Italy Pizzeria College Park

Delicious! Fresh, quality, house made. Coty is an awesome attentive server with a friendly smile and beautiful spirit. This will be of our regular restaurants

Service was slow. Gnats flying around my food. Did not order pizza but ordered off the dinner menu. Food was bland , no flavor. Needs improvement.

I don't know who wrote these reviews but we ordered pizza and garlic knots for take out last night. The garlic knots are almost inedible due to the raw garlic making it bitter and it was a greasy mess. The pizza was ok but lacked even basic seasoning. I've never had to add salt to a pizza. The Caesar salad was oddly sweet. No thanks. I really was hoping to love this place but nope. Never ordering from here again.

Newbie alert. New to the area. New to this pizza joint. No disappointments at all!!! Came in with hubby after a long day of house decor shopping and we divulged into their 14" (8 slices) I think... Bianca primavera- no tomatoes. Soooo friggin good! For me, pizza is not pizza'n if the sauce and crust don't tap dance together!! Fresh. Chewy. Savory. Crusty. Cheesy. Awesome goodness. We were greeted by a very friendly server and she was attentive as well during our lunch.Would highly recommend and will be going back for more. Mangia, mangia.

Tried out Eataly tonight for pizza. We were the only folks dining in, so the staff was incredibly attentive. We tried out the 1 pound garlic knot, Ceasar salad, cheese pizza, and the penne alla vodka. The garlic knot was insane - it was two pieces of bread with mozzarella cheese in the middle and garlic butter on top. They slice it into small squares, perfect for sharing. The penne alla vodka was very complex, smoky and tomato forward. We spoke with the chef afterwards who said he makes it daily. Really delicious. The cheese pizza had 0 flop. A perfectly crisp pizza. No notes. I would definitely recommend and will be visiting again.

Delicious!!! We stopped by for a late lunch and the food was fantastic. Service was excellent and friendly. We tried the giant garlic knot and were not disappointed! Reasonably priced too! Nice and clean inside and they even had a tv showing the pizzas being made in the back which we thought was pretty neat! Can't wait to come back again!

Best pizza place that I've had in Orlando for to- go! Great crust, tasty sauce, high quality cheese, not too greasy and just the right crisp. Very impressed and will be back to try other items. The head chef is from the Bronx and it tasted actually New York style pizza. (I was in New York a few weeks ago for comparison.) I am very glad this is new to the neighborhood!

Just ordered the 16" Godfather and Garlic knots for pickup and both were delicious... particular those knots! So crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Pizza was on point as well! Found my new spot for sure!

My husband and I had just gotten back from NYC and we were craving the pizza we had while there. We tried this place and it was so great we had it again the next day!! The margherita on the rocks pizza is incredible as well as the mozzarella sticks. Food was fast and hot and service was great! We will be eating here regularly!

Good pizza. Good balance between sauce and cheese, and the crust is excellent. Good service and ambience, though it's a bit hard to park on that corner.