Papa Paul's Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta

I've been coming here and staying at the Wigwam for business for three years and Papa Paul's is the bomb. When I stay downtown, I eat at Bianco's and when I stay west side. I always go to Papa Paul's.TBH, I may like Papa Paul's better.

One easy thing I'd like to suggest to the owners to improve the pizza and it'll easily be a 5 star pizza joint.... I did takeout and baked and then broiled the pizza so it became crispy and a bit charred. After that, it was game over. I crave it bow like this and sadly I do not live nearby! Going to make the 45 minute drive out there and from now on I'll ask for it to be crispy/closer to well done. Pros1. Great flavor of the pizzas I've tried (Elote, Brooklyn and Ricotta and Sausage).2. Wide assortment of creative toppings and pie options Cons 1. Cook longer or broil to get it more crispy/charred so the crust isn't as soft, and then it'll be perfect!

Server was very friendly and accommodating to our needs. She made sure we had everything that would give us a first time experience.The atmosphere was quiet except for music. We were early before dinner crowd which gave us a more relaxing hour of conversation of our end of day conference.Avocado chopped salad: crispy texture lettuce, sweet with a tinge of tartness from the red wine vinegar dressing, roasted red pepper minced, chopped tomatoes, chopped cucumbers (slight crunchiness), and slices of avocado which gave a creaminess to everything. It was very tasty.My chicken broccoli Alfredo pasta was gluten free. They used zucchini noodles which was different and great! The noodles were super long!!! But had a slight crunchiness and needed to be cut, different, but healthy.Spinach, artichoke, Kalamata olives, and cauliflower pizza. Unbelievably tasty, the Kalamata olives added a little saltiness...to spinach, artichokes. I'm not sure what cheese was used, but it gave a creaminess to pizza. All in all, what a pleasant glutinous free option!Restaurant is behind WigWam Resort and Spa. They have gates that's fronting restaurants. You can get back in using your room key on scanner.Great time there...Ciao!

This is the kind of pizza place every neighborhood should have. Nice decor that makes eating in a pleasure. The service was fast and friendly. The menu had a good selection of pizza with a nice mixture of toppings that gives it a gourmet slant. I like brick oven pizza and mine was done with a nice crust and toppings were plentiful.

Really charming place and friendly staff. Our server got a bit overwhelmed but it got really busy while we were there - people must really like this place! The Caesar salad was very good with fresh crispy romaine. I do wish the Caesar came tossed. Maybe something to request. The pepperoni pizza did not disappoint, not overly spicy, excellent thin crispy crust and flavorful stretchy cheese. The sausage ricotta pizza has an olive oil base, a nice variation and the sausage was good with just a hint of fennel. The tiramisu is a new favorite with a creamy top and moist but not soggy middle. We will definitely be back. Q

For a first time visit it was a hidden gem. Thin crust and crumbled sausage! Delicious. Next time we would share a salad and get dessert.

Love coming here for delicious food and great date vibes. The strawberry and bacon salad is a tasty unique salad. The Brooklyn style pizza is my go to great sauce and always made right.

Impromptu dinner on a Thursday with my mom and son! This place has been on my list to try. It was busy but a steady busy, not an overwhelming busy. Our waitress was attentive and knowledgeable. I couldn't decide between the bruschetta or burrata and she quickly recommended the burrata. Great suggestion, it was really good. My son devoured his spaghetti. Great serving of pasta and three huge meatballs. My mom had a pizza. She said it was good too. I had her rate the restaurant and she gave it 5 stars also. This will now be our go to Italian spot. I'm eager to try their other menu items.

Super chill vibe kinda reminded me of the bar on a show called Cheers. Felt like a place you could gather with friends, family or maybe colleagues.

Great cozy local pizza restaurant. Service was exceptional and have made this a go to place.