West Orange Creamery

Love the small town feel, lots of flavor options and variations of classic ice cream concoctions. Shakes, affogato, cups and cones. I also like the addition of having the option to spike my shake... yes please. Anywho it's a nice vibe w tasty cream and a cozy feel. I hope it sticks around even tho everywhere seems to be a chain nowadays.

Super cute old-fashioned ice cream parlor! They have a very extensive menu & great service. I dropped by on my birthday, and the server there was very sweet and surprised me with a candle in my cookies & cream ice cream cone. It was very thoughtful & made my night! We also got the cappuccino crunch flavor in a cone, which was delicious.

Cute locally owned ice cream shop with lots of variety on the menu and a cozy vibe. There are games available to play together while enjoying your ice cream and a seating area with old fashioned character. The staff is friendly as well. Ice cream is Hershey's and they have traditional side fountain options as well. We got scoops, dipped cones, and a peanut butter chocolate sundae. We had a group of about 10 but were served efficiently and plenty of space to sit and chat while the kids in the group played some of the games.

We had a nice time at the West Orange Creamery recently. I wrestled with giving a higher rating but I couldn't give it 4-5 stars for two main reasons. The first was that if a place is called a "creamery" I'm immediately getting excited and thinking that they make their own ice cream and I'm gonna see some cows. But they just sold Hersheys ice cream which was tasty, but not original. Second, I'm still salty as I got considerably less ice cream than my friends due to differences in who was scooping, and feeling cheated over ice cream is never a good feeling. Otherwise, the place was clean, and I really appreciated the 1950's soda fountain vibe that they we're going for. There was tons of seating, and the milkshakes were enormous which is fun. So if you're looking for Hershey's ice cream, but a variety of flavors, West Orange Creamery may be for you.

Service was fast and ice cream was delicious. I had the brown butter bourbon truffle and cappuccino crunch.

Great place with really friendly staff. Ice cream was really good. Nice atmosphere. Evan took great care of me with quite the delightful creamy surprise!

Stop by for some ice cream cravings. Place does not offer free samples so you'll just have to like the ice cream that you are getting. Plenty of flavors to choose from. I got a cup size of the coffee flavored ice cream. It was pretty decent and was not overly powerful. Good consistency. Plenty of tables to enjoy their ice cream and they do have board games. Check in and they have a free waffle cone offer. Great local ice cream shop.

West Orange Creamery was a cute pit stop with great flavors, fun menu items, and a cute photo op against the back wall. Whenever you check in on Yelp, you get a free waffle cone upgrade that they make and roll to order. I also chose the brownie and caramel swirl flavor, which was delicious! They do not offer free cups of water, so you would have to buy a bottle or order one of their specialty drinks if you get thirsty.

Great little shop right by the house. Kinda transports you back a little. They do malts as well as shakes, cones, and even boozy ice cream treats. It's always a good choice after watching a movie and the theater in the back.

This place is a HIDDEN GEM. We got the Nana's Love sundae but substituted with the coconut almond chocolate ice cream and it was amazing. The rum cake is incredible and I still think about it often. The cherry lime Rickey was also good but fair warning it's not overly sweet. The staff is also SO NICE!!!!