Goodfella's Pizzeria
Goodfella's Pizzeria
a plate of food
Veal Parmigiana, wedding soup and sausage and meatballs.
Spaghetti Carbonara - AWFUL
Chicken Nicole
a pizza on a platter
Sausage and two peppers. Maybe an onion?
Meat Calzone
Soggy
Lasagna
Sicilian Pizza Slice
Burnt chicken parm pizza
Garlic Knots
pizza, food
Combo sub with tomatoes thicker than the sun itself
Half Meatball Parmigiana Sub
Caesar salad. Very basic.
pizza, food
Pizza
Grilled chicken Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken
View of pizza to show huge scoops of sauce on it
Full sized salad on the left side and side salad that came with one of my meals is on the right. Same size.
Italian Wedding Soup - comforting
Grandma slice.
Katherine P.
Jan 13, 2025
Tried different slices and I have to say the grandma slice is a lot better the the cheese slice. Highly recommended.
Read More
Hilary M.
Feb 15, 2025
We used uber eats so I have nothing to say on the service or ambiance. We ordered a Caesar's salad and a vegetarian pizza. I asked for light sauce and several veggies. When the pizza arrived I was so surprised to find not only so much sauce on the pizza but then what seemed like large scoops of sauce on top of the pizza. It was the strangest thing. The crust was also so soggy it was only abt 2 inches from the top the cd b held. We each took two pieces and scooped off as much sauce as we cd and ate what we cd. The entire bottom of the box was wet from getting soggy. If we weren't hungry we never wd have eaten any of it. Pizza is usually a safe go to even if it's not great, but this truly was the worst experience I've ever had w ordering a pizza. We are from out of town and were heading to a show so we didn't have time to call and complain however I really feel this had to either be a horrible prank (at our expense) OR a disgruntled employee trying to hurt the company. This place has good reviews so I don't know what happened but hopefully this serves to warn others to at least not order if you don't have time Incase this happens to you too.
Read More
Jasmine T.
Sep 16, 2024
The pizza was one of the best and closest to New York pizza out here in Florida! The employees were so welcoming.
Read More
Charlotte A.
Aug 21, 2024
I have always had a good experience anytime I come to Good Fellas. I love their authentic New York style pizza. I always get the cheese or the white sauce pizza. I mean you can't beat a $3 dollar slice of goodness. The servers are always nice . I would definitely recommend if you're craving NY style pizza for a nice buck. I also like the versatility of their menu. The ambiance is really nice and definitely gives off old school New York dining.
Read More
Talisa C.
Apr 14, 2024
Went to Goodfella's yesterday and will not be coming back. We were never served! We were sat down in an empty area of the dining room, as booths were full, and we were given menus. That was the extent of our experience. When waiters kept walking past our table for about 10 minutes, we thought they were playing a little joke on us. Families began to fill the tables surrounding us and we were astonished when wait staff attended them, giving them drinks, taking orders, and even giving them their meals. After 15 minutes, we tried finding the wait staff in the dining area but they would just zip around corners before we could get to them. We were in the dining room for over 20 minutes before we gave up and left. I had heard good things about Goodfella's in the past, but I am simply turned off at the idea of giving them a try.
Read More
Anxo V.
Jun 9, 2024
I went to have dinner with my mom to this place and it was a great experience. The food was delicious, the service was excellent and the ambiance was very family oriented. We ordered the chicken tenders, the pasta fagiole soup, lasagna and the almond cake. My mom who is the Orlando resident will certainly go again in near future while me if I am in town again, will do the same. Bravo Goodfella's!
Read More
Eva R.
Oct 23, 2024
Amazing love it best pizza. Tiramisu was alright. And love garlic rolls. So garlic-y.
Read More
Kenneth S.
Feb 27, 2025
I had their lunch special #1 (2 slices of cheese pizza and soup or salad. I always get the Italian Wedding Soup, it's amazing). After I finished my meal, I bought a large cheese pizza to go, so I could meet my children at one of the local elementary schools. Goodfellas is their and my favorite pizza, by far. The restaurant gave me everything I needed for a picnic lunch with my twins, plates, napkins, and Parmesan tubs. Lunch was a big hit. Thank you.
Read More
Lizette F.
Jan 17, 2025
This WAS my favorite pizzeria, but on 1/17/25 I ordered the shrimp and bacon and it didn't taste the same, the sauce was not the same, was horrible, cheese was dry, not sure if I'll order again from here, for $30. I expect a good tasting pizza. Businesses change quality to save money and they hurt they hurt themselves.
Read More
Tiffany C.
Jan 15, 2025
This place the pizza send to bathroom with stomach cramps and diarrhea . This place I will never recommend
Read More
