Real New York Pizza

I ordered a large pepperoni pizza today, Friday 22 July with an order of garlic knots.I was so disappointed!!!The pizza crust was burnt & the sauce was so salty!I will never buy from this restaurant or encouraged anyone to buy from them.

I used to enjoy coming here but after my last experience I will definitely not be returning. First of all when I walked in the girl on the register didn't even acknowledge me for a solid two minutes. She's was on her phone and eating a cup of what appeared to be ice cream.Finally she says hi and I place my order, after paying she proceeded to move her hair back, touch her bare skinned midsection, and then grab a box for the pizza. She then took the pizza peel, and put two slices in the box and sent me on my way. Immediately I knew the pizza was cold after touching the box and then touching the pizza. I then went back to the counter and asked an employee politely if he could heat up the pizza because it was stone cold. He sucked his teeth and threw the pizzas in the oven and walked to the back. All three employees were back there eating the cups of what we'll call ice cream while prepping food! We're in the middle of a pandemic and they don't even have the decency to to practice proper hygiene. I witnessed who appeared to be the manager in charge lick his fingers then go back to making pizza dough! Never have I ever seen such a blatant disregard for people's safety, especially during a time like this! They have absolutely no shame in it. Absolutely disgusting and awful customer service and food safety practices. I will be reporting this to the health department and will be following up. What happened to customer service and food safety? I will never come back to this establishment and I hope all who see this review are wary of coming here.

A disgrace to be called real New York pizza. You would be better off making it yourself. Honestly i never expected pizza was this bad until I tried this place. Chuck E. Cheese, litlle Caesar's, pizza hut aren't even that good but somehow is better than this place. Wouldn't recommend. COLD MARINARA SAUCE that they claim is fresh. You would be better off saving that money than coming to eat here. The toppings on my pizza were all falling off ITS NOT LIKE THAT IN NEW YORK. Your buggin if u think this place is worth even a star. They are garbage never going back hope they go out of business. Disgrace to New York change that name ASAP!!!!

I don't understand why anyone below has stated this is amazing pizza. The pizza is flavorless, with bland dough and sauce that tastes like it's out of the can. They have a 50 cent up charge on all sauces including in the garlic knots that don't come with garlic coincidentally. Look elsewhere.

Their pizza is yummy. Also it was a big pizza that me and my coworkers spilt the check and for their largest pizza come to 23 dollars which is not bad and it was good and huge slices. If you want cheap and affordable pizza and delicious this is the place for you. We usually get their pizza every other Friday.

Horrible rob you of your money charge your more taxes then legally allow to service it's horrible cool is horrible place is dirty and just look at what they gave me then and ask the lady how come it was 7.01 I asked her how much was the taxes she said 6.5 % 4.99+ 1.50 and 6.5% of taxes it's not 7.01 robbing people right to their faces bad business practice

I just pick up the most ugly pizza! hard salty ! high price x nothing!!!I do never come back for another food from the store!!! Please don't Let New York pizza so bad!! done

Have ordered several times for office function and have always been well served. Mindy is delightful to deal with and offered us good prices and added goodies for our events. Will continue to use and enjoy their pies.Cathy - Beekman1802 Orlando

Tried for 1st time. Calzone has oodles of cheese pepperoni in just about every bite, sauce isn't just tomato sauce its tasty. The lasagna is meaty and cheesy and just what I was looking for. Did get the garlic knots, not as good will do garlic bread next go. Will order from them again this is enough food for a good 4 days,. Besides its too hot in FL to be exercising.

I want to start off by saying that this is the closest pizza shop to me and I will never come here again. After this place was recommended to me, I called and placed an order for a Large pie, half pepperoni, well done. Mayra who was the lady who took my order sounded as if she knew what she was doing, but soon I learned that I was wrong. Mayra tells me that it would be about 25-30 mins. Understandable timing. My pizza arrives and I tip the delivery guy. I open my box to find that my pizza was NOT well done, it was undercooked and I was charged for extra pizza, WHEN I never even asked for that. I call the place back and Mayra answers. I tell her of my concern and she tells me that I needed to give her the pie back and she will make me a new one. I tell her that she charged me extra for something I didn't ask for and she had no response on how to fix my issue. I tell her that I am in a rush because I had to be at a doctors appointment and she tells me that the only way she can help me was by picking up the old pie and she would replace it with a new one. I asked if she can just have the delivery guy bring some wings or something in place of THEIR error and she tells me NO. I then ask for a manager or someone else I can speak to, and she tells me that she is the one in charge. I ask her for the GM or owners name and she tells me she doesn't know. I questioned on how she works for an establishment and doesn't know the name of the GM or owner. She then tells me his name is Giovanni. I asked if I can speak to him, and she tells me that he isn't there and she doesn't know when he will be back, that she doesn't know his schedule. I THEN DRIVE to the establishment and bring the pie of pizza with me. I get there and tell her I want a refund for the pizza and for the tip i placed on the bill. She tells me that there is a pie in the oven for me. And I advised her that I didn't ask her to make me a new pie. I want a refund. She then looks at her coworker Darwin and asked if she can give me a refund. He approves my refund. I found it very weird that she was the one in charge when Giovanni wasn't there but could not approve a refund for me. After that, what took me by surprise was that SHE DIDN'T KNOW HOW TO COMPLETE the refund. I asked Darwin if he knew when Giovanni would be in, and he tells me that he will be in the following day and that he will pass my information along to him, so i can receive a call back. Darwin was very apologetic, and understanding. I don't get how a manager could not have these same qualities. I do want to end this review at the fact that when I walked into the establishment, Miss Mayra herself has a shirt that read "La Toxica" (The Toxic One"). Very unprofessional! I will never go back because the way Mayra handles things as a manager ! I would happily drive 25 mins to Bronx Pizza and get REAL NEW YORK PIZZA. Avoid this place. It's in a gas station anyways. Ghetto.