Anthony's Pizza
Anthony's Pizza
pizza, food
Small Caesar Salad
outside
Spaghetti bolognese
salad, food, salads
Spinach, tomato, black olives, and olive oil.
Register area
pasta, food, pasta dish
Menu
Menu
Freshly-made meatball & ricotta slice, pepperoni slice and a side cup of Italian Wedding soup...
the front of the restaurant
Specials
2 Hawaiian slices...
Disappointing- Ordered Large House Salad with no onions but apparently that's too difficult...
Rubbery Chicken Parm hero and tough garlic knots. The calzone is missing.
Menu
Minestrone
Anthony's Special
Menu
Garlic Knots
Inside
Eggplant Parmigiana Sub
Carl S.
Jan 3, 2025
Have been picking up Friday night dinner from here the last couple of months and it is on point every time. It does take between 40-50 minutes for your order but it is worth the wait. The service is very friendly and accommodating. Would definitely recommend!
Read More
Dj L.
Apr 23, 2024
Anthony's Pizza has just revamped and renewed their menu and the restaurant. Before it was dark and drab, now it is much more open and light inside! This is a cozy little place on the end of a plaza near the Altamonte Mall, directly next to Jason's Deli. They are open form aam-9pm every day and they have a yummy lunch special from 11-5 pm. They are generous with the portions and the food was excellent! I got the Anthony's Speciale pizza, with a small Caesar Salad and a drink for just $10! They do all of their pizzas not by the slice, but are 8' personal pizzas! That way you get a whole pizza to yourself! The toppings are fresh and of the best quality, even the pepperoni and cheese comes from Italy!! The service was quick and efficient. My friend started with the Minestrone soup, which I had a sample of. And wow that was one of the best Minestrone I have ever had!! Come in to try Anthony's Pizza to see their renewed dining space and menu!! (not to be confused with Anthony's Coal Fire Pizza - this is located on the same side as Altamonte mall)
Read More
Aaron M.
Apr 29, 2024
New Management has completely renovated the place. I had the pleasure of meeting the new owner, Ante. His dedication to bringing in the freshest ingredients is unparalleled. You should see how excited he got talking about the cheese he is working on importing for the pies lol. Very welcoming staff and a lot of care and attention is given to every guest. Can't wait to return!P.S. Lunch specials are some of the best deals I've seen. Forgot to take a picture of the menu
Read More
Nicole C.
Apr 19, 2024
Thought we'd try a new place that's nearby. We ordered from Anthony's for delivery through the Slice app. We ordered a Chicken Parm Hero, garlic knots, and a calzone. They completely left out the calzone and only delivered the Chicken Parm hero and the garlic knots. The hero was rubbery and tasted like it was two days old and the knots were tough like badly made bagels. Who knows what that calzone would have been like! Support for the Slice app wasn't helpful at all. They couldn't get the missing food delivered and I don't have confidence that I'll ever get a refund for the missing item. I won't be ordering from the app again, which is too bad because it seemed like a good place to order from local pizza joints.
Read More
Janine Levy S.
Oct 20, 2024
Wish we lived closer, as we could see coming here once a week! Stopped by while we were in town and needed a quick bite near where we were stopping in Altamonte Springs. Ordered Margherita pizza and a pepperoni. Yum! Crust was great, nice balance of crisp and chew. My dad had a Philly Cheesteak and fries and ate the whole thing. The bread had an awesome bake on it. Garlic knots were good too. My son's kids fettuccine Alfredo was a huge portion. The ambiance is adorable with perfect Italian music playing. Clean place you can see had a lot of love put into it. Attentive friendly staff! Highly recommend.
Read More
Jimmy P.
Sep 12, 2024
Had the lunch special with a slice of pizza, Caesar salad, and fried calamari. Nothing note worthy. Calamari was not fresh and the pizza was sub par. There are many other places around here that I would frequent than this place.
Read More
Ariel S.
Sep 28, 2024
Gave this location another chance since, and the pizza is back to being excellent. Consistency is still a little off but there has been improvement in quality and they honestly have the best new york style crave-worthy cheese pizza we cant find anywhere else.
Read More
Melanie M.
Jun 21, 2024
The spinach and tomato pizza is Devine and months later I am still craving it!! It has such great flavor!!!
Read More
Brandon M.
Jun 12, 2023
This cutesy, little pizza restaurant is nestled right in between the mall and Whole Foods Market in Uptown Altamonte. My friends and I typically come here for dinner-and-movie night. It's a much cheaper way to see a movie on a full stomach and not waste money on overpriced snacks. And we love it here. The atmosphere is red-bricked and looks like your typical Italian restaurant with all the historic pictures and paintings scattered around the walls. But the pizzas here are tasty and can be ordered by-the-slice or as a pie. And who doesn't love a nice side salad or cup of soup? All of them, which I've had in the past here, are also very good. The staff is always friendly to us and then there's the AMC Theater just over by the mall or the local dollar theater across the street. The only thing is that it can be hard to find. Just look out for Jason's Deli if getting lost because it's just beside it...
Read More
John M.
Aug 10, 2024
Excellent service, quality food, and presentation. We went off-hours and the food was great.
Read More
