wonderful texture of these cookies is attributed to their 10-ingredient flour blend called Miracle Flour. Vegan cookies aren't too tough to make, but. BUT. moist, gluten free cookies (vegan or not) are not-so-easy to accomplish without the cookies getting crumbly or having a grainy texture due to the alternative flours. Pinckney's Miracle Flour lives up to the name. Also, there is something to be said when a bakery decides to make Chocolate Oatmeal Cookie as opposed to Oatmeal Raisin. Who wants raisins??? That's like getting a box of raisins trick or treating!! Just. No. Chocolate Oatmeal was what told me I could trust this bakery (haha)I thoroughly enjoyed each one of the cookies ordered. My favorite was the Classic Chocolate Chip and Double Chocolate Espresso. As for the Apple Pie, I personally would have preferred a ton more spice but the cookie was still fabulous. It reminded me of a sweeter version of a Clif Bar. I would definitely order again now that I know which cookies I really love. Treat yourself to a cookie combo box!! No excuses, they ship nationwide!

Love these delicious and moist cookies from Pinckney! Our favorites were the double chocolate espresso, the brown sugar bourbon, the ginger molasses, and of course classic chocolate chip. Nice strong flavors, but not overpowering. Bought a dozen for $30 which I felt was a good deal for the quality and quantity.

I'm so happy I ran across Pinckney Cookie Cafe a few Sundays ago at the Ballard Farmers Market, I had a wonderful ginger molasses cookie and had regrets of not purchasing more.I haven't been able ton make it back to the Sunday market since and was happy find out I could order online. I placed the order on Saturday and it surprisingly arrived today; really quick considering the holiday shipping delay.I ordered the Pinckney Dozen, an assortment of the the favorites. My husband and sons decided to help themselves, and insisted I order more as soon as possible!! I really appreciate that each cookie is prepackaged, and can be frozen if you don't have a houseful of boys who devour all things good!No matter where you live if you love a great cookie, definitely order from Pinckney Cookie Cafe; I highly recommend!!

Got the gluten free and vegan cookies during the farmers market today. Got the double chocolate and the original. AMAZING. I wish I had bought more the minute I ate my first one. Texture was great. Flavor incredible. And they tasted so fresh. The original was just out of this world.

These cookies are delicious, especially the dark chocolate oatmeal, Pinckney original, and ginger molasses. Shipping is fast and easy. Great for gifts!

I read the reviews before buying and it's not that great. There are a lot better cookies out there.

I am apparently on a cookie phase where I see a place selling them I want to try :)I heard a lot about this company over a few foodie group so was pleasantly surprised to see them at the UW farmers market. Looks like the guy that is there is the founder and he seem to be pretty busy. Busy enough to not be able to restock the cookies. We managed to get 4 cookies: apple pie, dark chocolate oatmeal, classic chocolate chip and the double chocolate espresso. The cookies flavors are ok in my opinion because I'm not a fan of soft cookies. So if you are a softie fan, these are a must. I do like the dark chocolate oatmeal and apple pie cookies a lot though because the complex texture. Oh and they had a deal where if you buy 4, you get 2 of their brown sugar bourbon cookie, and they were decent. Overall, I can see myself ordering the oatmeal and apple pie cookies again here And the price is so much more reasonable than a lot of places

I needed a good vegan and gluten free option for a small get together and I've heard great things about the Miracle cookies, so I ordered a dozen. The cookies themselves were a hit, but the customer service leaves a lot to be desired. The FAQs on the site says, "We offer curbside pickup Monday, Wednesday and Friday between 4:00 and 6:00 PM. Your order will be ready on the Curbside Pickup day 2 days after you place it (e.g. order Monday and your order will be ready Wednesday, order Tuesday and your order will be ready on Friday, order Friday and your order will be ready on Monday, etc.)" Since my get together was on Thursday morning, I placed my order on Monday, so that I could pick up the cookies on Wednesday afternoon and they would still be fresh for Thursday morning (the FAQs also say that the cookies need to be refrigerated if not eaten within a day of arrival). I was surprised to get a notice on Monday at 2:30 pm that I needed to pick up my cookies that day between 4 pm and 5:30 pm. It was very short notice for a short pick-up window. I couldn't change my schedule to pick-up on Monday and called to find out what my options were.I told them I couldn't pick up the cookies during the time period required and asked what my options were and explained that I had expected to pick them up on Wednesday based on their FAQs and that they were for a get together on Thursday morning. At first they said they could freeze them and I could pick them up on Wednesday, so I had some questions on whether it would be better to refrigerate rather than freeze, etc. After I asked my questions, they offered to remake my order fresh on Wednesday and said I could pick them up on Wednesday. Note: I did not request this and would not have requested this, they offered to remake the order. I thanked them and picked up my cookies on Wednesday. When I got home, I opened the box and the cookies had obviously been frozen. There was condensation on the plastic wrappers and some of the cookies were still frozen in the middle. I made sure to store them in the refrigerator rather than leaving them out as I would have if they were made fresh. While the product is good and are 5 stars on their own, I have a hard time doing business with a vendor that would be unnecessarily deceitful and/or think so little of their customers, believing we wouldn't be able to tell if a product had been previously frozen.

We ordered a dozen of the regular cookies in multiple flavors. They were not special. Each was individually wrapped and sealed in plastic. This made them all soft, no crisp. Compared to cookies from Macrina bakery, Deru market, Met Market, and so on and so....these were not at all good and way over priced for a so-so bakery item. I wonder if the gluten-free, vegan ones are extra special? If not, I can't imagine why anyone would buy them.