Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse

I hate to do, but it's back down to 4 stars based on this visit. The food just did not delight like it should at this price point. I will say the exception was the dessert-we had the cookie skillet (best dish of the night in my opinion) and the pecan pie skillet with cinnamon ice cream, also delicious. I had the glazed salmon special for my entree, and I was so disappointed at the lack of flavor. I should probably stick to the steak next time.

The secret to a happy marriage is date night (okay, one of the secrets!), and we spent our date night at Mickey Mantle's. This is one of our regular steak spots in OKC, and it has been 80% hit and 20% miss over the years--after a slow start this night turned out to be another hit. We arrived 20 min early for our reservation and the host offered to see us to our table--maybe a bad idea because the servers were not ready for us, we should have waited at the bar with a drink instead of at our table without. We were seated in a side room we hadn't been in before, with a view of ... the bathroom. Could have been better. Our waitress Karina brought our drinks (a fantastic and reasonably priced Cabernet and an 18-year Glenlivet--the scotch selection is excellent) and our crab cake appetizer, a tower of delicate crabmeat on a lemony sauce. Next we had French onion soup and Mickeys chopped salad. The soup was stuffed with bread and onions, topped with cheese and the salad was fresh and crisp, served on a cold plate. For entrees we chose the steak--a perfectly cooked, melt in your mouth tender filet and a perfectly cooked ribeye. Our sides of fried okra and August gratin potatoes were also hot and delicious. Karina ensured our food was good and our drinks were filled and was great. We have been to countless fine dining steakhouses and I am disappointed that this one doesn't keep track of regular or recurring customers.

Was in town for work and heard positive feedback on here! Definitely was correct! Service was excellent on a Tuesday night and food was excellent. Got the 10oz filet and cooked to perfection as medium rare and nice crust. Also we ordered the lamb chops medium and they were outstanding. The bacon covered Brussels sprouts are a must if you like sprouts. The beefsteak caprese salad was solid but was missing some flavor. Would definitely recommend.

First review for me at Mickey Mantle's. First of all it's a great location across from the baseball stadium and Oklahoma sports hall of fame. Inside, there's a lot a sports memorabilia, dark woods and relatively low lighting. By the time we left it was almost full and pretty loud, but still a great atmosphere. I had the 7 oz. Roquefort filet medium rare with a house salad and tomato basil soup. The ranch dressing tasted great, the tomato basil milder than I'm used to but with a lot of flavor, and the steak was cooked perfectly and on a bed of garlic mashed potatoes. The service was excellent and our group had a great time. Recommend!

We went for our anniversary and it was a homerun! Excellent service and food. Jordan was an awesome waiter! We even got our dessert on the house. Will be coming back

Decided to dine here based on a recommendation from a friend. We had a lovely evening, the service was friendly and warm and it was a great start to our visit in Oklahoma City. We skipped the appetizers since we weren't too hungry and started with the blue cheese wedge and the soup of the day, which was a beef stew. The salad was delicious and not overdressed and the soup was excellent as well as a touch spicy which was unexpected but it worked. The steaks (a NY strip and a filet) were good and well prepared, but not outstanding. Comparing to other steakhouse I've been to, it was average which is why the 3 star rating. For sides we had the lobster risotto and bacon brussel sprouts were also good, but also not outstanding. It was a fine meal, but not something I would rave about.

Great steak and sides!! Can't go wrong the risotto or the mashed potatoes! The broccoli was the most underwhelmed sides. Just steamed. The waygu a3 was very fatty. It wasn't my favorite but the filet was delicious. Great service! I love the extra attention to details they had for our anniversary. It made our special day even more special!

Mickey Mantles is a staple in okc! Always great service, great food, great drinks, and atmosphere! Their chicken Cesar salad is so light/refreshing but filling! The lobster mac and cheese is rich and creamy! The chocolate cake is rich and truly heavenly! All around 10/10!

We love going to Mickeys! Great food and always excellent service! We enjoy happy hour as well!

Amazing service from Drew. He made several suggestions regarding food and drink. We ordered buttloads of appetizers since we had eaten a late lunch. The old fashion was so tasty, I had two. The only bummer was the tequila shrimp...where's the tequila Drew??? The interior space is high-end and comfortable. The steaks look delicious, oh well...next time.