Stevie's Pizza

I love this place I go here every time I want pizza and it's just an awesome place the staff and owner are really nice the service is nice the pizza is amazing and it's just overall good

My husband and I stopped in to get a couple slices of pizza on a Sunday evening at 7:30pm... they close at 9pm according to the sign out front. Walked in, restaurant was empty. 3 employees behind the counter. We both ordered a slice of pepperoni pizza and a drink. The kid at the register pointed to two pieces of pizza sitting in the warmer on the counter. They looked like they had been in there for hours. The employee said "... I'll just add pepperoni to this slice of cheese pizza for him and add pepperoni to this one for you.." Which looked to be a margarita pizza slice. What??? Are you serious?! Obviously we left. The restaurant was open for another hour and a half and this is the quality and service being offered? Coming from hospitality management for 20 yrs... I'm POSITIVE the owners would not be okay with this. The last customer at night should receive the same service and quality of food as the first person in the morning. Just thought you should know.. since, as of now, Stevie's is one of very few places to eat up here in Vistancia.*** I'm willing to delete this review once I know owners have seen this***

Meh. $27 for a Large Veggie pie with no cheese. For the price alone, won't be back. Also, was charged more than what the menu said! Menu says $23 for a Large Veggie Pie, we were charged $25 AND we got less ingredients. Oh well.

Tried Stevie's for the first time on Superbowl Sunday so they were quite backed up. It was a pickup of the only two (2) wings they offer, BBQ and Buffalo, but neither disappointed.They did their best on a busy day and we will definitely be back at a better time for them and their customers. Will try different menu items as the wings were good.Casual, counter service in a very casual atmosphere.

I definitely had to leave a review today based on the customer service that I've received consistently. As a native New Yorker I'm really hard on pizza makers and this place does not disappoint.Each time I come in the order is correct, the food is exceptionally great, and the people are kind. Today a young lady helped me out to the car after seeing me struggling with my cups and my pizza lol. I really appreciate that extra effort. Good customer service goes a long way with me. OMG and try the zeppoles. Thank you!

After a day of desert riding we decided to look for a nearby pizza place we'd never been and found Stevie's. The options in Vistancia are limited and this is the only pizza you'll find. The reviews here seem to vary. I try to look at the worst rated and see why and who is rating. While some are obviously valid with service being rude or wait times I also see reviews coming from people with only one or two reviews ever and only negative. I don't tend to take those seriously and want to give a place a fair shot. While I did see some of what the negative reviewers talked about our experience was pretty good. Let's start with the positives though because who wants to lead with the bad. While the parking lot was busy it was easily accessible and we were able to find parking even with our trailer and bikes. There is a grocery story nearby as well as coffee and other businesses. When we walked in we were greeted and given a minute to look over the menu. Options are pretty good and they also serve beer on tap. The location is small, but hold quite a few booths and tables. There are a few outside tables as well. It was quite busy and people coming and going with pick up orders and such. We decided on a large pepperoni, garlic knots and hot wings. They have both large and small pints and the glass was chilled which is a definite bonus point. The boy running the register was pleasant enough and explained it would be about 40 minutes or so for our pizza. We hoped it wouldn't take that long, but again it was busy. While waiting we heard the employee on the phone sounding like they were turning some customers away because the cook was getting overwhelmed. We were pleased to get our garlic knots and wings quickly. The wings were steaming and looked amazing. They are not baked which I love and not over sauced either. They were crispy and good sized wings with lots of meat. The garlic knots were good as well. Our pizza soon followed at about 30 minutes and the appetizers held us over so it was no big deal. The pizza had good flavor, my son was happy with the amount of pepperoni and crust was a bit crispy and not soggy which I liked. So on to the negative. I heard a little attitude from the counter employee when people picking up orders came in at their told pick up time to food not being ready. There's nothing to argue if you told someone good would be ready and it's not just apologize and thank them for their patience don't argue minutes. For us we had a pretty good experience. We enjoyed our food and service for us was ok. As I said I can see why some find customer service rude, wait times long and such. Just remember that this is a local owned business, it can get overwhelmed as it's a very busy spot. Have some patience and kindness. If you're looking for a big chain type place this may not be for you.

Tried the salad and pizza combo here and it was good enough. The pizza was very bland though and needed a better sauce, but was helped with cheese, salt, oregano and pepper. The $9 special also included a side salad, which was crisp and had a good Italian dressing. Will try something else next time.

Just ordered a calzone, wings, and antipasto salad from Stevie's. The food was actually pretty good. My issue was with the ranch. It does not taste anything like ranch and was very watery. Even had a bitter sour taste. What is it made with? I know it's just a dip but since I wanted it for my calzone and wings it made a big difference. Fix the ranch and the food would be 4+ stars.Second issue was online ordering. I live 1 mile away off of Loan Mountain, yet their site and mobile app could not find my address. They proceeded charged me $4 extra for delivery. The house has been around since 2005 so it's not new. Google maps, Waze, and all GPS apps find this place easily too. So I'm not sure what's wrong with the mapping function Stevie's is using. Please fix this.

Great pizza in a small,yet comfortable location! So much better than the chains. We just moved to the area and found this convenient, very tasty and very friendly service!! We plan on returning soon.

Pizza was good. Wings were ok. We found some hair in our pizza... showed the workers... not a care in the world... for $74 for 2 pies (1 Large and 1 Med) and 20 wings... and 3 drinks... I'd expect at least the Pie to be re-made without the hair... oh well.. won't repeat. More pizza joints in the area to try.