Pegasus Coffee House

We went somewhere else for breakfast before this, but were still intrigued by their Pegasus signature avocado toast, and I'm glad we followed through on that. The layer of goat cheese (between the bread and avocado spread) was goated. They were also quite liberal with the amount of avocado used in the spread, resulting in a fantastic bread-to-topping ratio. I'm also not normally a bacon person but I liked how the crumble was non-greasy and even a little sweet, and the tomatoes were super refreshing!!The coffee was solid, but I do wish there were more fun flavors in addition to their 1-2 season flavors. The cold brew also wasn't my favorite but wasn't bad. The place was busy but also large - there were also lots of seating options, both indoor and outdoor, so we didn't feel too rushed. The line got super long on our way out though (late morning on Memorial Day) so be prepared for that!!

Adorable little spot just past the main street and located at or near the harbor. Coffee was okay - I did ask for a ristretto shot and the gal that took our order asked "what is that". I told her quickly "its a slow pull" - after she spoke with the barrista I wasnt told if they were capable or not to change the settings on the machine (totally understandable as some spots wont allow the employees to change the settjngs on the machines). My latte tasted like a regular cup of joe - which is pretty hard to do when brewing an espresso shot. We had a bagle and an almond pastry whixh were good. The ambiance is super adorable - the outside is as cute as can be. PRO TIP make sure you fill out a FREE postcard to mail to whomever you want.

More like 3.5/5. Solid and standard coffee shop.We ordered the iced vanilla latte and iced hazelnut latte. They tasted exactly how we expected them to taste. Their drinks taste like Wood's Coffee or honestly almost any coffee shop's, so nothing special. I wouldn't go out of my way to come back. The exterior is cute and unique from other coffee shops though! Very cozy and could use a trim!

If you're visiting Bainbridge Island as a tourist, this is a great first stop to your day trip. It's a little out of the ways of downtown, but you can walk by the pier and get a great view of the boats and the harbor on your way. The exterior of this building is beautiful, with overgrown vines running up and down the brick walls. The interior is very cozy, albeit a little crowded. It's a great place to sit and relax for a slow start to your morning. In terms of the actual food and drink, everything else was just okay. We got a latte and an earl grey donut, and both were pretty standard and didn't taste particularly special. It's also noisy inside, so not a great place to get work done if that's the coffee shop vibe you're looking for. If you're over the aesthetic aspect and just looking for some good quality coffee, I'd probably suggest somewhere else.

The cutest little coffee shop! So quaint inside with delicious coffee. They offer local pastries and make their own sandwiches that are really tasty. The staff are all so friendly and helpful with picking out items off the menu if you need suggestions. It can get packed so service can be a little slow but worth the wait.

Cute cafe ambiance with pretty decent coffee. Staff are all very friendly. The cappuccino tasted a little burnt and nutty but overall still really yummy. Sadly did not love the donut, tasted like a healthy donut masquerading as a yummy donut...

my friend and I came here and we both got the seasonal (?) honey lattes! (mine was with oat milk and his was with almond milk.) it's a beautiful coffee house and it was really pleasant to sit inside and take a break from our day. The staff is really kind and the lattes are excellent!

My partner and I took the ferry over to Bainbridge for a day trip on a Wednesday, (so it wasn't super busy) and were super excited to try Pegasus. The building itself is super cool and quaint and the inside is soooo cozy, however the service was honestly not great. We had a few questions about the pastries in the case and the barista seemed super annoyed, which I think made the food and coffee taste like nothing particularly special when all was said and done :(. I really tried smiling a lot and being super polite, but it was to no avail. It was super unpleasant and then just made the whole experience very uncomfy, which was honestly such a bummer, we had been looking forward to trying it for so long!

One of the first coffee places I tried when I was in Seattle! Pretty good coffee! No complaints. Got the caramel iced latte and it was delicious.They have plenty of seating indoor and the service was pretty quick. Good spot for studying or hanging out to catch up with friends.

If you are gluten free and vegan they have a good selection of really delicious donuts. If you are GF and willing to risk x contamination you can get breakfast sandwiches cause they have GF bread. My sandwich with regular bread was so yummy. I went with the veggie egg and cheese.This place is so cute and the service was lovely. Got really busy at about 9:30 but before that was quiet The reason it's only getting 4 stars is because gf non dairy options were severely limited by the fact that the eggs are premixed and the girls were only "pretty sure" there was no milk in them which is too big of a risk for my husband to take.