Vito's Ristorante

★★★★★ 4.5 (438) • $$

"We absolutely love Vito's and have been eating here for years. Our personal favorites are the chicken parm and the lasagna with Cathy's sugo.The ambiance and service are impeccable."

Tellers - OKC

★★★★☆ 4 (436) • $$$

"Spent Saturday night at The National and finished off a wonderful stay with a great breakfast this morning at Tellers! Our server Ashley was so attentive and even able to keep up with my wife's diet coke, and my coffee, of which we both drink a lot of! lolFood was an excellent American breakfast, and especially the bacon. Also split a side of pancakes. Won't need to eat until tomorrow! Thanks to Ashley and team for a fantastic start to our day! Very much appreciate people who are professionals at their job!"

Benvenuti's Ristorante

★★★★☆ 4.3 (375) • $$$

"Love coming here for date night and drinks. Friendly staff and delicious food. Rack of lamb is amazing also"

Patrono

★★★★★ 4.5 (300) • $$$

"Food was absolutely spectacular. Amazing friendly service and great bread. We had 8 people, everyone ordered something different and was all incredibly delicious"

Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.1 (314) • $$

"I always enjoy their food. It's delicious especially their wings and the pizza service is always fast and very attentive. The ambience is perfect. I keep coming back for a reason. I am a very satisfied customer."

Joey's Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4.2 (274) • $$

"Delicious food, pizza crust and sauce is so so good!! Really great service too! Check this place out!"

Oliveto Italian Bistro

★★★★☆ 3.8 (294) • $$

"One word that describes Oliveto is Busy. We went at 530, and it was already jumping. I like to start with things that did not go well, and it was only one thing it was the new chocolate cake it came out freezing cold, just a minor over site, I am sure. I ordered a peach bellinibwhich was delicious. We also had the cheese bread. It came out fresh ,cheesy even the marinara sauce that accompanied the bread was good. For my entree, I ordered the chicken Primavera with no lemon butter sauce substitute angel hair pasta. Usually, when I order something with white chicken, it usually comes out dry, but not this time . The chicken was juicy and sliced for a perfect bite."

Ti Amo Ristorante Italiano

★★★★☆ 4.1 (224) • $$

"Another one of our favorite places to dine when we are in Tulsa! Who would have thought that this strip mall restaurant would offer such delicious Italian cuisine? It does!We've been here several times during our visits to Tulsa (first time in August and a few times in the fall of 2024 for subsequent visits). Always good."

Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza

★★★★☆ 4 (235) • $$

"SO GOOD!!! If we could eat this place every weekend we would. We have yet to have anything that wasn't tasty at this place. Their pizza rolls are so good, the pizza, the ranch, the desserts - ALL AMAZING! And their customer service is awesome as well! Jada has ironically ended up being our server every time, and she is so kind and attentive!"

Ten Star

★★★★★ 4.6 (176) • $$

"The staff was definitely short handed but they handled it with no issues. Kept checking on us. If you're not in the mood for pizza, get the chicken Caesar wrap. It is soooo good! They have a decent wine selection too. Pretty impressive for a small restaurant. We have been before but when we go back to Ardmore, I will not go without dining in again."

Falcone's Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4.1 (221) • $

"Easy recommendation if you're craving the following:1. Calzone (pepperoni and sausage)2. Tiramisu And...that's kinda it as far as must-have dishes go. Everything else I've eaten (pizza and wings) has been fine but not memorable enough for me to make this my one-stop-shop for all things Italian. They have a drive thru which is super handy for takeout and their service staff have been friendly each time I've stopped by - there's not a lot else you could ask for when it comes to decent, local Italian. I feel like other Italian restaurants upcharge to the point of absurdity because they make their food the authentic "old country" way so it's nice to find a place that just does what needs to be done in a consistent and thoughtful manner without feeling pretentious."

Cafe 7 Delicatessen and Pastaria

★★★★☆ 4.1 (192) • $$

"I love Cafe 7. I thought it was a weird concept when they opened though. All food $7 or less. Fast forward several years later and now it's "Open 7 days a week and food in 7 minutes or less". Food is $12-15, pre-made and much smaller portions. I think kids' meals might be $7 though.Food is really good. I love the Cuban sandwich and the pizzas. The baked ziti is yummy. The soup and salad meal is a good choice to pick your favorite salad (Ceasar) and soup (French Onion or Roasted Red Pepper for me).I also appreciate the fact that they have a drive thru."

