Super Slice Pizza

This pizza tastes like memories of being a child eating pizza while watching the newest movies rented from Blockbuster. It's that good. I ordered the Caesar salad and the garlic chicken pizza. The pizza was cooked to perfection with a crunchy yet chewy dough. There's a very generous amount of chicken on this pizza as well as veggies. The drizzle of garlic sauce made every bite addicting. I want to try all the different toppings now!

"Alright, so there I am at Lorenzo's - loading up my slice from the fixin's bar.. garlic and what-not.. mmm,mmm.. and I see this guy over at the pizza boxes giving me the stink-eye."- Cosmo Kramer, SeinfeldDa Scene: This time opt'd to swing by and pick a few slices from the display case, just like in many spots in Brooklyn. They had like 6-7 pies to choose from, so I grabbed 3 to bring home.Da Grub: 1 slice each of Pep, Cheese, and Margherita, left them room temp from the case as we fire up the oven to 550 at home and toss the slices on a pizza steel for a quick 2 minutes... perfect crispy crust without drying out things. The Pep & Cheese ARE quintessential NYC style, just like neighborhood spots in Brookyln, Queens and the Bronx. I normally shy away from Margherita in this style slice (preferring more traditional Napolitano), especially when I see actual tomato slices on the pie... we were pleasantly surprised, they did this one well, very thinly sliced tomatoes along with fresh mozzarella and basil, pretty damn good. We kick it up a notch and sprinkle a little pecorino on all the slices.Da Service: Friendly dudes, bright, clean shop, good assortment of pies, walked right in @ 11:30 on a Saturday. Parking in the center was crazy, I waited it outSo... my 1st time out, had whole pies which were just ok. This time slices that were ON POINT. Upping my rating for their slices and will stick w/ those for now, it IS a Super Slice.

My little sister has been wanting me to take her here since she first saw the signs after driving in the area last year. I finally took her for lunch last week. She said "They deserve 5 stars. This pizza is amazing." Lol She really enjoyed it and was amazed by how big the slices are. I like that the crust is thin.

Mehhhhhhh. It's OK.It's pizza. It's not terrible and they give you a nice big fat slice. I don't know what to say. It's OK. !!!

Pizza was great! My roommate didn't double check it was the right pizza, so we ended up with an x-large pep instead of a large peperoni, sausage, mushroom, but the crust was good and they gave lots of peperoni. Staff was super friendly and Sal said he'd take care of us the next time!

Great tasting pizza and awesome service! I receive two large one gilroy chicken and another large half margherita and half combo! Sooo good!!! Wish I took pic but we demolished it all before I remembered! Will definitely come back again! I'm a happy to have found a great pizza spot by this area!!

Very friendly guys who seem to be passionate about the pizza. Has an authentic NYC flavor. We get the large single slices. My girlfriend and I like to go here occasionally, and they are always smiling and remember our order after seeing us a few times.Interior is clean and the ovens are as professional as you'd expect.

First off, I'll start by saying that I've visited Super Slice twice. The first time I visited, we ordered a pre-made slice that was incredibly delicious and hit all our NY-style pizza cravings (my girlfriend is from NY). The cheese was great, the crust was great!Going off of our first experience, we decided to go backs second time to buy a whole pizza. We also brought along another friend (also from NY) who was craving pizza. We ordered a medium pizza to take home and enjoy but unfortunately our second experience did not match our first. The crust was so much thicker than the individual slices at the restaurant. It was almost like Domino's pizza or Digiorno style pizza crust... our friend from NY was really disappointed.So perhaps it was our bad to have assumed that this was NY style pizza, but just wanted to call out that the pizza styles between the pre-made slices and the made-to-order pies are completely different. Your experience may vary, but just wanted to let you know you might be getting something different if you order a freshly made pizza (compared to what you see in the pizza window). Sadly, we thought this would be our go-to pizza spot for large parties, but due to the thick crust, we will be sticking to the individual slices going forward.

The owner.Whoever was serving it was really nice.They're always real friend laying there.The people is good.I like thin crust I took.A slice to go , they also have sliced pizza which I really like

Great tasty thin crust pizza. So glad I finally tried this place. Ordered a whole Carnivore and picked up slices of pepperoni and the garlic chicken. My favorite is the garlic chicken but all were super tasty. The service was quick and easy to order over the phone and I added extra slices while I was there. This will be our new go to since we live a good thin slice crust. The other local pizza spots have been lackluster with flavor.