John And John's A Pizza Shop

I saw an Instagram video stating this was the best pizza in Orlando so I had to come and check it out for myself.Indoor/outdoor seating Playing some cool 70s/80s/90s music Customer service was exquisite. The young lady in the front with the red hair is truly amazing.Greet everyone, great atmosphere orders come out quickly.Cheesy bread was good, enough to take home and warm up in the oven. To the BEST PART The pizza was definitely delicious! Thin pizza and the pepperonis were crunchy my favorite. They definitely deserve the name that they have.

Definitely need to add this to the list of pizza spots to check out ! Loved the way they have it laid out and it reminds me of an old school diner out in New York with a couple seats and places to sit and eat at. Pizza was delicious and I think my favorite had to be the Bianca slice. Just the right amount of cheese and ricotta to combined to make an amazing taste. Service was quick and they were very friendly and straight to the point. Parking spaces are a bit tight and limited , but if you're in the area, stop by for. Quick slice of pizza !

Visited 10/29/2024. Cute little old school pizza shop with some indoor and outdoor seating. Service was great. The girl working the counter was incredibly helpful, friendly, and on top of things. We ordered a Greek salad, feta dip, and a 16 inch pepperoni pizza. Greek salad was super fresh and tasty, but for $10 it was quite small. The feta dip was surprisingly good. Produce was so fresh. The pizza sauce is probably up there with the best in Orlando. The only reason I'm giving it 4 stars is because the pizza was a bit burnt. I'm not sure if that's how they usually cook their pizza, next time I'll just ask for it to be a little less cooked. I'll definitely be back.

After hearing so many great reviews for this place I had to stop in and try it for myself. Admittedly, I was very sad when Mediterranean Blue closed as it was a favorite of mine but I'm always open to places becoming something new if it's as good as or better than what was there before. Unfortunately, John and John's is not it. We ordered ahead for pickup which was easy enough. Our pizza was ready fairly quickly, no complaints about the restaurant itself nor the staff. However, I will say the prices here are pretty high for basic New York style pizza so I was hoping it was going to be really good. As you can tell from the star rating, I was not impressed. This pizza taste wise is probably on par with Hungry Howie's. It was just ok and the ingredients didn't seem to be very elevated which I expected given the cost. Neither myself, nor my husband enjoyed our pizza. We normally always put leftover pizza in the fridge to eat later but this went straight to the garbage can. I will stick with other, better pizza establishments nearby (i.e. an amazing pizza shop basically next door) and won't be back.

I ordered a cheese pizza for lunch. It had great flavor and a good cheese to sauce to crust ratio. I ordered ahead, so that could have affected the crust crispiness since it sat in the box a little. But other than that, everything was perfect and delicious. The customer service was also really good.

Excellent small business pizza shop that serves salads, pizzas, appetizers, and subs. They also offer pizza by the slice for lunch AND dinner! Great service with personable staff. Casual vibes with indoor and outdoor seating. Private parking lot with limited spaces in front and more parking behind. Highly recommend!

Love this place! Lots of options and love that you can order a whole pizza or by the slice. Their John's Bianca pizza is amazing.

This spot has one of the best if not the best slice of pizza I've had in central FL since I've moved down here from NY. Service was quick to bring the food out. They were very polite as well. The ambiance was cool typical pizza joint with good old school rock music. Which i enjoyed a lot. My old man also agreed this was the best slice of pizza he's had in central FL and he's extremely picky with his Italian food/pizza

Fantastic New York style pizza in Orlando. Definitely the best I've had so far. They have traditional pies but also specialty ones. The one on the right was gyro meat with tzatziki sauce. Delicious! Super friendly staff. They've got a few tables to dine in but looks like it's more of a takeout place. Definitely will be back for some awesome slices. Wish I lived close so it could be my go to takeout place!

Food is amazing is just great pizzaService and staff are awesome and attentive. The Ambiance is hip and welcoming. It is one of my favorite spots in orlando