I Love NY Pizza Restaurant Bar & Grill
I Love NY Pizza Restaurant Bar & Grill
Sicilian Thick Crust
X-Large Cheese plus Mushrooms
a cheese pizza
One page of the menu where I found Rustico entree
Large Deluxe Calzone + Homemade Meatballs
Lunch menu looks good.
The photo...says it all
Awesome vibes
If you like to try it's ok it's my first and last time
Deluxe Calzone and Jalapeno Cheese Poppers
Deluxe Calzone & 10 Wings Garlic
Rustico
The burnt veal parmesan sub they gave me that was like rubber.
TERRIBLE Veal parmesan sub BURNT SMALL END PIECES THEY GAVE ME
Wings mild
oysters and mussels, food
dessert, food
food, steak
food, pizza
Pizza is okay. I do not recommend the garlic knots. They were burnt and the 1 that did seem okay was gross.
Half pepperoni..half sausage and pepperoni pizza
Deluxe pizza
Meatballs
Jason R.
Jan 23, 2025
It reminds me of the old school Italian joints. You could get slices and pasta. Everything was good.
Read More
James K.
Nov 2, 2024
Thee pizza was descent but it really needed more flavor, even the garlic knots needed flavor soggy in the middle . Felt sick soon after
Read More
Darren N.
Apr 5, 2024
The pizza was good and so was the chicken tenders and the location is nice but service was really lacking. I'm not sure if the person was new or this was a normal thing but I wouldn't go back when there are other options.
Read More
Brian R.
Feb 23, 2024
I don't know about the pizza but the Rustico dish was great. It had plenty of sausage slices, green peppers and onions in a tomato based sauce. My experience there was good. The dish came with a small tasty salad. We had a neighborhood group of 14 and our server did a great job. First she knew we'd be splitting the check so she took a name from each couple. We started with drinks while we looked at the menu. She took our orders and then the salads were brought over. Afterwards of course the pizzas ordered by some came along with our entrees. She was organized. Only comment about her service, which she did herself was the drinks arrived but half of us wanted straws. She brought them. Salads arrived but we needed utensils. She brought them. Entrees arrived but we had no napkins. She was sweet and moved the foods and drinks quickly. I got a second ice tea without having to ask. I'd give her an A-.Easy parking on the street and a clean bathroom. An 18% tip was added to each bill. I left a little extra since I tip at least 20%. My receipt says join us for dinner buy 1 entree get 2nd one half off by September 30th. Have to go back this summer.
Read More
Olga S.
Nov 28, 2023
I'm from New Jersey so for me the flavour was bland big portions though. Prices were eh okay a little high. Cheese Pizza/Meat Lovers Calzone
Read More
Judy M.
Feb 7, 2024
Had the baked ziti. It was delicious and large enough for two other meals. Garlic knots were disappointing. They definitely have deals on their menu lake but one with second half price.
Read More
Alvin A.
Aug 18, 2022
Being from the big Apple, I love NY Pizza too. So we decided to stop on in for a slice. If I could give a 4+ star rating I would based on the managers customer service, restaurant cleanliness, and quaint atmosphere. We ordered a few slices of pizza which wasn't horrible but it also wasn't the traditional taste found at your local NY pizza parlors scattered throughout the city's boroughs. I would still recommend this place as an alternative to your more commercially places.
Read More
Keith K.
Jan 1, 2025
We've been getting pizza here for years but last nights pizza was so salty we could not eat it. We ordered the meat pizza. Had to throw it out.
Read More
Andrew H.
May 30, 2024
AWESOME RESTAURANT! I went here with my Girlfriend and they even threw in some extra pizza for us! You can't get good quality like this anymore, felt like I was visiting New York again. My only regret was not being able to tip as much as I wanted. The atmosphere was super cozy and lovely too! So eating here again!
Read More
Alvaro T.
Sep 30, 2024
The food is mediocre, and the prices are crazy. For example, chicken marsala is $28-$29! $21 for ten chicken wings? Again, the worst part is that the place is old and dated AND the food is so so. Is not Raos people. Just don't bother.
Read More
