Castello's Pizza

My brother in law and sister in law moved near Universal Studios from Windemere and we needed to find some good pizza. (Note: in Windemere , check out Stromboli's). I saw this place while waiting for my wife to get out of Walmart.Anywhooo...we ordered two large pies. The biggest they offer is 16". Which was plenty for the four of us. We ordered sausage and pepperoni on one and sausage, pepperoni, onion, peppers and mushrooms on the other. The delivery, just a few miles was faster than quoted and the driver was very nice. The pizza is pretty good by NY'er standards and very good by Orlando standards. The crust is very thin, crispy enough, and plenty of toppings. The sauce is good but it could maybe use a little bit more.Check em out!

This is the second location that I tried and this one is awesome too. Great cheese pie, well done with light sauce.I also had a piece of a cheese calzone and some Caesar salad. Everything was on point. Good customer service and easy ordering makes me a fan. Super local business that I will definitely frequent again.

Great pizza - super fresh. If you call on a Friday night make sure you call at least one hour before you want to eat. They are always super busy but definitely worth the wait. Sometimes we also get the Caesar Salad. When We call in they know our address and what we have ordered before so ordering is fast and easy. I'm giving it 5 stars as it's the best pizza we eat - I've never dined in the restaurant or ate anything else from there.

Good crust with great flavor. Thin and I like more sauce which they oblige. Next up I'm going to get their Calzones. Windermere is lucky to have them. Big slices with a soda would bring me in for lunch instead of other choices. They use Grande cheese which is the best cheese not sold to us over the counter. If you love pizza order with their large selection of toppings.

I love to support local businesses. Who I believe is the owner was compliant to COVID-19 suggestions and he was great. The gentleman making my pie with the long beard didn't have a mask on ‍.

Excellent Food, Service & Prices. Delicious NY style thin crust pizza. Wings were large. The hot & teriyaki sauce was perfect. Phone rep had pride in his job. Employees were all wearing masks & offered to bring food to my car. Highly recommend & will return.

I am shocked to see any less than stellar reviews for Castello's! I've never had a bad experience here, the employees are always awesome and the pizzas are consistently amazing. This is actually the only pizza place in Orlando I still trust to be consistent. I first heard about Castello's from friends who lived in New York for many years and told me that this is one of the very few pizza places in Orlando that they found to be on par with real NY pizza, so of course I had to check it out. I've been going now for years and never been disappointed! My family and I love Castello's!

I was really quite thrilled to discover Castello's the other day. I have lamented for the past decade that Dr. Phillips needed a good hole in the wall pizzeria and, apparently, I was blind to one just around the corner.Castello's may be small -- a counter with half a dozen bar stools against a window for those who want to eat in the restaurant -- but it's staff has a very sincere way of greeting customers. As a result, the store does not seem small as much as it seems intimate, as if one were getting a slice in a friend's kitchen.I've ordered slices at Castello's twice now. Both were consistent. The sauce was flavorful but not too sweet. The saltiness of the cheese was a perfect match to sauce. A few droplets of oil lingered on my fingers when I was done eating but I as not bathed in an excess of fatty oils. The crust was tasty but could have been crispier to suit my taste. Of course, on my second visit I could have asked for my slice to be thrown into the oven a bit longer.Castello's is a great find and one that I will return to again and again. You should, too!

We order from Castello's often and have never had a bad experience.The pizza, wings, and desserts are always fresh and taste phenomenal!

This is a hidden gem!!! I honestly have lived within 10 minutes of Castello's for a long time but for whatever reason, didn't order from them! What a mistake! This place is sooooo good. Seriously. The pizza, salads, calzones, abs bread were all so fresh and balanced with great flavors! Their sauce is delicious and just the right amount on the pizzas! Great price for the quality! We are hooked!!