NY Pizza Baby
NY Pizza Baby
a half eaten pepperoni pizza
Sad Onion Rings
Even the pictures give that NY vibe only a true new yorker will understand
Brun
a half eaten pizza in a box
Calamari
chicken wings, food, fried chicken, bbq chicken, bbq wings, fried chicken wings, chicken, chicken wings and fried chicken, poultry
It's supposed to be a sicilian pizza, but received a square cheese instead
Fried Calamari
Meatball Sub! Sooo delicious!
Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
a half eaten pizza in a box
pizza, food
food
outside
John L.
Dec 18, 2020
I've never physically been here, but in the brave, new world of COVID I've ordered from here several times via delivery apps.I'm not a New Yorker, so I don't have the built-in aggression to certain pizza places and those places NOT BEING NEW YORK ENOUGH so I like it. It's pretty decent pizza and it definitely isn't "worse than any frozen pizza I've ever had" like another reviewer said.We get the wings, pizza, and knots. All good. We've tried a few of their entrees and they were OK, not great. Their pepperoni roll is DELICIOUS and very well-priced. The calzones were good. They have some nice specials and the food has always been packaged nice. I'd recommend it, unless you have NY pizza aggression issues.
Read More
Denise M.
May 3, 2020
*sigh* I was REALLY excited to get calamari for dinner & this is what i got... not even a pathetic lemon slice to go with them... 10 rings of calamari for $9...?????? I'm so incredibly upset & my calamari craving has not been met by any means. If you are looking for good calamari just look elsewhere Otherwise, the Hawaiian BBQ pizza was SO GOOD! Their wings are also pretty decent for the price. I wanted to give one a star but the pizza is actually pretty great.I don't know if i'll ever be able to get over how played so got on the calamari though!!!
Read More
Carolina C.
Jul 8, 2021
Pizza was good. Not enough sauce for my taste though. Fries were on point. Overall 3 stars. Don't think I'll be running to order from them again though.
Read More
Angela K.
Aug 29, 2020
Horrible. I get that you shouldn't maybe order other firms from a pizza place besides pizza BUT...The PIZZA IS HORRIBLE!!!! Gross, worse than any frozen pizza I've ever had. It's like some weird casserole meats pizza.Add to that the very worst burger I've ever had outside of the ones they fed us in 1978 at public school in Georgia growing up (not sure if any meat was in it). Oh, and at least in elementary school the fries were NOT THESE cold, gross undercooked fried and... yes, like an idiot I ordered shrimp-- I won't even begin to tell you how bad the shrimp are. Tried one thinning they would taste better than they look. I was wrong. Just don't.And BTDubs, If they tell you you can add a side of fries and a COKE and send you a Pepsi? Well, that's just wrong.Never. Order from here. Just don't
Read More
Karla P.
Apr 11, 2020
I've never left a review but this was a pretty disappointing delivery . $8 for calamari appetizer and we thought it was a joke when we received it. We called and they confirmed it's a dollar per calamari . If calamari is too expensive for them to sell , they probably should not have this on their menu. Very disappointing as we are a family of five and it was literally one piece sample for everyone
Read More
Ethan H.
Aug 6, 2021
I've just recently moved to FL, and I was determined to find my new go-to pizza joint. My girlfriend and I have ordered from "NY Pizza Baby" three times now. Great flavor, affordable, and solid delivery times. Service seemed experienced and considerate each time. One caveat, I wouldn't say anything on the menu stands out as remarkable, perhaps some more interesting menu additions would let "NY Pizza Baby" earn that final star. *DELIVERY REVIEW ONLY, DIDN'T DINE IN*
Read More
Caroline P.
Sep 2, 2019
Husband got takeout and this pizza is very enjoyable! We've been trying takeout from different places and this one stands out. Nice and thin and you actually want to eat the crust. Nice dusting of cornmeal. We have not tried anything else just the pizzas.
Read More
Ruby A.
Jan 25, 2023
The business was sold to new owners. I went there today and they were closed. They are not going to be doing business anymore and it's sad because new people took it over. I enjoyed Pizza there from the previous owner as a man by the name of Mo work there cooking the pizzas. He was not with the current owner now and I wanted to see if they knew where he went cuz I enjoyed the pizzas he made.However they closed out the place is all black and empty. It's sad.
Read More
Meachy T.
Jan 2, 2022
Haven't had pizza this good in awhile!! Best my style pizza in winter park! The crust perfect crisp, great amount of topping not too much not too lil and the nicest staff ever!!! The delivery guy an older Spanish man was great and whoever the girl operating the phone was the sweetest!!!
Read More
First L.
Nov 27, 2022
Just a terrible experience all around. Calzone was doughy and of the 6 garlic knots 3 were doughy and 3 were burnt. Staff is unprofessional and rude. Avoid at all costs!
Read More
