The Original Anthony's NY Pizza
The Original Anthony's NY Pizza
Meatball Parm Sub
Fettuccine Alfredo
Stromboli
Large Calzone
Lasagna
NY Cheesecake
Pasta Fagioli Soup
Philly Cheesesteak Sub
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Baked Ziti
Cheese Pizza
Cannoli
Hawaiian Pizza
Garlic Bread
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Parm Entree
Mozzarella Sticks
Spaghetti with Meatballs
pasta, food
Chicken Wings
Lunchtime!
Spaghetti and meatballs
Spaghetti and meatballs
drink
Christine S.
Feb 14, 2025
I've lived in walking distance of the pizza spot for almost 4 years. I think I got take out here once for a party, but this is my first time sitting down to dine.It's typical to most pizza spots. A few tables, a large to go area, the shakers of Parmesan cheese on every table.It's nice and cozy, nostalgic. The service was really good. The waitress was very friendly and polite.The pizza was really good and nice and greasy and cheesy, as it should be!We also got pasta soup, which was extremely hard and flavorful ! This is one of the best soup I've ever had!I'll be back!
Read More
Jalim A.
Feb 18, 2025
Great Service, Friendly Staff, Fresh made to Order !! Always great !!! Never disappoint! Oit hays off to Chef ! Like Always my over the seas family came to visit and our FIRST DINNER AT THE BEST ANTHONY'S PIZZA !!!!
Read More
Cyara F.
Mar 3, 2025
I've never been disappointed when my family orders from this location. The food is so tasty any item you choose you can't go wrong! My favorites have been their pizza, salads, and this location has become my go to place for wings!!!
Read More
Dan L.
Mar 1, 2025
Had the Extravaganza pizza with salad a garlic knots today. Taste was very good; fresh ingredients. Also service was good. I recommend but remember the 'single slices' here are large. It's worth it!
Read More
Steven F.
Dec 29, 2023
When we arrived, it was fairly empty since it was after the holiday so we received quick service from Maria (who was wonderful, by the way). It was fairly quiet and the place was clean. I was happy to find out they have gluten-free pizza available but was thoroughly disappointed that they wanted to charge $23 for a 12" pie! I recognize that getting a gluten free pizza usually cost a bit more than the regular pizza (usually $2 - $3 more) but an approximately 43% more is outrageous! My wife decided to try the Greek salad with grilled chicken and I order 2 slices one being pepperoni and mushrooms. Even though they didn't have Greek dressing for their Greek salad, my wife opted for the creamy Italian which was pretty good. I also ordered a side of French fries which was wonderfully cooked fresh and crispy with the right amount of seasoning!I have been to this place several times before and loved the pizza here. Both with a whole pie as well as individual slices. I wish I could the same this time around. It seems that the mushroom and mozzarella cheese was thrown on the slice and was put in the oven long enough for the cheese to barely melt! The taste was meh but at least it wasn't greasy. Maybe the pizza tastes better when it's straight out of the oven versus reheated.
Read More
Dawn E.
Jun 20, 2024
Food was absolutely delicious...I had the stuffed shells w/ garlic knots and a side salad with there homemade vinaigrette, while my husband had there spaghetti w/ meatballs and a slice of there meat lovers pizza, portions where nice and we definitely had leftovers. Service was awesome from Yolie , and we never needed for anything.very clean environment which is huge for me and the decor was an Italian layout with lite pleasant music playing ... totally recommend going if you in the area
Read More
Jeff M.
Jan 19, 2025
Spaghetti and meatball or maybe it had 2 for $14!...too much for me! Am still looking for a good mom and pop Italian restaurant with good simple comfort food at a reasonable price
Read More
Sonja H.
Aug 21, 2024
My favorite plain cheese pizza. Hands down. Been coming here for years. Though there's some new faces I don't recognize the service is still good. Food is delicious. And the ambiance is simple and cozy. A great place to get some pizza.
Read More
J T.
Mar 2, 2025
I am leaving another review to verify and confirm the validity of my previous review. After an attempt at allowing redemption, I stand behind the 1-Star Review. It is sad and shameful that the Business Owner would comment and accuse me of posting a "fake" review. Why? Hard pass on this place.
Read More
Natalia R.
Feb 24, 2025
To call this NY pizza is wild. Dominos is fine dinning compared to this. It was so soggy. I Picked up a slice in the car and all the toppings fell off. I ate it because I just moved and have no groceries. My drive home was 10 minutes and by minute 4 you could feel the bottom of the box was wet. The sauce was runny, the vegetables were HUGE and RAW. Im not even lactose intolerant and I know I'm gonna have the bubble guts later. I have never left a bad review ever but this had to be done.
Read More
