Paulie Gee's Wicker Park

Ugh! I was so excited to try Pauline Gee's when my cousin mentioned that they had vegan options. I ordered two vegan slices which had quite a few toppings, but was so bland. The most flavor came from the drizzle on top. I noticed they have two locations and the other has a more extensive vegan menu. I'm willing to give it another try at the other location, and maybe, if I order an entire pizza, it'll be a better experience.

Slice shop open until 2am that actually has several great tasting options. Thankfully a friend reminded me of this place after so much time outside of the city so that we could make a quick stop before we continued our late night up Milwaukee Ave. My go-to Sausage and Giardineira tasted great and the Vodka Roni was also a pleasant surprise that might be my new favorite topping combo. Quick and friendly service and although there was a good amount of people initially a table opened up pretty quickly so that our group of 4 could enjoy our slices along with the emo songs of our youth to nod along to in between bites.You can order full pizzas too at this location but I don't know how late that goes.

Really delicious and well priced slice shop!Stopped by the Wicker Park location and was very pleasantly surprised. The slices put you back $4.25 for just cheese or $4.75 with toppings. They have lots of fun topping combos ready to go. Slices come out super quick and hot, with a crispy bottom and crust. I had the white fish pizza and really liked it! Would totally come back and try some more. Fair warning: no free water available; just bottled water available for purchase. The bathrooms in the back have codes on them, so ask the cashier if you need.

This place is an absolute 5/5!!! The service was really great, with a warm greeting, cashier who helped us decide what to get, and gave us an accurate time of how long itll take to make it so we could come back and eat it. They also offer slices if you're in a rush/dont need whole pies. The sausage and pepperoni can be halal, which is a major plus! We tried the sausage and peppers pie and it was SO GOOD. the crust is perfect, it passes the pizza fold test and the ratios of cheese, meat, peppers was perfect. One of the best slices I've had in a really long time. The inside space is pretty large w some long tables and clean bathrooms. Fun music and its in a really cool neighborhood to explore while they make your pie. Highly recommend and will be back!!

I AM OBSESSED. My absolute favorite pizzas here are the Logan Zaddy and the Wicker Baby. The Logan Zaddy's star ingredients are the pepperoni, bacon jam, and Mikes hot honey. A winning combination and ADDICTING. The Wicker Baby's star ingredients are the pepperoni and the tomato sauce, which is so savory and has a spicy kick! I love that you can order by the slice here, especially when you're looking for a late night bite. But I also love how massive their whole pizzas are! Seriously, carrying a pizza box home is such a welcome workout to build my appetite before devouring this pizza. It's a bit unwieldy to carry because it's so massive but so worth it.Highly recommend taking public transit or walking here because the restaurant is located at a 6 way chaotic intersection where there's usually a bunch of cars and traffic! It's literally right below the Damen stop on the blue line so super easy access but public transit.Ambience is super casual with cool murals on the wall and natural lighting. The service is always friendly!

I won't be coming back. Unfortunately after coming back here to try more items and exposed to their customer service more, I'm left very disappointed and irritated. First, there's a 15% service fee added at time of checkout and not reflected in their pricing. It just isn't honest. On top of that, the service is unhelpful. When asked for some tap water we were told they don't have any. So we have to buy some, and a Topo Chico for example is FIVE DOLLARS. Restaurants not having tap water is unacceptable to me. Then, our dine-in pizza slices were shoved into bags and smeared a bunch of ricotta EVERYWHERE. When asked for a knife or something to scrape that delicious stuff back onto our slices we were told that was not available...no sort of knives or something to "scrape". Guy just didn't seem to care or understand how silly and thoughtless the service was.

Pretty good pizza in wicker park it's different in a good way it's very thin pepperonie it's different small it's like cup char pepperonie it's not Chicago style but it's pretty good pizza want some good Chicago style pizza try JB ALBERTOS RICOBENNES this pizza will disappoint but try and stop by Pauline's gees pizza to try

The food was amazing. Personally, I think the best pizza I've ever had and then on top of that the manager gave us a free water bottle when I already planned buying it will definitely come back next time. I'm in Chicago.

I have to admit I walked past this place a million times... I am so happy I gave it a try.I love my thin crust Chicago style pizza to death but this NY style that PaulieGee has is fire . Vodka/Roni and The Big Bad Wolf " fuhgedaboutit"

I had a great slice here. The pizza was great and service was top notch.It should be noted there is a mandatory 15% service fee added to each check. The menu indicates that it is given directly to staff, which I appreciate, but I'm not a big fan of service fees.