Sgt Peffers Cafe Italian
Sgt Peffers Cafe Italian
food, pizza
Side salad
tables and chairs
Decor
Mushroom pasta
Cheese bread
Cheezy loaf
Seafood Lasagna
Decor
Dinner Salad
Cheezy loaf
Menu
a sandwich and salad
Menu
Cheese Tortellini
Grilled chicken salad
Minestrone
Fettuccine alfredo
Fettuccine Alfredo
Garlic bread
Seafood Lasagna Lunch
Quattroformaggi
Mozzarella Sticks
Menu
Sabrina D.
Jul 19, 2024
Sgt. Peffers is an Omaha staple. Truly just feels like an old school mom and pop pizza joint...because it is Our GO TO meal here is the 5 white cheese pizza. It's savory, indulgent and seriously just so good all around. We've also dabbled with the baked pastas a time or two and they make a great option for a family style meal at home or an easy drop off meal if you're like us and have friends with new babies every few months .Today was actually the first time I tried one of their salad options - and while I would've preferred a Romaine option or something higher quality than iceberg - the chicken itself, house dressing and overall size made it feel like a worthwhile menu option anyway.Come in, order at the counter, grab a spot and settle in for some truly great pizza.
Read More
Kiera J.
Feb 2, 2025
I love their pizza and rolls and their salad! The seafood lasagna is always so rich and creamy and still delicious as leftovers!
Read More
Nicole C.
Nov 1, 2024
My workplace catered in individual-sized containers of minestrone soup and cream of BLT soup along with a large bag of bread rolls and butter. It was sooooo fantastic!!! Especially the BLT soup which I wasn't sure what to expect. I really hope they order from Sgt Peffers again for future events. I've dined there in person but not in a long time. I may need to rectify that soon.
Read More
Sarah P.
Jan 14, 2024
Despite living quite close to this Omaha classic, I hadn't tried it until just recently. I got the classic lasagna with a side of garlic bread, and while it was a solid take out meal, I'm not sure the lasagna itself (despite the addition of a side salad) was worth $18. It was quite good but I felt that price was a smidge steep for the quantity of food received. The garlic bread was quite good, although the addition of pepperonis did throw me for a bit of a loop. Overall quite a good meal, just some small areas that could be improved on.
Read More
Bobbi Jo H.
Apr 17, 2024
My family went to Sgt Peffers on a Wednesday evening. The restaurant name is a play on the Beatles song, so the interior is all decked out in Beatles memorabilia, but with red checked tablecloths and other Italian accents. You order at the counter and then your food is delivered to your table.Sgt Peffers has pizza, sandwiches, soups, salad, pasta, and baked pasta dishes. All three of us ordered baked pasta dishes. The prices are really reasonable (under $15), and they come with a roll, and choice of soup or salad. I got the seafood lasagna, and my husband got the cheese tortellini bake. My salad came with a personal sized container of homemade Italian dressing (you can choose any dressing but I chose Italian). The dressing was incredible! The rolls are made from pizza dough. They aren't particularly flavorful on their own, but they are great dipped in your soup or pasta. My seafood lasagna was insanely good--if you have a sensitive stomach I will warn you, it is incredibly rich! For me that was a positive; the sauce was rich and creamy and buttery and cheesy. Amazing. Along with the cheese and lasagna noodles were layers of shredded crab meat and shrimp. I could only finish half so I brought the other half home with me. The servers are kind and helpful, the decor is kitschy and cute, and the food is tasty and filling. Checked all the boxes for me.
Read More
Catherine W.
Nov 11, 2023
If you're looking for the most delicious grilled chicken salad you've ever had, look no further. I can't quite put into words how delicious this is but let me start by saying this salad is very hearty and at a place with delicious pizza and pasta, I often only get this salad because it fills me up. The portions are large so I will warn you, I'd ask for extra dressing. Outside of the grilled chicken salad the 5 cheese white pizza is one of my favorite pizzas. Typically I think a pizza without a little protein on top is a waste but not when it comes to the 5 cheese white.
Read More
Makenzie L.
Jan 15, 2023
Sgt Peffers is and always will be the go to. It's a cozy little cafe that never fails to satisfy your tummy and emotional needs
Read More
Hannah H.
Dec 16, 2024
10/10 Quick service.Delicious foodCheap with good serving sizes. Cant wait to try their other items
Read More
Michelle K.
Aug 6, 2024
"Julia" on Saddle Creek was extremely rude to me when inquiring about a door dash order and refused to let me speak to her manager. I have a suspicion that she gave me the wrong name. I called both locations and both stated that my order didn't exist. Door dash will not refund my order and the Saddle Creek location was where the order came from. I've been a customer for 30 years and am astounded at how I was treated by "Julia" at Saddlecreek and her refusal to allow me to speak to her manager.
Read More
Connie K.
Aug 10, 2024
Great little Italian place!! I had the best tortellini with red sauce a side salad with their wonderful house dressing and roll. The busboy was so sweet very helpful.
Read More