Pete's Place

★★★☆☆ 3 (345) • $$

"We were traveling and hadn't been to Pete's in probably over 10 years so we just had to stop. Service was sweet and attentive. We were placed in our own little private dinning room. The Garlic bread arrived first and it was so warm and delicious!! Then the salad. I know some don't understand the hype about iceberg lettuce with vinegar and oil, but it is so delicious and refreshing. Especially with the cheese and olives and peppers. I ate my ravioli and meatballs first, and then tried the steak and spaghetti. It's just like going Home for a Home cooked meal. I just can't explain it. It "feels" just as good as it tastes! That's Amore!!"

Fontana Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆ 3.9 (195) • $

"This cozy Italian restaurant is a great place for date night or smaller family gatherings. I love the quaint feeling of this town's favorite Italian bistro with an air of casual comfort, relaxing amber lighting, and family style atmosphere. With three muted televisions and the soothing sounds of lounge music playing in the background, I feel like I'm sitting in my best friend's home enjoying a lovely evening sharing stories and delicious food."

Frankie's Italian Restaurant

★★★★★ 4.5 (145) • $$

"Really good from-scratch home recipes from my experience, and locally owned/operated. Very kind people and very hard working. The building and dining area are small but they did a great job making the best of the space available. The parking lot is small in the front but lots of parking around the buildingI highly recommend avoiding arriving in their last hour of operation. For example: if they close at 9pm then don't come in after 8 or 815pm. If you read this and decide to test this and get turned away then I hope your guilt eats you alive, but if you feel dismissed or angry then you should definitely go fly a kite in trafficThe sauce is really incredible, and the dish preparation is full of goodness and it reflects their care and appreciation to serve their food to customers. Their attention is given to customers kindly through the entire visit every time. They have one tv and it usually has sports on. They take reservations and they offer catering services. If you have a large group they will work with you to accommodate."

Napoli's Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆ 3.8 (198) • $$

"Excellent Italian place!Came here for a quick lunch.1) Place is clean, welcoming, and classy.2) Waitress was very friendly and very attentive.3) Food: Appetizers and Main Courses were excellent!We ordered several pasta dishes, appetizers, Eggplant Parmesan... and more.The cheesy bread was excellent.I will be returning to this place next time we are in town.Please give them a try!"

Gaberino's Homestyle Italian

★★★★☆ 3.8 (187) • $$

"What's not to love about Gaberino's! We've been coming here for a very long time and will continue to be repeat customers. In the casual, yet comfortable atmosphere you can enjoy fabulous appetizers, soups (I recommend the butternut squash soup), pastas, salads, etc. Do you like stuffed mushrooms? Theirs are diVINE!! They also have gluten free options and my favorite is zoodles with the best marinara in town. (I would love the recipe.) Then, there's the wait staff. Today we were served by Sarah K. What a delightful person. Attentive and friendly. We thoroughly enjoyed her. We've also had the pleasure in the past to be served by Sam and Josh and were equally as happy with them. GREAT staff and food, Gaberino's! Well done!"

Bellini's Ristorante & Grill

★★★★☆ 3.8 (156) • $$

"Got a chance to try Bellini's to celebrate a friend's birthday. If you're going for the first time, keep in mind that to get into the restaurant, the main entrance is inside a parking garage so you don't get lost! Anyway, the service was great. Our waiter was very attentive to our needs to our larger party so no complaints there at all. The food was fine. The pesto chicken was good, the salmon fettuccine looked great in person - I ended up ordering one to go for my hubby at home but it just wasn't what I expected. I took a pic of a friend's pasta and one in the to go box. I guess the plate was very misleading because the portion was a lot smaller to go. The flavor was fine, overall the food was good. Not my favorite Italian type of food but a nice place overall. Would love to try brunch there one day!"

Volare

★★★★☆ 3.5 (175) • $$

"The food is awesome. They have $2 Tuesdays where you can get 2 dollar drinks and slices of pizza for 2 dollars. The service isn't always that great. The crack fries are delicious."

