Park Ave Pizza

Great cheap bite if you're in the Winter Park area. Great pizza and great price at $9 for two big slices. Staff was very friendly and efficient. Inside is a little dingy pizza place, nothing fancy but who needs that?

My Go-To pizza place on the avenue for a quick slice of pizza for lunch! Service is okay; nothing to rave about but the order is perfection every time. I'm not sure if they have AC here as sometimes it's quite warm inside on a summer day. The red pepper and Parmesan is located in a difficult to see location (in my opinion - I'm short so idk if I just can't see it! Lol ). Decor and ambiance is consistent for the style of the restaurant as its appearance is a "quick NY style pizza" and not what I would deem a date night kind of place. Their Bianca pizza is perfection but I also enjoy some of their other slices which you can add toppings to by the slice at lunch time. It's all soooo yummy. Their subs are great too

A solid choice for pizza in Winter Park. It's a 2 or 3 person operation, and service can be spotty at times. I've generally had good luck but sometimes had to wait to order; other times, I've seen people need to check on their orders. But, the pizza is good every time. The crust is a good mix of crispy and chewy and there are a good variety of toppings. The inside is pretty basic, but has a good amount of seating, typical of an eat and run pizza shop.

Small Mom and Pop pizza shop with great food, good pricing, and friendly owners. When I went in here, there was only one other table full so I felt kind of bad. Hopefully other nights are busier for them because the food is excellent. I really enjoyed my pizza and would return.

Thank you so much to Park Ave Pizza for opening up right after hurricane Ian. The owners were running the kitchen and all when we came in. We felt lucky enough to find them open and have a hot meal!This was actually our first time having Park Ave Pizza and we weren't disappointed. I'm very happy we discovered this location as it's a great place to pick up pizza for a party. The slices were large and even the average cheese pizza had great NY style pizza flavors to it. The winter park community is very lucky to have you guys! Thanks again.

Ordered ahead and arrived early. They put my "finished" pizzas back in the oven. Got home a few minutes later and realized they just reheated older pizzas. Crust is burnt, too is cold. Not fresh pizza. This is forgivable with a slice, but not two pizzas. Very disappointed and won't go back. Too many fish in the sea.

At 9:20pm, website says they close in 10 minutes. They still happily made us 2 amazing pizzas and delicious freshly chopped salads. Highly recommend.

I just moved to FL from NY - so I know NY pizza and am accustomed to a certain level of Italian food/pizza. This place was GREAT! My cousin ordered in their regular pie for me and it was delicious! Definitely better than some places I know back home. Also reheats just as good! Excited to try more from them!

SOOOOO yummy! the people were so sweet, and the pizza was absolutely delicious!!!! highly recommend

Placed a call ahead order this past weekend. Was asked how long I wanted it to take, was then told 10 minutes longer than what I stated (30min to 40) which was fine since I had to drive there. Arrived only to find they hadn't even started the order even though it was completely empty in the restaurant. Then proceeded to tell me it was still going to be 30 minutes. Never got our pizza and ended up ordering from somewhere else, arriving and getting it quicker than this one would've taken.