Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza

Instant fan here! Tonight, we were at a party and ordered pizza from this place--WOW. I'm officially impressed.We tried the Star Alessandro, Star Cheese, Margherita, and Pepperoni. Each one was stuffed with ricotta cheese and absolutely bursting with flavor. But the Alessandro? Game-changer. I'm such a sucker for truffle, and it did not disappoint.I honestly don't think I'll ever go anywhere else for pizza again. If you're a pizza lover, do yourself a favor and give this spot a try. You won't regret it!

This spot had been on my list for about a year, and I'm so glad I finally got to try it! The decor strikes a perfect balance between casual and minimalist, making a subtle yet stylish statement.I was greeted promptly and handed a menu to place my to-go order. I chose the Star Luca ($18.99), a star-shaped pizza filled with ricotta cheese, spicy salami calabrese, mozzarella, Italian tomato sauce, and basil.The flavors were fantastic and complemented each other beautifully. The pizza came with a side of hot olive oil, which I absolutely loved--it added a spicy kick that elevated the experience.I'd definitely order from here again!

New pizza place in town and I highly recommend it. Pizza is FANTASTIC!!! Thin crispy crust and no flop. Nice combination of different types of toppings. Not your corner pizza joint. Toppings, sauce, and cheese extremely fresh. There is also a good selection of salads, deserts, and antipasti. A fresh burrata is a must with your meal. You MUST eat in to taste the freshness and crispness of the pizza. Once you put this pizza in a box, the magic is lost. Service and staff is very friendly and helpful. The ambience is clean and you can eat inside or outside. Great local place to eat.

My first review of 2025! If you have not visited this place yet, what are you waiting for? Not sure why it took myself so long... their pizza is absolutely delicious. I haven't had the pleasure of dining in the restaurant just yet, but we have done takeout three times. Their coffee pizza and star Luca pies are sooooo tasty. The crust is perfectly crisp. I am looking forward to visiting asap to try more of their "extraordinary" pies (that's what they call their speciality pies).

First time visiting Mister 01 Pizza after hearing great things about it for a very long time. My friends and I decided to do girls night out at this restaurant and everything went great. The establishment is cute and clean. Our server was amazing, gave us recommendations and was very attentive the entire time we were there. We ordered burrata as an appetizer, 3 pizzas and 1 Nutella calzone for dessert for 5 people. We had plenty of food. Everything was delicious but my favorite thing was the Star Alessandro. The Nutella calzone had bananas in the middle which made it even more perfect. It was pretty big so, definitely a plate to be shared.I will definitely be back. I want to bring my hubby for a date night. Lovely place, delicious food and excellent service. So happy to have found a new pizza place in Sanford/Lake Mary.

The pizza here tastes quite good, but I find it a bit greasy. The crust is crispy, but the toppings are uneven. The service is quick and the staff is friendly. The restaurant space is comfortable.

Went to try this place out last night and OMG. It was amazingly good. We got there a little later in the evening so there was no wait or anything and the pizza came out fast. Our server was very knowledgeable and told us the history behind the name. And the manager checked on us throughout our time there. It's a cool little place with outside seating. It's the old peach valley in Heathrow, so it's small and homey feeling. Now let's get to the pizza. I was a little skeptical about the ricotta in the star pizza when reading about it. So I had to try it out since that's what it's famous for. And it works perfectly. The crust is a thin crust and the entire pizza is light and airy. It's not over filling. And also come to find out they don't use any sugar in the ingredients (dough or sauce). I got the Star Beckham, which is the meat lovers. She got the Star Michele. Both top notch. And will definitely be back for more

We came for a date night and had the best time here! The staff was super friendly and shared their back story and wonderful recommendations! Our server Momina was wonderful, very sweet and very quick with everything.I had a Cesar salad which was the size of a basketball and the truffle burrata, both could easily serve 4-6. I also tried the Daniele pizza and it was super fresh with tasty prosciutto. And for dessert the Nutella pizza, so creamy and just what I needed to end the meal. You can tell they really take pride in their restaurant and it was a pleasure to dine here. Can't wait for the next visit!

Mister O1 is a fast casual pizza restaurant with various locations throughout the nation.They have a bit of a unique pizza they offer, their pizza is shaped in the form of a star. In the pockets of their star crust it contains ricotta cheese. This is their extraordinary pizza, they do also offer a more traditional style as well. Their pizza is a very thin and crispy crust. Their menu is limited to just pizza and salads. This location is very casual type of environment, very laidback with limited seating inside as well as outside. For the service, our server was courteous for the most part but she wasn't very attentive. Before any of our food came out she came to check on us a few times, once our food arrived we didn't hear from her, we even had to track her down a few times to get some items. After we had finished our salad she asked if we wanted it a to go box in which we replied no. The salad bowl which was quite large on an already small table remained. She came back after our pizza had arrived and asked the question again if we wanted a to go box for our salad which we replied once again we didn't want one and she never took the bowl. We didn't see her for quite a bit and then finally another server near by asked if we needed anything and we asked if she could clear the salad bowl to free up some space for us and she obliged. I'll also note it took almost 50 minutes for our pizza to arrive. I'm not one to complain too much about wait times but when I factor in the fact that multiple people had gotten their pizzas before us even though they were seated after us and the restaurant wasn't very busy I do find the need to point this out.For the actual pizza, I did enjoy the thin and crispy crust. I'm not a huge fan of ricotta but it wasn't overpowering. The pepperoni and sausage toppings were very subtle. If you're into saucy pizzas this isn't the pizza for you.The bottom line, from what I've heard they're known for having exceptional service and great pizza. I didn't experience the great service but they do have pretty good pizza. I'd maybe like to try another location to see what my experience is like.

The pizza is delicious and different love the star pizza and the Hawaiian pizza is my favorite