Pagliai's Pizza

I really enjoy Pagliais. It is a friendly family welcomed atmosphere.The pizza buffet is a great price. If there is a particular pizza you would like to try or to cater to your specific dietary needs, they will prepare it & bring it to your table to give you 1st slices before putting it out. I start my buffet with a predominately Spinach based salad. There is a variety of toppings as well as dressings. Next is the spaghetti & mac & cheese. Both are very good & the little ones really enjoy it. The cheese bread is awesome & the pizza's are usually out in about 6-8 different varieties. It is simple, but good.This family run business has been a round many years. Hire's the college kids. The people/kids that work here enjoy their job & each other... You can see it in their behavior & performance.

Enjoyed a lunch while watching our daughter in the MIAA Conference track meet. All the items on the buffet were excellent.

So I travel quite frequently for work, and get the chance to experience all the local sights. This place though has to be top tier. The service is outstanding. Almost guaranteed to leave fool and satisfied. The food is pretty phenomenal as well. With an excellent salad bar that really gets the job done. The atmosphere is definitely small town which is not a surprise. Overall I give it a 8.8 out of 10

Was right after they reopened. All orders were for out the door which meant the buffet had absolutely nothing on it. We tried to order food to take with us and was informed it was too long of a wait for them to take. Needless to say we paid full price and left hungry.

Pagliai's is a hometown favorite for a reason--food & service are consistently timely & pleasant. Buffet allows opportunity to try favorites like their homemade spaghetti (the buffet version is spaghetti already mixed in sauce; personally, I prefer the spaghetti there served as an entree, versus the buffet version). Salad, cookies, cookies & cream cool whip, hot chocolate cake, cheesey garlic bread, garlic bread, speciality pizzas, single topping, etc. ALL available on their buffet. If you've never been here, TRY it. You'll be back

Myself and 3 friends walked in 30 minutes past closing time and we were given 3 pizzas, a strawberry dessert pizza (must have!!!!), 2 full baskets of the potato muchers, and 3 full trays of cookies. The service was unbelievably great! Our waitress heard my ice hit the bottom of my cup then immediately offered to refill it. By the time we were done eating and went to go pay our bills they offered for it to be on the house. These are some of the most heartfelt and kind people you will find in the food industry.

Was the best buffet pizza place I have ever had. It was legit pizza the service was great! I would definitely go back again probably two times a week!

It's a good pizza for a town with limited options. The crust is a bit thinner than I prefer, but it was overall good.

Everything was really clean. People were superfriendly. The food was great. We had the buffet and tried a whole bunch of.. All of them were good.

best pizza in a 200mi radius. If you don't see what you want on the buffet, ask and they will make it and give you first dibs on a slice.