Antonella's Pizzeria

I don't think I've been to Antonella's since pre-pandemic, and I'm happy to report that not a thing has changed! We went on a Saturday afternoon and they weren't super busy. Since it's a small mom and pop spot there isn't a lot of seating inside and not ideal for large groups. However, there were only 4 of us, and it was a beautiful day to sit out in the patio.I was bragging about the lunch specials, which are some really great deals. The sliders are my fave, so those certainly got ordered. And of course you have to get the garlic knots! Just be sure to have your breath freshener ready, because they are loaded with garlic. The 2 slice special, along with the veggiboli was ordered, and a baked ziti to go. Let's just say there wasn't one complaint at the table.I highly recommend Antonella's if you want to just grab something to go or happen to be in the area and want to grab a quick bite. The service is superb, and they are super friendly. I'll definitely have to make sure I don't let as much time pass for my next visit.

I've been going to Antonella's for over a year. I noticed at one point the pizza quality just wasn't the same, so I took a break. However, now the pizza quality seems to be better then ever! They are generous with the toppings that also taste really fresh! My fave is the Grandma's pizza.The staff and owner are really nice and helpful. Plus the ambience is great. Although the place seems small, I always see an available table.

Well, I work in downtown Winter Park and really wanted a Calzone today. I already tried one from another Pizza place nearby, but it was not good. And definitely worth the price. So I gave these guys a chance. And you know what? Not bad at all! Actually, it was pretty good! Today, I tried the Antonella's Calzone and although the price might be a bit high, it is definitely worth it. The thing was massive, and I couldn't eat the entire thing. I just wish it had a bit more Italian sausage, which I will probably request as an extra add-on the next time I place an order. I love that they sell pizza by the slice. It is also a great option if you want to try different toppings, are on a budget, etc. All in all.... yes, I would recommend this place. And before I forget, the staff at the restaurant was super nice and accommodating. Next time, I will definitely dine in, so I can try their pizza fresh out of the oven. I'm pretty sure it's going to be really good. So there will definitely be updates to this post.

Great pizza. Great service with Gabriel. Good luck with The Voice! He was so kind. The pizza was fresh and delicious!

We were in the area and looking for an affordable bite to eat. My boyfriend was in the mood for pizza, and Antonella's Pizzeria came up when I searched pizza. So why not, we love trying new places, and the reviews seemed pretty good. They had good lunch specials, so we both rolled with the 2 slices & salad special. They had many other lunch special choices as well. I'm sure we will be back to try out a pasta ones most likely in the future. The salad was bigger than expected but fresh and good. I upgraded my slices for tomatoe & spinach, it was hood i just felt they overdid it on the toppings. Overall, we enjoyed the food. There were not many seating spots but we chose to sit on their patio since it was so hot inside. They stay busy tho I will say, they had a lot of pickup orders and uber eats it looked like. I say if you're in the area, give it a shot, and we will be back.

Stopped in on a Saturday afternoon for lunch! Great find! Great variety of lunch specials through 4pm. I opted for the 1/2 hero (Italian cold cut, but you can choose from several heroes) and small Caesar salad. This special is #4 on the lunch menu; it's called "Twice As Nice". The salad was a generous portion for a side salad and tasted good. The hero was HUGE! Probably an 8" sub, packed with Italian meats and cheese. I had to eat it open face, with a knife and fork as it was too big to close to bite into. The pizza looked good! I think I'll try that next time.This place is small. Only 4 tables inside, and just a couple outside. If you want to dine in, visit during off hours or he prepared yo wait for a table - Butnthe wait will be well worth it!Highly recommend!

It's just ok pizza. Service is good Ambiance - if you like loud Spanish music Ratings state great food. ( not so ) Will not reorder.

Went over to this Antonellas after the closer one by me closed down, safe to say ill never go back. I walked in and knew what i was g into with the dirty environment and 2 workers who looked at me like i had 10 heads when i asked if they had my order i called in for pickup. They did not of course, then proceeded to completely burn my pizza! Bottom of the pizza black, and after sitting for just 2 hours the cheese already looks bad and no good. Easily my worst pizza experience.. Even any marcos, dominos or other fake pizza is better than this!

This used to be a really good pizza place. The staff was friendly and the food was great. My friends and I came here for a number of years. Apparently they had a change of ownership, and now it's awful. We came tonight. The service wasn't as good and the food was definitely not very good. Burnt. So sad that a great restaurant has gone downhill so far. We won't be returning.

Food was very hot! Service was good in good size portions. Had a lot of juice from the lunch specials. The food came out fast definitely be back.