Rainbow bagel! When you say "cream cheese," they mean it!!
Morning cinnamon raisin bagel!
Lots of New York City references
people sitting at tables in a restaurant
You can see Cinderella Castle at a distance from here.
Bagels to go
outside
Salao
two cars parked in front of a store
Exterior
people eating at a fast food restaurant
interior
Owner gave us a treat when finding out first timers and drove 20 minutes to get here.
bagel, bagels, food
the inside of a bagel
interior
Interior where you order
Lox cream cheese yum
Inside decor
Lambreta
The coffee cake... after I cut away (and happily ate) a piece.
Entrance photo
Annie N.
Feb 14, 2025
Stuff a Bagel is our local bagel spot for authentic NY bagels. This is family-owned location that also has another shop in Naples. This has really been where we come to get bagels or breakfast. It has been gaining more popularity, and I have heard more people talking about it. This location is in Winter Garden, very close to us. It is also directly across from the cast member parking lot for Magic Kingdom. I do think this is a great location, grab breakfast or lunch and head into work. They do offer a discount for Disney Cast Members, which is great. They are very small, with only a few tables inside and a couple outside. Most people tend to get it to go, which we always do. We did eat here once, but honestly, it is so busy, it feel very crowded if you are sitting down. They do serve breakfast and lunch. They are not open all day. Their food is very similar to a bagel shop you would find in New York. They are truly some of the best bagels I have ever had. They really do have a great variety as well including your classics, pumpernickel, salt, rainbow, everything pumpernickel, and more. I would say there are about 20 different flavors. If you are going more towards lunch time, there might not be every flavor available to you. We have been here a few times and usually come on the weekends. I do honestly forget that they have lunch and am going to try and go there when I am working at home. It is much better food options. MY husband usually orders the Lox Deluxe, which is basically a lox bagel but very good. He also enjoys the Veggie Omelet, which has 3 egg whites, assorted veggies, Swiss cheese and a whole wheat bagel or whichever bagel you want. The last item he really enjoys is the breakfast burrito which has 2 scrambled eggs with peppers, onions, sausage and cheese. I usually order the same thing - pumpernickel bagel with cream cheese and bacon. This is my favorite combination for a bagel. If you want your bagel toasted, you do need to let them know, it is not automatic. Overall, this is a great place for a quick breakfast or even a lunch. The line is usually long, especially on the weekends, but the staff is so great, they are so friendly, they are quick, and you never end up waiting long to order or to get your food. I love that it is family owned as well! Their coffee is great, continuingly making fresh coffee. I highly recommend stopping by.
Read More
Abe A.
Jan 16, 2025
Stuff a Bagel is gaining more and more popularity and it's so exciting!! This is a bagel shop located in Winter Garden. It is very close to us, only about a 10-minute drive. I will say this is super convenient if you work for Disney as it is located directly behind the cast member parking lot for Magic Kingdom parking. It is a very small location but really produces some great food. They are open for breakfast and lunch, I believe they close around 2pm. Their food is very similar to a bagel shop you would find in New York. They are so good and have such a great variety of bagel options. To actually have a proper bagel place in Orlando is fantastic. To have this near our home, is even better! Their bagels are truly outstanding. Soft, warm, freshly made... everything you'd want. We have been here a few times in the last few weeks, and I have tried a few different items. I usually order the Lox Deluxe, which is always good. I have also tried the Veggie Omelet, which has 3 egg whites, assorted veggies, Swiss cheese and a whole wheat bagel or whichever bagel you want. I have also tried the breakfast burrito which has 2 scrambled eggs with peppers, onions, sausage and cheese. Both of these are really good, but I prefer to get something with their bagels. My wife usually orders the same, pumpernickel bagel with cream cheese and bacon. It is her absolute favorite. If you want your bagel toasted, you do need to let them know, it is not automatic. Overall, this is a great place for a quick breakfast or even a lunch. The line is usually long, especially on the weekends, but the staff is so great, they are quick, and you never end up waiting long to order or to get your food. Their coffee is great, continuingly making fresh coffee. I highly reccomend stopping by. Aces!
Read More
Brenda T.
Jan 12, 2025
The variety of bagels is amazing. They clearly are from New York and the bagels, don't disappoint. They are so fresh, that even without toasting, they are soft to chew into. Ahhhhhh!The location is quite quaint (small) so it does get packed, as just a skip and a hop from Magic Kingdom's cast parking lot. They service is quick, however, and the wait - minimal. I had to have the rainbow bagel - and the maple walnut cream cheese - DREAMYYY! Perfect spot for a great NY sandwich and bagels to go! Loved it and will return!
Read More
Tharin W.
Jan 4, 2025
Located about as close as you can possibly get to Magic Kingdom, this New York bagel spot has actually good bagels. No thin, not weak on cream cheese. This are good sized bagels with solid flavor. The loaded fries were good, we might not get them again but they were worth a try. There is ample seating indoors and out and nice, quick service.
Read More
Maria T.
Jan 4, 2025
Nothing like a morning Bagel here in Winter Garden! Really on of the best places in Orlando to get an authentic NY bagel... service is always excellent, and we love the options for bagels and cream cheese, plus any breakfast sandwiches! Our favorite definitely is the memorabilia of the NY sports teams, the posters on the wall, the cool items, and just the vibe of the place!
Read More
Allison R.
Sep 17, 2024
The inside is quite small and cramped, so I wouldn't recommend eating in. We went on a Saturday morning around 9:30 and there were only a few other people in line. The lady at the counter was very friendly, and our food came out quick and piping hot.We both tried an egg and cheese sandwich, one with bacon and one with sausage, on an egg everything bagel. I had never had an egg bagel before. I was told it would be softer and a bit sweeter than a regular bagel, but honestly I found no difference in the flavor and was slightly disappointed since it was so talked up. The sandwich was good and the bagel was good, but I've had better bagels and better sandwiches elsewhere.
Read More
Laura G.
Jun 23, 2024
So glad I found a bagel place that is almost tastes and feels like from NY! Ambience and staff are straight formNY and first place in Florida I found my favorite..egg everything. Be sure toTell them to toast your bagel or they won't. They need to fix their menu board. Prices are all outdated. Otherwise, it's clean, and great food! On a Sunday get there early if you want the bagels you want. They were wiped out around 11 when I went.
Read More
Amy L.
Oct 16, 2024
Small location in a strip mall. Saw an online reel of their special Italian cookie cream cheese and needed to try it. Staff seemed rushed, not overly attentive and I was the only one in line. Ordered a toasted bagel with the Italian cream cheese which was about $5. The bagel wasn't toasted or even warm and the cream cheese was very basic with minimal Italian cookie flavor. We are not from the area and had driven out of way to come here, so quite disappointed. Will likely not try again.
Read More
Christian M.
Jan 22, 2025
Owner & staff were very welcoming & friendly. And the food was delicious. We got a bacon egg and cheese bagel and the lox deluxe and both were great. 10/10 come by
Read More
Michelle T.
Feb 18, 2025
Just ordered the Pastrami Bagel with mustard on a Garlic roll and it was absolutley delicious!
Read More