The Old Spaghetti Factory

★★★☆☆ 3.2 (205) • $$

"Decided to visit on a cold Saturday night before the comedy show nearby began, great location overall - conveniently located in walking distance. Just ordered a round or two of drinks. He tried local beer Stormclouf (?) - if you like a strong IPA, it's worth the try! Bartender on first floor was quick and friendly. Great spot for a quick drink at bar!"

Da Vinci's Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆ 4.1 (114) • $$

"My husband and I came here for Valentine's Day and had a great experience. There aren't many Italian options here in Stillwater, so I honestly came in without great expectations.Our server was friendly, attentive, and on top of things, which made us feel welcome but not overwhelmed.The bread was complimentary and just fine. We ordered the fried calamari, which was nice and crispy, and the marinara sauce was amazing, so I sopped that up with the bread. We also ordered the shrimp diavolo, which was really good and had a hefty amount of seafood. My husband ordered something with sausage and peppers on it, and it was alright, but paled in comparison to the diavolo sauce, which was the star of the show, with the right balance of spicy and salty with a hint of acid. For dessert we had a slice of limoncello cake and it was light and delicious. Will be back to try the rest of the menu."

The Compass

★★★★☆ 4.3 (92) • $

"The Delilah pizza and Poblano bacon Mac and Cheese were very tasty and the service was friendly. We recommend that you give The Compass a try!"

New York Pizza & Pasta

★★★★☆ 3.5 (129) • $

"The number one place I know of for great New York thin, foldable slices or whole pies. Salads and pasta dishes are also available. There are a lot of tables for dining. A fixture on campus corner since my college days, the owners are actually from New York. They do it right! Still have to try Pronto NY in OK City. To be fair to negative reviewers, we usually order a fresh whole pie, which can make all the difference!"

Hobby's Hoagies

★★★★☆ 3.9 (102) • $$

"I've just returned from a week in Italy (Verona, Florence, Pisa, Turin) and here I am seeking an Italian sub. What's wrong with me?On the way to the airport, Hobby's met my search criteria - "open now" and "$" - and I lucked out with finding a spot on the street to leave the rental car. This was a quick in and out so I didn't pay a meter and lucked out.After waiting for the two people in front of me who apparently have never ordered a sandwich before in their lives, it was my turn. "Italian sub. Large. All the way." So very easy.It took only a couple of minutes and I had my sub in hand. It was unwrapped about 20 minutes later sitting at a counter in the Oklahoma City Airport. Delicious! Crunchy bread, spicy toppings, thin sliced meat and cheese, topped with veggies and spicy peppers and perfection. I think the only thing that would have made it better would have been more meat but I'm nitpicking at this point. It was delish![Review 17091 overall - 126 in Oklahoma - 607 of 2022.]"

Gino's Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆ 3.6 (118) • $$

"Food was amazing!! Service was perfect! Restaurant was clean, nice inviting restaurant. Will definitely go back if ever in town!"

Othello's Italian Restaurant

★★★☆☆ 3.3 (134) • $$

"Brought my wife here for Valentine's Day before the dinner rush and we had a great time. They handed my wife a rose which was warmly received and the service was top-notch (thank you Chloe). Chicken Alfredo is my favorite to order - creamy sauce and flavorful, and the bread was crispy and warm. The ambiance is perfectly set with Sinatra and Louis Prima softly playing combined with their colorful candles. Love coming here."

Venezia Italian Ristorante

★★★★☆ 3.5 (119) • $$

"This place was absolutely amazing. Theybhave the best calamari i have ever had. It melts in your mouth. I had the chicken carbonara and it was just amazing. If you haven't been here yet. You absolutely should!!"

Luigi's Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆ 4.3 (75) • $$

"We are moving from So Cal to Ohio and this was one of our stops for our road trip. We went to Luigi's to celebrate my sons 8th birthday. Let me say, their customer service is AMAZING!! Everyone was so nice and welcoming. I didn't get our servers name but she was awesome. She gave us extra napkins without me asking. She helped move my drinks when I was cutting my kids food. It's the little things! The food was DELICIOUS! The calamari was crispy (just the way we like it!) and the marinara dipping sauce was yummy. Tour of Italy was saucy and also delicious. I got the linguine with clams and white sauce. That was very light but yet so flavorful and the clams were perfect. My kids got fettuccine Alfredo and they rated that 1million out of 100 haha. They enjoyed their dinner! They also surprised my son with a chocolate cheesecake for his birthday. Thank you a wonderful birthday dinner!"

