Italian Garden Pizzeria
Italian Garden Pizzeria
Baked Ziti
Pan Pizza
a pizza in a box
Inside
Personal Italian Classic Pizza
Menu
Outside
Menu
Tomato Caprice
Menu
Salmon Florentine
Pan Pizza
Menu
food, pizza
Roma Meat Lovers Pizza and Carbonara Pizza (half and half)
Fried Mushrooms
chicken breast topped with eggplant and melted buffalo mozzarella sauteed with mushroom, onion and artichoke in light marinara sauce
pan seared salmon with Spanish Rice special
a plate of food
a plate of bread rolls
24 inch pesto pizza
interior
Sole stuffed with crab and shrimp on lobster sauce
Bruschetta
Kika G.
Jun 16, 2024
We shared the dishes as they came out. Everything arrived as expected. Inside was well lit and clean
Read More
Scott M.
Oct 20, 2024
This storefront restaurant will suprise you with the extensive menu selections available. The food and portions are very good. The pizza and sandwiches are excellent. The service is always good, it is a family owned restaurant. Try the rice pudding, they don't always have it.
Read More
C S.
Jul 28, 2024
Things have changed since my last review. Fee for using a credit card and a new "inflation adjustment fee" was added to my bill. Business owners just don't understand how hidden fees like these really turn off customers. Even though I like the food, I have no desire to eat there again. Just raise the price on the menu so I know my cost instead of these nickel and dime fees.
Read More
Thomas L.
Aug 3, 2024
We love Italian Garden. Closest thing to an authentic NYC cheese pie in the area. And we've tried all of the options around here and always come back. The pizza is great. Foldable but still a crispness to the crust with great chew. The chicken parm is breaded from scratch and not frozen tenders like other pizza places. The meatballs are huge and great flavor. Not an over abundance of filler flavoring from breadcrumbs. Last but not least, the people working there are so friendly. Even today when we picked up our order, they commented on how they usually deliver to our house and knew our street name. It's those little touches that make me love supporting this small establishment.
Read More
S R.
Mar 9, 2024
This was our first visit to Italian Garden Pizzeria and it won't be our last. The pizza was outstanding and you could tell great care was taken with the placement of the toppings. We received a complimentary basket of garlic rolls that were also amazing. Great service, too.
Read More
Melissa C.
Jul 6, 2023
Coming here reminds my husband of his childhood. He loved a family-owned pizza place in his hometown, and Italian Garden gives him the same feeling in Orlando. Attentive, kind staff when we sit down and delicious pizza and pasta for an inexpensive price. Can't beat hole-in-the-wall places. If you want to just soak your life in garlic butter, get the garlic knots.
Read More
Harper S.
Dec 8, 2024
Amazing pizza! Would 100% get again. The pricing might be a small scare at first but let me tell you, it's worth it! Such amazing pizza. The service is quick and you can see them make your pizza, they aren't behind any walls where you can't see what they're doing. It's also lovely quiet and cozy in there.
Read More
Ryan R.
Oct 20, 2024
Ordered my pizza and wings at 9:05p from their website and received an emailed confirmation. Called back 15 mins later (9:20p) to see if I could add to the order. I gave them the order number (directly from email) and was told that the order had already left and should be there in a few minutes. At 9:53p (33 mins later) the order still hadn't arrived, so I called back inquiring about it, and was asked, "Who IS this?" in a somewhat rude tone. After giving my name once again, they left me on hold, shuffled around and was told they had to "switch computers". At this point, I believe they discovered my order and asked me if I still wanted to add to the order, since it hadn't gone out for delivery yet (52 mins after the order was placed!!???). I was rather aggravated, but being that it was 9:57p and I was starving, I went ahead with the original order since nothing else was open (I was almost certain that they would at least cut me a break on my $65 bill). At 10:24p, he (Norberto) showed up at my door and said "It wasn't your fault or my fault... It was our internet. When you order online, it screws everything up. You should've called us".At that point I suggested to them that they should include this instruction on their site, since the first screen literally prompts you to order online. He took my card, and I told him I had already left a 20+ percent tip on the pre-order and he said, "Yeah. I see that." He then PROCEEDED to run my card for the entire amount PLUS the tip without batting an eyelash. No discount, no "don't worry about the tip", no concern whatsoever. I was completely baffled, and he could see it. After running my card, he then told me to ask for him personally next time and he could hook me up with a discount. (But no discount offered or mentioned right then). So.... He had the chance to make it right and keep a customer, and he chose not to. That business decision right there showed me the low integrity of the establishment. They'd rather have that $65 than my future business. And it's a shame, because the food is good. And to top it off, the order was missing a sauce that I paid extra forLook, I understand that mistakes happen, and I never tip in advance (the website instructed me to add it before the purchase), but it had been an HOUR and a HALF. To not even offer a reduction on the bill, AND unnervingly run my pre-given tip of about 22%, all while shirking it off to not be their fault (if I received my receipt online, then their internet was working just fine).... It was the worst experience I've ever felt ordering food. It left me feeling completely scammed. Just the worst. I will never order from there again. Sorry Norberto. NEVER coming back without integrity in your customer service. You screwed up, delivered ridiculously late, told me I should've called instead, took my money and ran. $65 for pizza and wings. So very disappointed.
Read More
Malissa Y.
Oct 11, 2024
We've been eating at Italian Garden for years. They belong to a barter company like us. We ordered a large pizza half pepperoni and half cheese and 10 teriyaki wings. We normally pay half cash and half barter. When my husband went to pick it up Kenny told him the cash portion was $29 plus tax and 28% tip. My husband questioned him about the price and Kenny wouldn't answer and give him the price. Well those pizza and wings would have been $34 plus tax. He was charging $58 plus tax and mandatory tip! And this was Wednesday late afternoon. Seems kinda like gouging to me. Very disappointed. Won't be back again. We sent many cash customers and were trying to arrange something with our church to use him for some of their events. My husband couldn't believe his attitude. This was for take out.
Read More
Mr M.
Jul 13, 2024
While ordering take out at the Italian Garden restaurant, I questioned two additional charges on my bill. A 2.00 Market Inflation charge and a ridiculous 2.60 charge for Other Taxes in addition to the regular sales tax charge. When I inquired about the Other Tax charge, the man at the register ignored me. Very questionable in my opinion. Buyer beware when eating at this place for sure.
Read More
