Pizza Pirate
Pizza Pirate
Not thin crust
a pepperoni pizza on a table
pizza, food
interior
Outside
Menu 6/6/24
interior
Squished pizza
Menu 6/6/24
Lemon Pepper Wings
Pizza Pirate... off the port bow!
Ahoy!
Menu 6/6/24
pizza, food
Anchors Away pizza
Menu 6/6/24
Menu
menu, donuts
Double Chocolate Brownie Sundae
Menu
Dining booth area. Clean tables
interior
Heather H.
Nov 10, 2024
Fresh ingredients, fast service and a very special atmosphere that is perfect for a family with kids after a day of walking around.The combination of pizzas is special. But when you trust the owner to give you a good recommendation, you will be positively surprised.Thanks for feeding our family on the way through town.
Read More
Kim T.
Jan 31, 2025
Chad replied to me in private and apologized over my experience, which is commendable.Because I truly want to support local, I will give them another try next time my son is craving pizza.
Read More
Danielle M.
Dec 1, 2024
Cool lil spot with a small town vibe and tasty pizza! My classmates and I ordered from here one night as we were studying for finals and found ourselves satisfied by what we got. We ordered the following for a group of us:- Abandon Ship Pizza: Crust was soft, the sauce was nice and tangy, and the cheese pulls on each slice could speak for the pizza itself (ABSOLUTELY YUMMY)- Caesar Salad: Simple and tasty, gave us all the greens we needed make sure we were still being healthy while studyingStaff here were super friendly and the venue itself was intimate and yet loud. This is the type of place you'd go to with a group of friends to catch up and have a good time. If you're in the area with a large group, I'd recommend Pizza Pirate for some good local flavor.
Read More
piyom g.
Nov 22, 2024
This place needs some work. I really miss the salad bar at pizza pirate. This was the main reason I liked going here. However I got kids now and they love the arcade, however it seem a they let that go too. After spending $40 on arcade cards for my kids, they go back for arcade to find only one real working arcade game. The others are either unplugged or likely broken. They had like 4-5 stupid claw machine, that are almost empty. One of the stupid and empty claw game cost $3 each time to run it. Seems like highway robbery and the owners are price gouging little kids who don't realize they're spending $3 a run. And they no longer have Stella beer on tab. No arcade, no salad bar, no Stella.... I'm sorry, but I'll be heading to round table and/or mountain mikes from now on. They both have salad bars.
Read More
Deborah H.
Dec 22, 2024
Came in a Thursday night to celebrate my son's birthday. We haven't been here in about 4 years. There were quite a few people dining. It was cold outside but nice and warm inside where they had a fire going. We were greeted and had our order taken right away. The TVs were on and the 49ers game was on which made my son and husband happy. We got a Caesar salad, garlic twists, lemon pepper wings and the anchors away pizza (the XL is huge). Everything was fresh and delicious. The wings took a while to come out but were well seasoned and worth waiting for. We also had the ship wreck Sunday which was big enough to share. We will definitely come back.
Read More
Alaura B.
Feb 7, 2025
One of our family favorites. Always have to stop here when we go to Benicia. Highly recommend the walk the plank pizza and the Caribbean joes! Great family place, our kiddo loves it and the food is always on point. Service is well, sometimes takes a bit, but its worth the wait. Ambiance is loud because of the games there and the animatronics, but its a family place, so what do you expect?
Read More
Rich G.
Nov 2, 2024
Best Lemon Pepper wings I've had in a while - I'll be back. Tried the Habanero and Buffalo wings too. All good but Lemon Pepper was the best.
Read More
Doug M.
Jan 21, 2025
This isn't a general criticism. I am gluten intolerant and can only eat a gluten free crust. Their gluten free crust was bad. I would guess that the gluten free crusts are not made on site, which would be typical. Most pizza takeout places have bad gluten free crusts.
Read More
Francisco
Jan 21, 2025
Best pizza in town. I love the atmosphere. You don't get these types of places anymore. I got the wings which were amazing. Cooked perfectly and with my choice of sauce. My daughter choose the potatoe skins and they might be my new favorite item to order now. Of course the pizza was as normal. Better than before. Some time last year the pizza tasted like a cardboard. Now the pizza was raised, fluffy and crispy on the bottom. Captain's Combo with the creamy white sauce is the way to go. I've eating at Mountain Mike's, round table and Napoleon's and Mary's Pizza. Pizza Pirate is my new togo spot now.
Read More
Cari W.
Feb 24, 2025
The pizza was delicious. They use all fresh ingredients!! The price was reasonable. I found out you can book the room in back that seats 60 people for free!! Also the service was great!! And they have an arcade room for the kids!!
Read More
