Sal's Pizza
Sal's Pizza
Bruschetta
Cheese New York Pizza
Peperoni New York pizza
Check you pizza so you don't get stabbed in the mouth like we did.
Garlic Knots
Cheese New York Pizza
Cheese New York Pizza
4 Cheese pizza
Garlic knots
Stuffed Chicago supreme pizza
The pizza is stuffed and all you can taste is the cheese and green bell pepper. Minimal sauce, sauage and pepperoni.
The middle of a stuffed Chicago Supreme pizza.
Raw chicken! And not just the one piece the entire order! Never again!!!!
pizza, food
menu
Hot cafe from Sal's Cafe shop open 8 am to 10 pm
menu
"Chicago deep dish pizza"
Chicken and veggies
Chicago stuff supreme pizza
Pizza and pasta
Cheese Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
Ham and cheese bagel
Breakfast menu
Debbie O.
Nov 13, 2023
The best pasta & pizza ..so good you be hooked.The staff is amazing and very friendly.
Read More
Kevin M.
Jun 4, 2022
It was our first time ordering from Sal's the other night. We got 2 Chicago deep dish pizzas one meat lovers and one steak and they both came with the pizza savers upside down and when pulled out took the topping with it, mangling the pizzas. Somebody new over there? The spacers are suppose to be flat side up. Needless to say one person got stabbed in the mouth because they didn't see it there. Do better Sal's....The pizza was tasty however it's not anything like Chicago deep dish. Far to much dough. It was like eating pizza and the having a leftover french bread roll after words. Seriously, I could have made a hoagie for 8 people out of the crusts. I know you can't make Chicago pizza in Florida because of the humidity and the difference in the water but to call this Chicago pizza is an insult to Chicago.The only reason I gave 2 stars instead of 1 is the pizza was tasty.
Read More
Charlie R.
Jun 23, 2023
Not real sure why all the negative reviews. This one of a limited number of pizza places open on Sunday. The owners are from Italy. Great NY pizza thin & crusty. The owners are real nice, they have outdoor seating and located in old Town part of Auburndale right off the circle. Defintely a hidden gem in Polk County FL. Great tasting pizza and desserts.
Read More
Michael J.
Dec 22, 2022
I've lived in Florida, from NJ, since 1980 and I've found it hard to find genuine New York pizza here. I've made my own since 1985. I've been burned by many so-called New York style pizza joints. I tried Sal's because they sell by the slice and I don't like to pay for a whole pizza and then be disappointed.Honestly, the pizza was pretty good and almost replicates real NY pizza. The crust was very good. I would consider going back. On the other hand, I'm very satisfied with my own homemade pizza considering that my 16" pizza loaded with pepperoni and mushrooms cost me $3 to make.
Read More
M G.
Jul 29, 2023
What a disappointment! What a disgrace! What a total shameful embarrassment to the Italian people!!!My family and decided to give it a try ( if only we knew!). We entered the place and it was empty, but since it was around 2:30ish we thought it was passed lunchtime rush, so we sat down and ordered a cheese pizza, a pepperoni pizza, a penne pulcinella , some garlic rolls and a pasta fagioli soup. Tables were very sticky, lack of cleanliness there! The table where we were it was formed of square tables uneven, no one table was equal, it looked like an unpaved and uneven road. In fact, when the drinks arrived almost all of them spilled out on the tables. Pizzas arrived and besides been burned on the bottoms ( burned with filthiest oven burns, because, if it had been a wood burn burn it would have been delicious, but it was filthy by lack of cleaning the oven!) they had no taste at all! How can you messed up a pizza? I tell you how, by not putting the right spices on it, they lacked of salt, of flavors they were totally bland! Let me continue with the penne pulcinella, a joke by itself, it was watery, with a funny taste and no seasoning at all! But it gets better! At the time of the soup, the only taste it had was the one of a tap water, which obviously was the main and only ingredient, you could see it was mainly water. Oh, and the garlic rolls were as hard as a rock. You could have slammed those rolls on the walls and you would have needed to call someone to fix those walls. And let me tell you about the guy that managed/ owner this place! He was grumpy, unfriendly, and with the will to do nothing! I just don't understand why people even bothered to give 3 stars since they don't deserve not even one. And most of all, why are they lying giving good reviews about a place that is not good at all! I will definitely never recommend this place ever! What a shame for the entire Italian Country, heck, in this case it's probably the entire hemisphere!!!P.S. unfortunately we didn't take a picture of the pasta fagioli.
Read More
Earl K.
Aug 2, 2023
Was really Good food it came to us hot from delivery It was our first time flavor was different that the chain stores I would order here again pricey but doable
Read More
Marilynn B.
Feb 5, 2025
Great service food was served hot and plentiful 6 people ate different pasta dishes and loved them all I had Sals chicken yummy
Read More
Claudia W.
Jun 5, 2024
Sorry Sal, we're from Chicago not New York!! Pizza had no flavor and barely anything toppings. It was HOT inside with only one little window air conditioner. One plus was their live music, they were great!! Won't be back, not even for take out!
Read More
Joe S.
Mar 19, 2024
Best pizza in Florida. This is real pizza, properly baked. The only thing holding me back from 5 stars is that they are skimpy with their ingredients even if you order double pepperoni it isn't uncommon to find a slice without a piece of pepperoni on it. This is not to take away from how good the pizza is.
Read More
Sophie R.
Mar 12, 2024
Super friendly staff. Had a late night order and they were willing to make our food and greeted us with hospitality. Was my first time visiting this town!
Read More
