a woman eating a pizza
Bianca/ no ricotta/ garlic oil/ mozzarella/ black olives and onions! Bueno Gusto.?
interior, sushi and sashimi
Menu
Meats Pizza, Bianca Deluxe
Pizza was 30'mins late and I was told to move from the table I was waiting at...
New York Cheesecake. creamy and delicious.
two slices of pepperoni and pineapple pizza
Only one piece left of our large cheese pizza!
Half an order of steak fries.
Bianca Deluxe. Picture may not seem appealing but damn this was an amazing piece
Part of the large antipasto salad.
Delicious white pizza.
Large Meat Lovers Stromboli. Came with 2 Marinaras!
Large Specialty Bianca. It was massive and delicious!
This is the portion you get
Tiramisu
Lunch
Mushroom Pizza. Ask for it crispy!
interior
NY Pizza is easy to miss, keep an eye out for it in the right hand corner of the plaza.
My man slinging pies!!!! If you aren't getting your pizza fix from NY Pizza you are missing out
Grease.
1/2 pepperonis 1/2 cheese
Mike M.
Feb 15, 2025
100% forgot to take a photo but told the wife she'd love this place and we opted for it on valentine's day. Just got a cheese pie, cheesy garlic bread, and a couple slices of cheese cake. Everything absolutely delicious. Their pizza may be my favorite in the Orlando area right now, the sauce is amazing;, the thin crust crispy, and mozzarella just bring my back to my home town in New York. No gimmicks here this is new york pizza.
Read MoreCindy D.
Nov 1, 2024
Ordered 3 large pizzas and 3 containers of garlic knots for an office party. Order was ready when I got there, everything was piping hot. Prices are great and the food was delicious. They have a really good pizza crust and I can taste the quality in the toppings and sauce. Garlic knots were topped with mounds of fresh garlic and butter, sauce on the side. The office favorite was the Bianca with bacon. Everything was absolutely delicious.
Read MoreJaina G.
Jan 19, 2025
As a New Yorker who's been desperately trying to find a comparable slice down here... I have to say this place is pretty solid.
Read Moreharrison m.
Jan 13, 2025
I have gotten pizza from this place now five times, and I've never experienced a problem. Great pizza, quick service, awesome experience.
Read MoreSamuel W.
Apr 14, 2024
This is the closest you will find two actual New York pizza in Seminole county. With a proliferation of pizza places recently, this is definitely a. neglected staple. It is primarily a takeout restaurant, but the pizzas are fab AB old style pizzas. Substantial ingredients, crunchy crust, and done just right the old way. Quantum of the business is takeout, but we are worth it!
Read MoreDaymond H.
Jul 25, 2024
This as close to NY pizza as I have found in Florida. When O walk into this location, I feel as if I have stepped in to a pizza shop in NYC. Great job!
Read MoreAime K.
Dec 1, 2023
The cheese pie and the bianca slice were delicious!!! They were incredibly flavorful, foldable and yummy! We also had an antipasto salad and garlic knots! The steak fries were hot, crispy and a generous portion! It's small inside and they close promptly at 9 even on a Friday... but reasonable prices and overall definitely will be back to this hole in the wall gem! I wish I took better photos...
Read MoreChelsea S.
Apr 9, 2022
Super pizza! I was looking for some NY style pizza and came across this gem. Unfortunately they don't deliver or use any delivery services but it was worth the drive. We ordered a large specialty Bianca and the Meat Lovers Calzone. Both were HUGE! Also, incredibly delicious. You can tell the ingredients are premium and they don't skimp. This is one of our new favorite pizza joints and I can't wait to try some of their other specialties.
Read MoreAmy A.
Feb 16, 2025
The best pizza I have had since living in Florida for 28 years. I am originally from Brooklyn, NY and have been to many pizza places. New York Pizza has them all beat!
Read MoreAnne S.
May 23, 2024
Everything is excellent ...best pizza in town. Love the Manicotti!!! Friendly people as well. Very yummy. Our favorite place to go!!!
Read More