Pauly's Pizza Joint

Visited Pauly's Pizza Joint great place! Hopefully we have the chance the meet Pauly himself on the next visit

Ordered on door dash and was very happy with the result. I'm obsessed with garlic cheesy bread and this hit the spot. Crunchy, gooey, flavorful. Will for sure re-order. Need to try their pizza next.

Small pizza place in SD. I'm from NY and was curious about this one. The regular cheese slice and the margherita slice weren't very good. The chicken bacon ranch one was pretty good, but didn't come with much chicken or bacon on it. The pizza didn't come out very warm tho. There's also no bathroom to use. My search definitely continues for good pizza in this state....

A reliable foodie friend dined here about a month ago and raved about the pizza he and his fam had devoured. Because of his update, I was more eager to eat here, and I had this joint bookmarked for about two years. Unfortunately, I had a sub-par experience. We've ordered pizza by the slice, and it was about 6:00 pm on a Monday. Perhaps the pizza is far better if made-to-order, and on weekends.Pesto pizza slice: this was a bit dry but flavorful. Herbs and garlic came through, but the amount of cheese was lacking, 7.5/10 rating.TKO and Hawaiian pizza slices: these were both dry and average tasting. The sauce was bland, while the cheese was minimal, 7/10. The atmosphere was strange, as the majority of the lights in the dining area were off and the restaurant looked closed from the parking lot. The employee that took our order was not communicative, and I had to ask if the two pizza slices that I've ordered include a canned soda, in which he only nodded to confirm. This spot is a one and done for me =(

Good solid pizza option in the sorrento valley/miramar area.Tried the buffalo chicken. Tried the pepperoni. Was so good, went and got another slice.Cons: Parking can be a problem during lunch in this strip mall since there are other food places as well

I picked up a pizza and calzone on their app in the morning for dinner pick up. About 30-45 mins after placing the order, I received a call asking if I could come earlier because they wanted to close early. I was surprised and had to scramble to get someone to cover for me so I could pick up food about 2 hours earlier. When I arrived the cook was standing outside and hadn't even made my order! No apology. I had to wait 20 mins. Food was OK, too much dough. I like supporting small businesses, but sometimes adjusting my schedule to accommodate theirs makes it difficult. I would not recommend Pauly's, especially not if you plan ahead.

We love Pauly's! Amazing calzones and stromboli. Flavorful dough. This is our favorite local pizza spot!

The pizza was one of the best pizzas I've ever had. 10/10 would recommend. My favorite is the Buffalo pizza. This is what real east coast pizza should be! Crust is delicious and you can tell that dough was made fresh!! It's not rubbery and you can fold it in half.

Great customer service!!! Best pizza in town! Absolutely love everything on their menu.

The best pizza NY style pizza I've had in San Diego! The crust is great, the toppings all tasted fresh, and the service was excellent. Glad I found my new pizza joint.