Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream

Kelly's Ice Cream in Maitland is hands down the best ice cream shop in all of Orlando! The flavors are incredibly fun and unique, with so many to choose from, and every bite is packed with loads of delicious chunks. It's clear that they don't skimp on the good stuff! The Oreo Dough flavor is my absolute favorite, a perfect mix of cookies and cream and cookie dough that never disappoints.The scoop shop itself is small but bright, cute, and inviting. The staff is always friendly and happy to give you some samples!

After a busy day of checking antique malls, my folks and I felt like grabbing ice cream. We saw this location for Kelly's was close to where we were - it is their newest location that opened recently. It's on the ground floor of an apartment or condo residence. There is street parking and I believe some of the floors for the garage are for visitors or those there to shop the businesses on the street level. We were fortunate to find a spot to park, but I would suggest going when it's not a busy period if you don't want to take a long time to find a spot. This is one of the smaller footprints and I feel this is better for those who are picking up ice cream to eat and take away or to take back home, versus the main shop which has more room and tables where people can sit and eat their ice cream there. That being said, they have a good variety of flavors available and same as their other locations, they will let people try their ice cream flavors before making a decision. They still had the November flavors in store when I went, so we tried a few, but we landed on our tried and true flavors of strawberry, coffee, and pistachio in the end. Staff were friendly and made great recommendations to those who came in asking for assistance.The ice cream was smooth and tasted fresh. It is not cheap, but it's great to support a local brand.

Kelly's Ice Cream is hands-down my favorite ice cream shop in Orlando! Each visit is a delightful experience, thanks to their incredible selection of flavors that are brimming with rich, vibrant taste. What sets Kelly's apart is the generous chunks of cookies, brownies, and other delicious mix-ins that make every bite an indulgent treat.The attention to detail in crafting each flavor is evident, as you're always met with a perfect balance of creamy texture and delightful surprises. Whether you're a fan of classic flavors or adventurous combos, there's something here that will blow you away. It's a cute and bright shop and the service is always great. Friendly staff, always happy to give you a sample, and believe me, you'll want a couple!

I recently visited Kelly Homemade Ice Cream's newest location in Maitland after a night out with friends. I wasn't initially interested in trying them, but I was craving something sweet, and my friends suggested this spot. Even at 8 PM, the line was super long, which was kind of crazy!I ended up ordering the strawberry pop tart flavor, which was really good. Unfortunately, they were out of my first choice, pistachio--definitely my favorite flavor of anything. The PBJ Crunch, however, wasn't my favorite.Overall, it was a solid experience, and I'd definitely go back to try more flavors, especially if they have pistachio next time!

I love Kelly's! I had a coupon, so I came in to check out their seasonal menu. The staff are always high energy and positive. They move quick and getting through the line was easy. I got the honey cinnamon latte flavor. I was worried it would taste too similar to their standard coffee flavor, but the warm honey cinnamon flavor really came through. I was impressed! Kelly's is always amazing

New location in Maitland! Finally able to visit their new location. As always friendly staff and great flavors. This time I got their key lime pie flavor and it was dellicious. They have inside and outside seating. Great decorations. They have a great variety of signature flavors as well some seasonal ones. You can either have it on a cone or cup.. they also sell ice cream on a pint or quart to stock on your freezer. Non dairy ice cream is also available but their is an extra charge. Great spot to have an ice cream.

Tasty ice cream spot in a cute location with nice staff!Came here with my mom and we both enjoyed ourselves. We were able to taste a few flavors and that's how we discovered the Salted Caramel Oreo flavor (i think that's what it's called)... so good! I ended up trying the vanilla ice cream with the "Chimney Cake" which was actually good! I will definitely return!

I love this place!!!!!! I was helped by Vivian and she was SO nice! She let my daughters try a few samples to determine the flavor they wanted. They tried a few and were really happy with the variety. I got the toasted coconut and pre-dough. The toasted coconut was recommended by Vivian and I'm so glad I took her suggestion!! There was coconut in every bite!! I love the location and the inside is pinkalicious!! My girls and I have found our new favorite ice cream shop!! Go for the AMAZING flavors, stay for the great customer service and good vibes!

Apple cider donut and pumpkin spice latte made my night! After dining at Lazy Moon [across the side street], my friends and I came to enjoy the newest location. We caught them in the last hour before closing. The team members were kind, professional, and patient as 10 of us made our way through the line. It was a great way to close out a milestone birthday. The shop was clean and well-lit. You can't go wrong with flavors. Their usage of real ingredients is delicious, indulgent, and what keeps me coming back. While I'm an OG at the original Corrine location, this one is closer and a location to which I shall return.

Small but quaint ice cream shop in Maitland city Center. Outstanding customer service. Great flavors.