ParAgon Deli Cafe
ParAgon Deli Cafe
Comes with bacon or sausage, hash browns and toast.
Toast, avocado, and grape tomatoes.
2 poached eggs, English muffins, hollandaise sauce and ham with hash-browns and fruit.
Eggs,bacon, Gruyere cheese,onions with a small side salad
Pan cooked eggs.
Meatless sandwich.
French ham, gruyere cheese, and bechamel sauce.
Pan cooked eggs.
Meatless sandwich.
French ham, gruyere cheese, bechamel sauce, and egg.
Egg,bacon,cheese,avocado,chipotle mayo served on a grilled Cia batta
Plain, maple and brown sugar, and apple and cinnamon.
Parmesan cheese, croutons.
Lettuce, fresh roast turkey, bacon, avocado, tomato, blue cheese, sliced egg.
Stuffed with tuna, chicken or egg salad on bed of lettuce.
Chopped fresh vegetables and greens.
Mixed greens, tuna, green beans, red potato, olives, red onion, tomato, sliced egg, and nicoise dressing.
Stuffed with tuna, chicken or egg salad on bed of lettuce.
Egg,Gruyere Cheese,Onion,Bacon, Pie Shell
Lettuce, tomato,beans,,corn, avocado,fritos,seasons ground beef,grated cheese,and catalina dressing
Ham,mortadella,,salami, provolone cheese,olive salad spread, lettuce,onion, tomato served on a grilled ciabatta roll
Served open face, roast turkey, bacon, lettuce, avocado, blue cheese dressing on rye bread.
French ham, gruyere cheese, and bechamel sauce.
Shave smoked German salami, smoked gouda.
Grilled peppers and onions, deli mustard, and smoked gouda cheese on a roll.
Genoa salami, mortadella, ham, provolone cheese, pepperoncinis, and Italian dressing.
Sirloin beef, mushrooms, onions, red peppers, hot pepper relish.
Shaved corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, 1000 Island dressing.
French ham, gruyere cheese, and bechamel sauce, fried egg.
Fresh roast turkey, bacon crumbled blue cheese avocado.
Ham, roast beef, linguica sausage, cheese, fried egg topped with francesinha sauce. Serve with fries
Steak,onions,Swiss cheese, avocado, chipotle mayo on a roll
Cooked on a rack over a grill. Smoked and cured beef.
Cold salad with shredded tuna.
Salt cured beef.
Cooked over dry heat.
Chopped eggs that have been mixed with seasoning and mayo.
Smooth soup with pureed tomatoes and basil.
Soup that is made with chicken, broth, noodles, and vegetables.
Stuffed with cheese and fried.
2 pieces. Quartered with sliced beats.
Fried potatoes.
Cooked in oil.
4 pieces. Halves.
Croque Monsieur Lunch
food, dessert, cupcakes
Aperol spritz
Menu April 2024
So unique
Outside
Inside restroom - light fixtures
Cute entrance
interior
Interior
Inside restroom which is always well-stocked
Menu April 2024
Nice deli restroom.
Tuna sandwich and tomato basil soup
Inside restroom... CLEAN and COZY
Rotten cake
California Cobb Salad Lunch- very tasty!
Fans
Love this wall mirror
Copper ceiling with rotating fans
Portuguese Francesinha Lunch
Homemade clam chowder
Tuna Nicoise salad
John K.
May 13, 2024
Best cookie ever! Seriously.The sandwich I got was above par, if I lived locally I'd return for lunch everyday. The people who work there makes it very family like more than a business. I would move to San Diego just to feel their kindness and eat delicious food for very very affordable prices. A must go if you're around.
Read More
MA R.
Feb 22, 2024
It's food you can't find anywhere else. The Francesinha Portugal is such a unique sandwich, and the Pennsylvania Dutch smoked sub melts in your mouth. The croque monsieur and croque madame sandwiches are out of this world. Outstanding service and location. I rank this place 5/5 on service, friendliness, quality of food and European flair ambiance.
Read More
Eileen Z.
Feb 19, 2024
The Ciabatta Breakfast Sandwich. Chipotle Mayo. O.M.G. Chef's kiss.As many of the best places are, ParAgon is tucked away in the corner of a nondescript strip mall. Bon Appetite!
Read More
Kelcey S.
Aug 12, 2024
Great place on Shelter Island. We Read reviews ahead of time. Did not disappoint. Ordered a mimosa and Bloody Mary. The Bloody Mary is the way to go. Huge and delicious. Also ordered the Madame Croquet breakfast sandwich and it was delicious. Crispy edges. Egg was cooked perfect and on top. Great place to eat!!!
Read More
Loredo L.
Jun 7, 2024
We couldn't pass up this 5 star sandwich deli spot near the Cabrillo national monument for lunch. The place is small with an old European vibe. The cashier was friendly but unfortunately didn't honor the 10% off Yelp coupon. The sandwiches tasted great and were perfectly seasoned. I really enjoyed my Paragon chipotle cheesesteak. The bread was baked somewhere else and wasn't the freshest. The royale cookie with chocolate chunks, macadamia nuts, and coconut was impressive. Definitely recommend
Read More
Preston G.
Aug 4, 2024
The food here was so good! Family owned and just delicious! We took our 1 year old there and everyone was so kind and said hi. We got the omelette and maple brown sugar oatmeal. 10/10 food and vibes!
Read More
Rose L.
Feb 28, 2024
This was a good stop for an easy lunch. Food was good and service was somewhat friendly. Ambiance is a little loud so I wouldn't go there for a quiet conversation but it was a good quick stop for what it is. Only gripe was that I don't think the soup is homemade. Seemed like it was from a can. I love good soup so that was a little disappointing. Otherwise the food tasted good, fresh and was a large portion.
Read More
Gregg Y.
Jul 26, 2023
Wonderful surprise find!This was my first time staying in the "Shelter Island Area" and Paragon quickly became the go-to place for breakfast. The breakfast sandwich was solid. Everything you could want in a breakfast sandwich.The eggs benedict was also incredible. In general eggs benedict can be a pretty underwhelming dish; however, when it's done right it can really pop. There's a combination of factors that make this eggs benedict exceptional. The hollandaise sauce, the perfectly cooked egg, a good salt to the ham. Masterfully done. I'd really like to come back here and try some of the other breakfast options as well as the lunch menu.
Read More
Arielle E.
Aug 16, 2024
Great little cafe! The staff is friendly, especially Cari. Very attentive and generous. Food was great as well!
Read More
Madalyn P.
Aug 9, 2024
Really good lunch! Cute little bistro tables outside. Place is busy, so have to wait a bit. They do a lot of takeout business. Tucked into a little shopping center, but worth finding it. Owner came out to be sure we were happywith our meal. Appreciated that.
Read More