Italia Express

★★★★☆ 3.9 (86) • $

"Delicious - generous portions, good prices, friendly service. Forgot to get food pics. Stromboli and calzone were both excellent - reminded me of our favorite Italian spot in NY."

Johnnys Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆ 4.3 (69)

"From the homemade rolls with garlic oil to the very last tasty bite, everything was excellent! Our party had sea bass picatta, chicken Alfredo and the perfectly cooked rib eye. Try it! You'll be quite pleased! And great service, too!!"

Spazio Ristorante

★★★★☆ 3.5 (102) • $$

"So on this lovely day of solitude I decided to order the pesto pizza and linguine al pesto. I was not expecting the pizza to be that big for the price. The crust was a nice golden brown gives you the right amount of crunch when you bite into it. Now linguine al pesto lacked all kinds of seasoning. The vegetable had some seasons on the so I mixed them all together and tried it, it helped a little bit l. I think may be some parmesean cheese would have helped. I know if I were in the restaurant they would ask me if I would like some at least I hope."

Casa Del Mare Italian Kitchen

★★★★☆ 4.1 (71)

"My husband and I were visiting Lake Murray for the long weekend and were staying in Ardmore. Saw this little restaurant while driving around and decided we'd give them a try. We have a hard time finding really good Italian restaurants where we live. They are few. This place was a very nice surprise!!! They weren't very busy but I believe that was due to Covid19 and the fact they had just recently reopened. We walked in and there was a gentleman playing the piano. That was a great surprise as we love live music of any kind and he was great! The restaurant was clean and decorated nicely. We started our meal with their delicious house made rolls and ordered their special garlic oil. It was yum! Then we shared the insalata del bosco salad that had mixed greens, gorgonzola, pears and almonds tossed in a port wine vinaigrette.... it was definitely large enough to share and was really delicious! For our entrees my husband ordered the chicken scar pella which had Italian sausage and onions in a garlic oil white wine sauce spiked with a touch of balsamic vinaigrette. He enjoyed it very much and I had a taste.. it had tons of flavor! He had the roasted veggies as a side. They were way better than your typical side of veggies! I ad the chicken genovese. Chicken sautéed with portobello mushrooms in a classic brandy cream sauce. It was amazingly creamy and delicious! I had the side of pasta, it was surprisingly good without the marinara and with the garlic and oil! Everything was so so good! So we decided we couldn't skip dessert! We got tiramisu to go! Ate it later that night and it did not disappoint! My husband and I both said that was the best Italian meal we have had in years!!! Now that we have a boat and we love lake Murray we can see this place being a regular stop for us while in the area!! If you have not been to Giovanni's run don't walk!!! Go get you some!! P.s. there was so much food there was no way we could eat it all... so we took it back to our AIRBNB with us (thank goodness there was a microwave) and ate the leftovers for breakfast! Still amazing!"

Luigi's Bistro

★★★★☆ 3.5 (95) • $$

"The hot breadsticks were so good and when they brought the meal out it was even better. Friendly waitstaff and they took great care of us. We will return."

Luigi's Express Gyros & Pizza

★★★★☆ 4 (71) • $$

"We stayed in Lawton after driving up from DFW for an overnight stay. There were few options for food but we decided to try Luigi's.I ordered inside before taking out order to go.The pizza's are 2 sizes, small and large (if i remember correctly) and they also have gyros along with some other Italian specialties. We tried the large pizza and a gyro.I let them know we needed plates and they were more than happy to accommodate as we took the food back to our hotel.The food was cooked quickly and honestly pretty good! My husband loved the gyro and we both thought the pizza was good. If we were in town i'd stop back!"

Doni

★★★★☆ 4.4 (58)

"Food and service was excellent. we moved here from SoCal 3.5 years ago. Ate at Doni tonight...best Italian food since we moved here."