Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken
Spaghetti with meatballs
food, pasta, pasta dish
food, burritos and wraps
pizza, food
food, pizza
food, chicken wings and fried chicken
pizza, food
food, pizza
pizza, food
pizza, food
Wings
pizza, food
pizza, food
food
burritos and wraps, food, wraps, burrito
food
food
food
chicken wings and fried chicken
Completely burnt garlic knot
food, pizza
pizza, food
Deluxe Pizza X-Large 18"
Alicia J.
Sep 17, 2024
This was my first visit to NY Pizza Baby. I was in the area and stopped by for a fast casual no frills lunch, and this place ticked off the list. Their pizzas by the slice were delicious, with a nice crispy crust. The staff were nice, and service was prompt.
Read More
Sam G.
Apr 14, 2023
They have great pizza and wings. They should have more reviews. Visited on a Friday night for take out. My family loves this place.The pizza was hot, fresh and delicious. Sometimes it's hard to get good wings from a pizza spot but their wings have been good for years.
Read More
Kelli L.
Feb 4, 2022
We have ordered from this place twice now and each time have been pleasantly surprised. It has been in the area for a long time and has recently moved into a larger space. So, they must be doing something right!! Last time, we ordered pizza. This time we ordered a calzone. This is their deluxe calzone. It comes with pepperoni, sausage, ham, onion, peppers and black olives. Of course, ricotta and mozzarella are part of the calzone. My disclaimer: I do NOT enjoy a lot of ricotta cheese in my calzone. Lucky for me, this did not have a lot of ricotta. It was just the right amount!! It came with a side of marinara sauce and It was tasty and one calzone is enough for two people for sure!! It was crispy on the outside (which is a feat since delivery time is about 15 mins) and warm on the inside. I crisped it up just a bit more in the toaster oven and it was perfect!!
Read More
Rooster C.
Jun 10, 2023
Great pizza. Highly recommend. Extremely large pizzas 24". Feed the family with three of them and ten people ate till full. Love it.
Read More
Suzanne M.
May 11, 2023
Ive only ever had their Pizza but its always hot and delicious and I'm not a huge pizza fan so liking theirs says alot!!
Read More
Brianna A.
Feb 12, 2021
I feel like the review for this place are completely inaccurate. Normally I wouldn't order from a place with 3 stars but I'm glad I did. The pizza was REALLY good. We got a large thin pepperoni. It was delivered through Grubhub sooo it wasn't the hottest the girl got lost and all that. Honestly I don't mind my pizza at this temp. If it needed to be hotter a quick 5 min oven reheat would do. My kids LOVED it and they are picky guys. 9/10I got mozz sticks. Those were blazing hot! Very good 10/10 The only thing that was eh was the shrimp diavolo.. the shrimp is great cooked to perfection. The noodles were cooked to perfection. The sauce had a great taste.. just a bit to much sauce for me. The spice was great. 7/10. It really doesn't make up my mind about this place.I will be back and I usually take my time to review and I have yet to finish eating. I'd say give it a shot because the reviews are misleading.
Read More
Terra I.
Dec 19, 2020
Worst pizza ever, cold and cheese wasn't melted.I ordered a Sicilian and got a thick dough brick... a pseudo Detroit style is what it looks like.
Read More
Kenneth M.
Jul 23, 2024
They always take care of business and the quality of good! They are extremely nice to me and get everything handled for my deliveries. Thank you!
Read More
Noah L.
Jun 14, 2024
Work right next door. Great place to eat and grab a quick bite. The pizza and subs are always delicious
Read More
Dollez P.
Sep 7, 2022
After ordering the chicken stuffed pizza with NO BACON online. I showed up to find that they screwed up my order. When explained that i requested no bacon, instead of correcting the error and making a new pizza. The guy just insisted that it wasn't pork and that i should be fine. He went on to explain that they don't use any pork on any of there food options. He advised that they use beef bacon, turkey ham and etc.... Interestingly enough there is nothing in the restaurant advising of the type of meat used. I refuse to eat this pizza. Not sure if he lied to get rid of me but this is disturbing because I am allergic and he could be lying and putting my health in jeopardy.Very dissatisfied with the service from NY Pizza Baby.
Read More