Garlic knots
Medium with sausage, bacon, pepperoni & mushroom with light sauce. Fantastic pie!!!
Menu
Store Front
Menu
Burns wings and thin slices , parmesan cheese in some slices ... would not recommend it.
Front door.
Pepperoni
Scrumptiousness!
This is the "lightly baked pizza I ordered".
Cold, sloppy , 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 sausage and onion pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
pizza, food
Dry cold soggy pizza
Menu
Large Pepperoni Onion Pizza
My slice of my ginormous magherita Margherita Pizza!!!!!!! Amazing!!!!
What's in this photo? Certainly not toppings.
Hello Paige, We apologize for the issue. When we received the order from DoorDash is said left side, so we only added topping on half.
Pepperoni Pizza
Wrong pizza
outside
Veggie goodness
Pepperoni Pizza
Steve M.
Aug 20, 2024
We were out shopping and looking for a lunch spot and came across this pizza place. Said NY pizza so being from NY had to try it. The place is rather small with like one standup table , otherwise not really anywhere else to eat. Caught a special for 2 slices one topping and a drink for like 7 bucks. The server made us a pie as we needed two of the specials and had it out quick. Pizza wasn't bad. Crust could have been a bit more crispy but otherwise the rest of it was very good. And decent size as well. Worth a try for a decent slice at a good price.
Read MoreAndrew S.
Dec 31, 2024
Well that was a disappointment. Lackluster taste aside, it looks like they're having a shortage of toppings, because I ordered an XL Hawaiian that had maybe a dozen crumbs of pineapple and ham.And it's worth noting, of you order on your phone the default size is limited to XL only. I suppose it at least qualifies as "New York" style, but I'm rally only assuming based on other reviews.
Read MoreRachel Macie H.
Sep 21, 2023
Now this is exactly what I would call a hole in the wall as well as a perfect example of what you'd find in a good slice shop in the city as it's literally just a front door and a register inside along with a pizza kitchen doing things right!So one random rainy night it was all about some pie and what better place to grab some on the way home than this little spot as it was a quick in and out as we called ahead for our pizza and it was ready upon arriving!So we ordered a large pepperoni and onion pizza and let me say it didn't disappoint as it was very delicious from start to finish with a yummy sauce, crust, and toppings making for scrumptious at every bite!Overall there's not to much to go on here as it's just a chill spot to grab a pizza so with that said I'm sure I'll stop by here again at some point because it was just that yummy!
Read MoreMarisa V.
Sep 4, 2023
Came here after a long day at Disney. We wanted something quick and yummy. I came across this pizza spot on Yelp and thought we could try it out.We pulled in and found the business quickly and ordered. We were told it be about a 20 minute wait which we were ok with. We ordered a small pepperoni pizza. The small was four slices and was just enough for the two of us. They had a small table inside that we were able to sit at and the cashier brought our food and napkins over to us which was really nice of him. We were pleasantly surprised by the pizza. It came out nice and crunchy yet chewy in the middle. I enjoyed our crispy the edges were and the cheese and pepperoni weren't too salty or too much. I'd love to come back and try the garlic knots next time!
Read MoreAnna K.
Apr 27, 2024
I ordered a small pizza and a wedge salad. They gave me some random salad that I didn't order....the pizza has a weird taste as well. Won't be coming back here. Was very upset about my salad.
Read MoreGlenn K.
Aug 10, 2024
This was a door dash delivery that really detracted from the product Slices NY provided. Both the delivered pizza and meatball roll were disasters in a box. It looked like the entire order had been dropped on its side pushing everything into the corner. It's a shame, the food that was edible was pretty good and the marinara sauce was delicious. The pizza was missing the familiar NY pizza oil drip but the crust was good. I will order from the again but next time I'll pick it up myself.
Read MoreTina M M.
Apr 27, 2024
I'm not sure what to make of this. After a long tiring trip, we were told this was the place that was still open. We ordered a few items on the menu especially awaiting of the pizza. The pizza has to be under the heat lamps because the sauce was no where to be found and the cheese was disintegrated. Then to my surprise was an added gratuity and service charge. What is that about? If you were closing soon you shouldn't have taken our order.
Read MoreAriel V.
Sep 5, 2023
The spot looks like hole in the wall. Very basic inside but right to the point. Service was good considering they made a fresh pie for my two slices. Taste was great, and good crunch on the crust.
Read MoreAustin D.
Oct 31, 2024
Ordered through UberEats and Slices forgot an entire pizza on my order and told me they didn't remember my order. They had so many orders they didn't know. Then they told me I could come pick up the missing pizza, but after I paid and tipped my driver 25%. The one pizza we did receive tasted horrible.. Also every app you try to order off of has a different menu for them.
Read MoreDaniela D.
Jan 24, 2025
10/10!!!! Amazing pizza! We are originally from California and we wanted to try some pizza. We ordered 2 large pizzas, garlic knots, wings and all was very tasteful and everyone enjoyed the food. The guy at the cashier very friendly/helpful and the service was quick being that there was only 2 workers he said to give him 15 mins and he was on the dot. We have no complaints. If we come back this will be the place.
Read More