NYPD Pizzeria
NYPD Pizzeria
Buffalo Chicken
Large meat lover
What??!?!? Special menu
Specialty Sausage pizza
a pizza in a box
Cheese bread
a pizza in a box
Cheese Chessy Garlic Bread
Menu
a pizza box on a table
Check. Ouch.
Eggplant parmesan
Queen's Deluxe Pizza, no peppers sub green olives
Menu
Cheese Steak hero
a slice of pizza in a box
10" Personal pizza
Bacon ranch
Meat lovers
Special
Brooklyn Buffalo Chicken Pie
pizza, food
Pepperoni & sausage
pizza, food
ana l.
Mar 4, 2025
The past year NYPD has added great new menu items. Please try their happy hour menu with great prices! Service is always excellent and NY ambiance feels like back at home.
Read More
Tom P.
Sep 14, 2024
We tried the NYPD Pizzeria today, complete with NY themed painted windows and wall coverings. Furniture was nice, AC definitely works. Staff was friendly, attentive and fast. The food was good, but the prices were definitely on the expensive side. I am sorry, the value is just not there. Will not be going back.
Read More
Marilyn S.
Feb 14, 2025
This place has changed things up a bit! The window work was redone~sends you fun vibes even before you walk in! Front dining room holds booths and tables, back dining room, same. They could accommodate larger parties here. I love that they let me sub an ingredient on the Queens pie when I didn't want green peppers. Thin crust, requested well done. Perfect! Just so happens I was here on a night when their wine distributor offered samples of their wine menu! Definitely switching from my usual IPA to a glass of Cab! Love the changes!!!....passing through dining room on my way out, the pastas looked amazingly. Changing it up next time!
Read More
Anthony E.
Dec 10, 2024
Karaoke was fun and the chicken parm was delicious as was the friendly staff.. The pizza was also really delicious... I hope to be back again the NYC vibe is also cool..
Read More
John H.
Jul 21, 2024
Always looking for a non-chain restaurant and this one fit the bill. Being close to the turnpike on our travel to Miami didn't hurt either.Service was fast and Sonja was awesome being able to handle the whole restaurant by herself.You walk in and feel like you are in NYC with all of the decor.Trust me, have the arancini and cheesy garlic bread. Loved each bite. If you order slices come hungry. Each slice is about a quarter of a large pizza. You could also split a 2 slice lunch special with someone else.And you can't go wrong with the zeppoles. We threw caution to the wind and let Sonja choose the flavor. Can't go wrong with cinnamon sugar.Come hungry!!
Read More
John M.
Jan 18, 2023
NYPD Pizza is a pizza place here in the orlando, Florida area. At one point, it had multiple locations, but now, I believe it is only down to this one. Curiosity just had me look at their website and I find that there is still multiple locations. The one that I remember here on the east side of Orlando has long since closed. In defense of the pizzeria, it was a very bad location that they chose.NYPD Pizza offers at best, middle of the road food. Mediocre pizza, the staff was friendly. I grew up in new jersey, where there is great pizza pretty much on every corner. With that being said, my expectations are high. Even if you're living in Florida for over twenty years, where I sadly discovered that great pizza is not available on every corner, I still seek out great pizza and am sadly more disappointed than celebrating a great find.It is not that NYPD Pizza is terrible, it is just not great either. As I said, middle of the road.
Read More
Blair E.
Nov 25, 2022
I have only been here once a few years ago but decided to give it a shot again through Uber Eats. Ordered the Patrolman Pepperoni Calzone and Bone-in Wings.The calzone was mediocre. I can't really say anything bad about it but can't really say anything good about it either. I didn't love the flavor of the pepperoni itself and the sauce that was on the side was pretty basic. It was fairly large which made it a decent value for the price.I was more bothered that the wings were wrong. The order was for bone-in wings but instead I was given breaded boneless wings. Definitely wasn't what I wanted, which were basically over breaded chicken nuggets. I tend to order hot Buffalo wings but the hot sauce here was quite hot. I imagine the soaked thick breading had more sauce which probably made it seem hotter.All in all, there's much better pizza places in the area. I wasn't impressed the first time which is why I hadn't gone back, but this delivery I think was enough for me to realize that I should just keep to the other places in the area.
Read More
Victor M.
Apr 21, 2024
I visited this pizza restaurant hoping to enjoy their afternoon special, only to be sorely disappointed. Despite being regular customers, we were denied the special offer because of a restrictive "limited 1 per family" policy. This felt unfair and unwelcoming. The management's decision not only left a bad taste in our mouths but also soured our overall experience. It's disappointing when loyal customers are treated this way, and it definitely affects our willingness to return or recommend this establishment to others.
Read More
Sean C.
Oct 22, 2022
This review hurts me to write as this used to be the only pizza place we ordered from. NYPD Pizzeria was my go-to order when I wanted tasty and authentic NY Style pizzas, calzones, and strombolis.My last 2 out of 3 orders using Door Dash from NYPD Pizza have been terrible. Two times, the Swat Team Stromboli has been undercooked. Literally raw dough on the inside of the stromboli. As for the calzones, the cheese was barely melted on the inside.In addition, I ordered everyone desserts. New York Cannoli - Soggy and inedibleOreo Zeppoles - Super oily and tasted like old stale frying oilBrooklyn Stuffed Zeppoles - Same as aboveAll of the desserts were inedible.The first time, I gave them a pass as I can understand errors can occur.This time I felt compelled to write a review to hopefully allow them to address their issues.
Read More
Silent B.
Nov 23, 2024
I was passing through the Stoneybrook area and was craving a slice of pizza. I recalled NYPD Pizza was close by and decided to grab a slice to go. I was very disappointed when opening the box. The slice was full of oil. Not a big deal. I just used a napkin to clean it up a bit. I was hoping to eat the slice while continuing my drive. Slice was as soggy as a wet towel. Completely collapsed when trying to pick up. Could not lift or fold like NY style pizza. Again, no big deal and stopped to eat. Unfortunately, tasted like day old pizza. It was very chewy. I have been here in the past and pizza was better. I noticed the slice was not pulled from the window display and pulled from the back. Not sure if the older pizza is kept in the back. Decided not to eat the whole slice. Tasted like 7-11 pizza. Not sure what changed but pizza is not the same as before.
Read More
