The Tastiest Pizza in Omaha

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4 (695) • $$

"Great vibes, not too loud, and options for seating. The food comes out as it's ready, so there was a 10 minute delay between me getting the salad and Nate getting his wings, but I appreciated this since they don't use heat lamps or let the food sit and get stale. The salad was amazingly flavorful, would definitely get it again!"

Eatery A

★★★★☆ 4.1 (555) • $$

"I've been to Eatery A a few times back when I lived in Des Moines, but after visiting this weekend I knew I had to write a review. I enjoyed a nice dinner outside on the patio. The construction on Ingersoll doesn't make for the greatest view, but the atmosphere of the patio is still great. Our waitress was very attentive and took good care of us. I had the lamb sliders for the first time and they were to die for. Perfect amount of garnish and aioli, and well-priced!"

Via Farina Downtown

★★★★☆ 4.2 (512) • $$

"The pomodoro sauce is 10/10. The sauce with our focaccia was the also delicious and unique. They used fennel to add flavor to our meals, which I enjoyed. We tried the pizza and the risotto special. The crust on the pizza was just right. Our server was great. This is very very small restaurant. The kitchen is in view, which is nice, but it's not exactly a fine dining experience. It's more like a hipster Italian joint. There is a political propaganda sticker on the door and the staff has tattoos. I won't be back because this isn't my kinda scene, but the food was tasty."

Orsi's Italian Bakery & Pizzeria

★★★★★ 4.6 (411) • $

"Guess who LOVES Orisi's pizza more than my family? NOONE!!!!! Freshly made to order, freeze what you don't eat in freezer bags and it lasts us for months...pull out and toaster over it..yummness in minutes! Meat lovers FAMILY SIZE PIZZA, and PEPPERONI and PINEAPPLE FAMILY SIZE PIZZA...is what we bought for our family of 2tonight! Sometimes you gotta live a little...ORSI's is always ready with your order (call ahead) when you arrive...I highly recommend!"

Noli's Pizzeria - Blackstone

★★★★☆ 4.1 (469) • $$

"Sorry forgot the flavor of the pizza - I just know it was a medium and it was scrumptious and really great to munch on! Service was great - waiter delivered the food to us in a timely manner. Ambiance was great, we ate during a summer month, so there was a nice sunny (non-cold) breeze from the open porch window, while we were eating pizza."

Mangia Italiana Pizza & Pasta

★★★★☆ 4.4 (403) • $$

"We had a delightful experience at Mangia Italiana in Omaha! Kicked off the evening with an Italian Margarita - a tasty start to a wonderful meal.The Meat Lasagna was a highlight for my wife - baked to perfection with layers of seasoned beef, ricotta, and that delectable Sugo. Her side salad with Ranch Dressing was fresh and flavorful.I opted for the Chicken Primavera - a savory dish packed with broccoli, mushrooms, onions, artichoke hearts, and roasted peppers, all tossed in a delicious marinara sauce and served with Bow Tie pasta. The Creamy Gorgonzola cheese added a rich and creamy touch that elevated the flavors.What truly impressed us was the courteous and knowledgeable server who made our dining experience top-notch.Mangia Italiana is a gem in Omaha that delivers on taste, service, and ambiance - definitely worth a visit!"

Timber Wood Fire Bistro

★★★★☆ 3.9 (469) • $$

"I've been wanting to try this place forever and it didn't disappoint. The cozy, wood filled space and a seat right by the fireplace made it the perfect spot, especially with the snow falling outside. I felt relaxed and at home. The focaccia with whipped ricotta and truffle oil was unreal, I could have eaten the whole thing. I got the timber mac and cheese, which was definitely not your typical mac. The chimichurri and pico de gallo gave it a fun twist. Service started off a little rushed, but our server turned it around and ended up being great. Can't wait to come back and try more things on the menu!"

Pitch

★★★★☆ 3.6 (415) • $$

"Arrived hungry after a soccer match, seated quickly but a friendly face. Our waitress was super friendly and helpful, though a little forgetful as we had to ask for refills and ranch sauce multiple times. We ordered our pies and the Marsala came out almost immediately, it seemed as if it was actually someone else's order. My one regret with the Marsala was that I didn't ask to add a protein, pancetta would have really complicated the flavors. The Thai Pie had fantastic flavors with a nice little kick that made my lips burn nicely. The Pitch Your Own was soggy, but the flavor was spot on. We absolutely loved the truffle fries, the sauces were a great addition, the favorite was the garlic aioli, coming in a close second was the pesto aioli. We sat inside, but they had multiple seating options available and I can really see spending an evening drinking my way through the margarita menu while enjoying their patio and pizza pies in my future.I will definitely be back."

