Anthony's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
Anthony's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
The Boss. Pepperoni. Cheese.
Garlic Knots
a hallway with framed pictures
Store front
Chef Salad (the meat was rolled up, but I unrolled it before I took a picture )
Beverage and Desserts selections
Small pizza no green peppers.
Wine and Beer selections
Calzone with meatballs
Special Calzone
A lovely cheese pizza just for me
Bianca Pizza with mushroom and olive
Half Bianca , half Hawaiian Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Bianca Pizza
Bianca and Sausage with onions
Large Margherita Pizza with Meatballs OhSo Good!!!! #theperfectpie
Ordered the Meat Meatlovers Stromboli, My crew loved it!
Gluten Free Pizza with ricotta cheese, spinach, and mushrooms
VIP Pizza
Garlic Knots extra Garlic
Salad
Center cut Sicilian Pepperoni with garlic
Meatlovers Stromboli
John D.
Feb 12, 2025
I had a late dinner last week and forgot to add this review on them so here it is. Food is fantastic as for Calzone for it was what I was in the mood that day. Delicious! The special calzone includes pepperoni, sausage, resucito and plenty of cheese. The girls here are very friendly. A lot of customers coming in enjoying the restaurant food and ambiance. Yes folks you need to try here for traditional Italian food.
Read More
Colette L.
Dec 15, 2023
We live right by here and I am so surprised we are just now checking it out! We went on a Wednesday evening and boy was this place popular! Every table and booth except for two were filled. We were a little confused when we first walked on in regard to seating ourselves versus waiting to be seated, but eventually we were able to get someone's attention. The waitresses were definitely overwhelmed but even with the huge crowd, they were as efficient as possible! We did order garlic knots and never received them (but they also weren't on the receipt, so all good!). I got the chef salad and shared the Bianca pizza with my boyfriend. The salad tasted very fresh, although was slightly disappointed that the meats were just rolled up and placed on top which made it a bit hard to eat.The Bianca pizza was very yummy and fresh! The crust was a bit soft on the bottom, but I devoured this pizza! Super yummy! Overall, not bad for a pizzeria. We will definitely be back and the prices are not awful for what you get. My boyfriend and I shared the small pizza, and with a small salad each we had plenty to eat!
Read More
Steve F.
Oct 12, 2024
Great local Pizza place always good Bianca is a good option that is unusual topping good for lunch good for dinner been coming here for long time never had anything other than great pizza here
Read More
Darwin G.
Dec 1, 2024
Closest pizza place to me, wish it was better. Very floppy, a little bit under done, Definitely not worth the price for quality of pizza. Plain slice was almost $4. And that's even close to NYC quality.
Read More
Sri R.
Jan 20, 2024
Outstanding Customer Service by Mr. Jimmy ( long time good friend for long - earlier he even offered:)Just....saying... Very nice, genuine, hard working person...Other two great kids who do fantastic job are Iliana & Laura- true family folks... Few others worth mentioning are Ms. Gabby and Ms. Diana (She always look for work and highly work oreitned, focussed person... Please ensure they are recognized- i need to work on this and put in Google reviews and Yelp also. Thanks again Sri...Asian Indian thick accent who comes there now an Old man - 20 years back i was young:) still i know Mr. Jim brother for long...Sri aka drjustkidding.comGreat food super Veggie Pizza, Veggie soup and They give Slice other than full Pizza- nice people...Thanks & Best Regards,Respectfully Submitted,Sridhar Rangaswamy ("Sri")US Trademarks: #5030763 & 4837686"Promise Less/Under Promise and Deliver More""Excellence is not an act, it is a Habit""Honesty is the Best Policy"Be Truthful,Honest and Fair"
Read More
Mimi S.
Jun 18, 2024
When I tell you the best NY style pizza ever. Pizza is moist and fresh atmosphere was friendly and inviting. The serve pizzas, pasta dishes you name it. Service was great. Definitely the spot for that NY style Pizza. My frequent go to place for pizza.
Read More
Matt D.
Sep 20, 2024
Love the pizza! It's super good. Ive only ever gotten take out. It's very casual dining not fancy at all. They also have a vast Italian food menu besides pizza. The service has always been prompt and friendly. I like that you can watch the pizza being cooked.
Read More
Michael G.
Nov 14, 2023
My family has been eating at Anthony's for years!! Three generations now. The pizza is great!! The salads are fresh and served cold. Our favorite is the Greek salad. We most of the time choose the Three Cousins ( chicken & veal parm with eggplant parm ) we choose to have the pasta served with olive oil, garlic,red pepper flakes and cheese!! Ricky the chef cooks consistently great food every time we visit. Our server greeted us with a smile and great attitude. Don't know her name, but wanted to mention her bright being. Cool beans as I said to her . She only works the floor on Tuesday. The rest of her shifts are behind the counter. The restaurant has a simple small Italian restaurant vibe. Thank you for serving great products all these years. Don't know who owns the place. Just know his name is Nick. It's on the guest checks. Keep up the great job. Take good care of your crew Nick
Read More
Phil C.
Sep 14, 2024
We found a little slice of heaven when we walked into Anthony's Pizzeria. Cozy and quaint, what any NY Pizza joint offers for ambience. Add nostalgic music and you have everything you need for a memorable dining experience. And all that BEFORE the meal.The meal for us - The Boss 14" and a Greek Salad - Stupenda!Baris is the perfect supplier of hospitality, service and his cook staff, warm and welcoming.I recommend this dining experience whole-heartedly if you're looking for great food and a feel-better-about-yourself Italian dining experience.One last point - it's a great place for an event.
Read More
Taylor M.
Jun 9, 2024
My friend ordered two slices of Hawaiian pizza to-go and stated no pork. Instead of ham they put bacon on the pizza. When my friend called to inform the staff they were argumentative and unprofessional. They initially stated they would remake the item as ordered free of charge, however, called back moments later to state my friend had to pay. Please note, this was an order of two slices of pizza not two full pizzas. This conversation occurred in front of a group of 10+ people who actively order from this establishment. However, after this situation, we will not be returning. We were very disappointed as this is an establishment of which we previously held in high regard and often catered from.
Read More
