Perrotti's NY Deli

So so goooood! $47-ish for 5 sandwiches. Ordered 2 hot pastramis, classic Italian, hot New Yorker, and roast beef. I can't speak on the other sammies other than the hot pastrami. But my sandwich was soooo good! Didn't hear any complaints about the other sammies so maybe they're good to? Lol. I ordered on the phone prior to arriving to pick them up right when they opened at 11. When I got there I ordered an extra sammie which didn't take long for them to make. A couple of other people in the shop sitting down and enjoying their lunch. My hot pastrami was so good. I did customize it a bit to my liking and the lady on the phone was more than gracious enough to put up with all the orders of the different situations and the additions and the allergy restriction. Always so appreciative when an establishment can accommodate. Clearly didn't get pics of the sandwiches as it seemed that everyone devoured it. Definitely recommend and will be back when we are in the area!

Hear about this place from a Facebook group where they were raving about it. They weren't wrong. The Pastramageddon - Hot pastrami and pepper jack cheese with hot cherry peppers, jalapeños, 1000 island, and (minus the creamy horseradish ) on toasted Rye was outstanding. The place is hoppin' at lunch time but a definite winner in our book. Friendly family running the place and service was quick in light of how busy they were.

I've been going to Sue and the boys for years, and it makes me so happy to see them continually doing well. Though I haven't been in a while, upon entering to pick-up an order I placed over the phone (which is always the way to order), Sue recognized my face and knew my order. What I appreciate about Perrotti's is the quality in everything they do. My go to sandwiches are the Grosvenor Square, the Perrotti Bros with Turkey or the Godfather. All are so different but the quality in the meats just makes each so delicious. Inside can be a little chaotic (if you're ordering in person, you first do so in the back of the restaurant and pay at the front after). I always do takeout and the sandwiches travel well. I love that they place hot sandwiches in a warmer till you arrive to pickup your sandwich. Love having one of my favorite sandwich spots 10 minutes from my place!

This was my first time here in quite some time. Used to spend a little of time in this. Neck of the woods for various reasons. Glad I stopped in. It felt like going home (NJ for me). From the signage in the back of the store which presents the menus of available deli sandwiches and wraps. To the friendliest folks running the joint! Had a great conversation with the man making sandwiches exchanging quick stories of various places in the Garden State.Oh and the food is just what you want in a deli. Sandwiches, meats, salads, assorted goodies. I also got some Tuscan Pizza Bagels. The lady behind the counter raved about them.Great deli!

The food was good, family owned and very welcoming. I had the Perrotti burger which was roast beef with cheese lettuce tomatoes pickles ketchup mustard and mayo. Surprisingly it tastes like a burger, the kaiser roll was lightly toasted and the flavors all went together.It is a casual atmosphere where you go to the back menu is posted you order at the counter and pay at the other end. They get their bagels in from New York,they are flown in frozen and they warm them up for you or you can purchase them frozen.

One of our favorite local spots! The food is consistently delicious and fresh. Service is always friendly and quick. Highly recommend!

Best Local Sub Shop!I've been eating subs here for years and never been disappointed! The food is always so fresh. I usually get the American supreme and everything on it tastes so amazing together. I love the macaroni salad as well.Everytime I eat inside the staff is always so friendly and service is quick it's also one of my go-to options on DoorDash!Definitely recommend!

First time coming here absolutely fantastic!! First time trying the pastrami I had the rachel and it was excellent!! Service was excellent!! I will be coming back that's for dam sure I absolutely love it here

I'm not a big sub person and Perrotti's was great! I ordered off the kid's menu to try since it was my first time. I came in during lunch time and the place was busy. With the kid's meal you get a bag of chips and a drink but nothing fancy and it was small but filling enough for me. They didn't skimp out on the cheese and I did request pesto mayo which was flavorful. I would get a 6 inch sub/meal next time and I do want to try a bagel as well.

It was a busy when we arrived. The staff was veey polite and even though they were crowded, they did not make you feel rushed. It was very delicious and the portions are very generous!