Piezon's Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4.3 (278) • $$

"Wings are very good especially the buffalo, pizza is great as well, place was packed and we were still able to get seated and food came out in a timely matter"

Lighthouse Pizza

★★★★☆ 3.8 (339) • $

"My go-to order is the Thai Chicken pizza! Always great. Usually use the drive through. Staff are friendly & efficient"

Yia Yia's Pizza & Beer

★★★★☆ 3.9 (292) • $$

"We had the Polynesian pizza, and one of the veggie. The veggie was just okay, but the Polynesian was incredible! Spicy but not excessively so. Not cheap, but fairly priced. We got takeout but it's a cool vibe inside the place, wouldn't mind dining it sometime. One tip - absolutely get the thick crust. We got one of each and the thin crust left a lot to be desired. The thick was tremendous."

Pizzeria Davlo

★★★★☆ 4.2 (250) • $$

"If you're a fan of the Chicago stable of deep dish staples, then you'll be pleased to know that Omaha has a place of its own that measures up well. Excellent sauce, flaky crust and fresh ingredients. Davlo delivers."

MoMo Pizzeria & Ristorante

★★★★☆ 4 (261) • $$

"Professional fancy atmosphere with quick service. The food was great and everything was clean."

Greek Islands

★★★★☆ 3.9 (264) • $$

"If you want some great greek food, this is your spot. Service was great during lunch even when busy. My gyro was very big and good. This restaurant has been around for a long time and continues to be a destination worth going to. The decor makes you feel like you took a flight to Paros."

Smokin' Oak Wood-Fired Pizza and Taproom

★★★★☆ 4.4 (183) • $$

"Stopped in on a Friday night for a quick bite to eat and some drinks. It was recommended as I'm a beer "snob" by some friends. You get a wristband and pay by the ounce for your drinks, which is great when there are tons of options. Unfortunately, I was a bit underwhelmed with the beer selection, it was not at all interesting or new. They had the staples and some decent options, but nothing I hadn't tried before. Not one stout or porter (it's December for crying out loud). There were several cocktail options which my wife and her friends liked. We ordered 2 pizzas. The "Classic" was just ok, and the "Pokey Dokey" which was excellent. The restaurant itself is decorated really nicely. Fireplaces, outdoor fire pits, string lights, and what looked to be comfortable outdoor seating. We sat inside (it was 10 degrees out) and unfortunately got a wobbly table :( The service was very good, the people working the register were full of smiles and the manager even stopped by to say hello and make sure we were good. I would definitely recommend this place for a night out with friends if you are looking for a quieter atmosphere than the bar scene, but still get some decent drinks and ambiance."

Backlot Taphouse

★★★★☆ 4.4 (157) • $$

"We stopped here again before another hockey game, and I was surprised they had the full menu available from what it appeared. We went with the butchers pizza that tasted amazing. This was my first time with Detroit style pizza and it did not disappoint. I also ordered the bacon cheddar sticks that were very good as well. Our pizza easily fed my husband and myself, and we took home leftovers. They have a decent selection on the menu, so I definitely plan to visit again and try something different."

Virtuoso Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4.1 (169) • $

"Amazing NY style pizza. This place is amazing! Hands down best pizza in Omaha. Crust was cooked perfect, plenty of crunch."

Thunderhead Brewing

★★★★☆ 3.8 (195) • $$

"Best pizza in Kearney! The pretzels & nachos are also super yummy! Great drink selection & friendly staff!"

Zio's Pizzeria

★★★☆☆ 2.9 (325) • $

"Over all great experience and very inexpensive. The environment was very family friendly and our server Zane - although busy was very attentive and social. The Meatball sub was really great, and super filling. Would recommend if you are looking for a pizzeria!"

