Eddies Pizza
Eddies Pizza
Delicious pasta...simple with oil and garlic.
a row of pepperoni pizzas
Not 'crazy' after all these years... it's just "Eddie's Pizza" now.
the front of the restaurant
outside, bagels
a large cheese pizza on a table
a large cheese pizza on a table
a variety of different pizzas
The sausage/pepper/onion pasta (penne) is actually baked as well, and it is HUGE!
Yum yum food from Crazy Eddie's pizza
Sausage, peppers and onion
Small Stromboli
$2.50 Pizza by The Slice
O-ML I think it was a Calzone??? With like Philly- there was this young server and he had this amazing suggestions!
Cheese and pepperoni.
Their Garlic Bread / Garlic Cheese Bread!!! Omg I drooled all over it and still ate it all- goodness- it's 1am and I'm crying
Bianca Pizza
Cheese Pizza - 14"
Slice of Supreme Pizza
Philly Cheesesteak Sub made with fresh bread
The Philly cheese Philly Cheesesteak Sub!!! The best sub I have ever had!!! Literally the bread melts in your mouth.
pizza, food
Amazing pizza crunchy crush, balanced sauce!! Very very good
Danielle B.
Feb 4, 2025
We saw this pizza place highly rated on Yelp and decided we had to give it a try. Wow how could we have had this gem so close to home and not have known?!? We got an Alfredo and chicken bacon ranch pizza. GET THE ALFREDO, it was SO GOOD. It came with garlic knots and a salad, both absolutely delicious. The pizza was delish as well, although we will probably try a different flavor next time because we want to try the red sauce, but the crust was so crunchy and perfect. Everything about this place was great - don't let the little shopping center deter you. It's not fancy, but the food quality was superb! Both ladies we spoke with while we were there were super friendly and helpful. The food was amazing, we will definitely be back and hopefully have room for some tiramisu next time!
Read More
John D.
Sep 28, 2024
A few years ago, we discovered this charming pizza shop through a Facebook post from a nearby store that praised its food. Intrigued by the new ownership, we decided to give it a try, and we were thrilled with the delicious dishes and the warm hospitality from the chef and staff. Now, we make it a tradition to visit every Friday evening, and we've sampled every item on the menu, consistently impressed by the quality. Our chats with Elizabeth, Luli, and Adrian always add to the experience. This hidden gem is an absolute must-visit!
Read More
Margaret P.
Apr 26, 2024
Pros: Fast service, delicious pizza (New York style, with thin crust). Convenient location, affordable.Cons: None!Overall score: A+(Side note: I don't go in to get my pizza -- it was delivered. Therefore, I cannot rate the ambiance.)
Read More
Paige G.
Nov 21, 2023
I've been wanting to try Eddie's based on the reviews and being voted one of the best pizza's in the Orlando area. I ordered a large pepperoni pie and wings on a Friday night. The service over the phone and in person was awesome (hence the two stars). The pizza on the other hand was lackluster and I barely finished a slice. We both agreed it tasted like cardboard and the wings were average. Maybe it was an off night, but with so many other great options in the area, I'll be going somewhere else.
Read More
Art H.
Oct 11, 2023
Eddie's Pizza is your classic American-style Italian quick serve/delivery kind of place. The menu fare is the typical stuff you'd expect - some soups, salads, subs (both hot and cold), pizza, pasta, the strombolis and things like that. But here's the thing with Eddie's - they do all of this stuff really well.As a restaurant, it's really not a sit-and-eat kind of place. It's definitely a spot designed to primarily be take-out. Go in and you'll see. It's the kind of place that uses old cafeteria tables and chairs and uses a lot of the space as storage. So, beautiful it is not. However, the quality of the food and the care that the chefs put into it, is what sets this place apart. Especially considering that it's sort of in this no-mans-land out here on Ronald Reagan Blvd, by the train tracks, somewhere between Longwood and Lake Mary.Add everything up and it's a solid 4 stars. The subs are super good, so my recommendation says start there.
Read More
Kyle W.
Jun 26, 2024
Stopped in to Eddie's by way of seeing other positive reviews on Yelp. Did not disappoint. The garlic knots were some of the best I've had and the pizza is on point. Great cheese, sauce, and the crust was perfect. Will be back!
Read More
Adam C.
Aug 31, 2024
Best pizza in Longwood try to eat here every time we get pizza and it's consistently good. I usually get a half pepperoni and mushroom half cheese and it's consistently good and delicious. The owner is super nice and very grateful for your business. They have many other things on the menu that people say are very good, although I haven't tried them yet.
Read More
zachary s.
Jan 15, 2025
The Pizza here is amazing!! I come here almost everyday for lunch!! not only is the pizza amazing, the customer service is excellent, very friendly, attentive and makes you feel comfortable and welcoming!!
Read More
Laura B.
Jan 24, 2025
I'm not typically one to complain...but...ordered $60 worth of food and was really disappointed. Garlic cheese bread cold and worse than that raw garlic taste. Who in the heck likes raw garlic taste? Stromboli Regular...looked amazing...taste filled with very little cheese and way way to much onions and green peppers. Supreme pizza...same issues very little cheese and way to much onions and peppers! It's a shame because we liked the crust and the sauce This was our first time ordering not sure we will order again.
Read More
Chelsea N.
Dec 28, 2024
High quality ingredients make great food. Service is always amazing and I appreciate how fast they remembered me after I'd come in a couple times.
Read More
