Large Supreme Thin Crust Pizza
Husband always orders Mr. Meaty and I get When in Rome but with extra Alfredo and no bacon.
The Monster Mash special yum!!!!
Club Sandwich with tater tots
When in Rome Pizza
Calzone
Calzone
Julie L.
Jul 9, 2024
This is a great pizza restaurant! Pizza was sooo good. Ben was such a sweet person, enjoyed talking with her.This used to be where my husband's grandmother worked when he was a young child. The place used to be Johnson's.Loved the atmosphere. Great place!
Read More
Amanda B.
Dec 31, 2023
Wow hidden gem. The pizza is fantastic and the desserts are too. The place is a precious cafe style with the kindest waitstaff.
Read More
Tunney C.
May 29, 2023
Heads above any competition is Ben& Jay's GLUTEN FREE PIZZA!!Allergies and food intolerance makes eating out difficult BUT NOT HERE!!Hands down the BEST GLUTEN FREE PIZZA IVE EVER EATEN. Consistent? Yes!! Have eaten here several times. Never disappoints. Also has salads and LOTS of choices for this who can eat what they want.
Read More
Caitlyn M.
Nov 30, 2024
Food was pretty good and the service was also good. It's a cute restaurant good lighting. But that's all it was, just good. Nothing really stood out to me but I'd eat there again.
Read More
Paula S.
Oct 26, 2024
I always enjoy eating at Ben & Jays. The food is consistent and so good. Everyone is very friendly and the pizzas are amazing!
Read More
Barry B.
Sep 21, 2024
This Italian restaurant has excellent food, and good service. Sometimes the music is a bitloud, but they always turn it down so we can have a conversation.
Read More
Brock H.
Jan 5, 2025
tried again.wife loves the food but we hate the service.time to change staff or time to just eat in lawtons one.garlic o holic is the bomb.
Read More
Larry S.
May 18, 2024
Shout out to your Lawton location! Not on Yelp yet, but let's support a small business! Salad bar was perfect, our waitress, Selma S., was the sweetest ever and in tune with our needs. Pizzas are great. Wishing you success at your Lawton location.
Read More
jeremiah s.
Jul 25, 2024
we went as a family, my wife had the pepperoni pizza and she loved it very crunchy crust. the kids had cheese burgers and fries and I had the meat pizza and salad bar salad bar is great a lot to choose from. the atmosphere was very relaxing not very busy and they were other children there making noise as ours were.the service was great till she spilt some sweet tea and made a remark using a cuss word which my son copied. she quickly apologized and said it just slipped out.if that is how Jackie the server works. we would not encourage small children to eat there .my wife asked for the owner and was told they were not available some apologies are just not enough we won't be back .
Read More
Joe C.
Dec 23, 2023
Stopped here while in town for the Festival of Lights. Great pizza and calzones! The service was great too and even got to meet the owners. We will be coming back even tho we do not live there. Pictures below is the When In Rome Pizza & Calzone
Read More