La Casa Pizzaria

★★★☆☆ 3.4 (218) • $$

"After a day of traveling and settling in with our hosts in Omaha, we made our way out to dinner. La Casa was the restaurant of choice and a decent one at that! An historic institution to the area, La Casa boasts its' history in photos throughout the space, creating a homey vibe. The interior is cozy, yet spacious and allows for parties of all sizes. Our hungry party of 5, opted for a round of appetizers (garlic bread and toasted ravioli) and salads before diving into our 2 large pizzas and a house made lasagna. I'll admit the crust on the pizzas is light, fluffy and crunchy, which made the entire thing, but I found the pizza to be a little lackluster. Nothing to write home about, in my opinion. The lasagna was stacked high and tasted good but definitely heavy - so avoid if wanting a lighter meal. Desserts here are decent too - we ordered a round of the zappole for home, which I apparently liked even more after a few cocktails. Service was okay - clearly overwhelmed from the Friday night rush, but our waters were refilled consistently, and wine delivered after a bit of wait. Not sure I'd go out of my way to return, but a unique introduction to Omaha."

Sgt Peffers Cafe Italian

★★★★☆ 3.7 (182) • $

"Sgt Peffers is and always will be the go to. It's a cozy little cafe that never fails to satisfy your tummy and emotional needs"

Villagio Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4.3 (132) • $

"I will start with the good stuff. Both my wife's and my dinners were very good. My wife ordered the lasagna and while she thought it was too spicy, I thought it was perfect. It was loaded with meat and the sauce was thick and very flavorful. My chicken Parmesan was very good. It was tender, juicy, covered with their very good sauce and absolutely delicious. Both our entrees came with a fresh and very good warm bread stick.Now for the negatives. Neither or our entrees came with a side salad or soup and they wanted $5 for such. I do not ever remember paying $15 for and entree and not getting a house salad come with it. Next, my Chicken Parmesan came served over Penne pasta. Everyplace else I have had this came with it served over spaghetti. Lastly, while my Chicken Parmesan was very good, I usually like mine on the thicker side All in all we both liked the place enough to agree the we will be coming back in the future to try more items on the menu."

Vincenzo's Ristorante

★★★★☆ 3.7 (178) • $$

"We ate dinner at Vincenzo's recently on the last night of a 3-day stay in Lincoln. It had been close to 100 degrees every day we were there, the house we were thinking of buying turned out to have a fatal flaw, and none of our restaurant meals had been anything beyond "okay." To top things off, I didn't feel like Italian food that evening! But just the bread and salad tasted fabulous, and along with the ice water, made me feel a lot better! And then the throw-caution-to-the-wind stuffed manicotti I ordered was simply over the top in deliciousness! We finished off the caloric extravaganza by splitting a delish creme brûlée. The food, service, and ambience were each 5-star items! This dinner really ended our short vacay on a high note!"

The Porch

★★★★★ 4.5 (114) • $$

"The Porch is a great place for lunch. Ordered the protein style burger. Patties were huge and very filling.Service was great.. service with a friendly smile.Inside is nice and clean. Definitely coming back"

Noah's Ark Ristorante

★★★★☆ 3.6 (177) • $$

"Made a reservation for 4 because never been here and glad I did! The parking lot probably needs to be expanded but good location. When first walking in there is a revolving door that you have to push hard. There is a bakery right as you walk in along with pasta machines and a display case of all the desserts. I love the fact that our chairs were roller chairs as it made it much easier to scoot in or out. The service was great, our waiter was an older gentleman and he gave great recommendations! The music was light but ole fashioned and the decor was old parts of boats, and beautiful paintings. The food was so delicious. My friend ordered the feasting bread and OMG it was so much bread but so light, and full of flavor! I was sad they didn't have ranch but the creamy Italian dressing they had was so delicious I could have brought a container home. I highly recommend the Noah's Chicken Parmigiana - it's phenomenal!! There is a small side of spaghetti that is served with it as well. My friend ordered the pork chops for two and she said she liked it. Bf and I decided to try dessert and I definitely was not disappointed. I love tiramisu but the waiter suggested the berry one, it was so flavorful of berries and cream! I wasn't sure I would like it as I'm not a huge fan of berries but it was by far the best dessert I've had in a long time. Bf tried the salted caramel crumb cake and he said it was good. Prices are about average for this type of dining as well. We will definitely be going back!"

Mama's Pizza

★★★★☆ 3.6 (162) • $$

"Great pizza. Got our large order correct - everyone loved it. 10/10 will eat here again!"

Let It Fly Sports Bar

★★★★☆ 3.9 (130) • $$

"Went here with a group of 4 before a concert and I was impressed! The place was crowded and the atmosphere was just lively to be in. Everything we got tasted amazing, but my favorite would probably be the pizza. They burnt our pizza & kindly made us a new one AND they took it off our tab! I would also recommend the garlic teriyaki for the wings over the chipotle honey. Our food came out in a decent manner, however our waitress would forget about our drinks/condiments when asked, but it was probably because of how busy the place was. The crispy mozzarella had a nice cheese pull after taking the first bite and the onion rings came out crispy too. My least favorite was the onion rings, but it was still good!!"

Backlot Pizza + Kitchen

★★★★☆ 4.2 (111) • $$

"Detroit transplant in Omaha who was very happy to find Detroit style pizza. I recommend the Detroit Classic (pepperoni) and finish with a hot fudge cream puff, that's Detroit through and through. They just need Vernors and it would be complete."

Zio's Pizzeria

★★★☆☆ 3.3 (175) • $$

"I used to rave about zios in Tulsa... it was my favorite place and made my taste buds happy. This was the first zios I've tried since 2002 and boy or boy... not great at all. The salad was limp and the pizza has zero flavor and the dough wasn't cooked. Every slice we tried slide right offThe crust into a pile of oil/juice. I was so grossed out I couldn't eat. Not sure what happened to quality of food/taste etc. but I won't be coming back."

Lyle's Pizzeria

★★★★★ 4.6 (89) • $$

"Always a favorite! Their service is good and food is worth it. Sad for me but, great for them, it is getting harder to just walk in and get a table or a seat at the bar! I need to remember to continue to make reservations. This trip I had a pesto roll which was 10/10 as always. I also tried the chorizo and potato pizza. The flavors were so good! A bit of spice from the sauce and chorizo and the potato cut it nicely. I do wish it was a bit more "stiff" because it was it was hard to eat this without a fork. But that was my only suggestion!"

Timber Creek Pizza Pub & Grill

★★★★☆ 3.7 (137) • $$

"Long time Timber Creek Patron, first time poster. We've been going to Timber Creek on a fairly regular basis essentially since they've been open. We live close by so it's nice to have a good option to rely on. We've taken family members, met friends or even just had a date night here. Although most people probably come for their pizza I love their burgers. In particular, the Timber Creek Bourbon Burger. I've had this specific burger more times than not and it has never disappointed. I'm a huge fan of bbq burgers in general and this one with the pulled pork, tangy bbq sauce and smoky bacon is always satisfying. Paired with well seasoned tots and ranch... I'm always pleased. Great option to have in south west Omaha with quick service, and nice array of food options. Plus we love playing trivia with the table cards!"

Isles Pub & Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.2 (106) • $$

"The pizza here is always soooo good. Thick crust but cooked perfectly so it's never chewy. They're generous with the toppings so no bald pizzas here and the wings are crispy and delicious. Our servers are always sweet, fast and attentive"

Copps Pizza

★★★★☆ 3.8 (129) • $$

"Service was a bit slow...but it is a Saturday night...we had a bam bam shrimp salad...it was excellent...shrimp was perfectly cooked..nice and crunchy..savory and sweet (strawberries were the perfect combo in the salad) Dean had Bills Hawaiian bacon, jalapeños...amazing burger...it was delicious ..the sweet potato fries fell short...they were not crunch at all ..mushy/soggy on the inside ....not good...Sonia had a wedge salad...it was a win! She also had the bam bam shrimp served on a bed of slaw ..very yummy! Keith had a chicken wrap (he sent back) wraps usually come cold and he said he wanted it hot..well it was SPICY HOT...(not warm heated hot)...but waitress graciously apologized and made it right...overall all good atmosphere...nice spacious place..full bar...lots of TV's to watch ...it had a sports bar feel to it...with outside seating..."

Big Fred's Pizza Garden & Lounge

★★★☆☆ 2.9 (210) • $$

"We started out with a small side salad that is decent sized & their Italian dressing is home made - Yum! We ordered two individual pizzas. I got Phil's Special which is chicken, red onions, mushrooms, Mancini peppers, and light mozzarella. That is full of toppings & delicious.My uncle got the hamburger and mozzarella pizza. He really enjoyed its thin crust & covered in cheese. Our waitress was tentative & quick to serve. She stopped at our table several times to make sure we were doing OK! It was busy on a Tuesday night with groups of people celebrating birthdays all around us so the noise level was a bit loud but we didn't mind. They have a few TVs that had golf on. I really enjoyed dinner and plan to be back soon!"

Mama's Pizza

★★★★☆ 3.7 (125) • $$

"Great chicken fried chicken w/mashed potatoes and gravy, and side salad. Of course they have awesome pizza. Service is quick and they're on top of it. It's a Omaha original. They're up for family and friends style dining. The bar is also available. Support our local restaurants."