New York Pizza

BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE! This place just went to $#!+. I ordered a pizza with EXTRA SAUSAGE & EXTRA MUSHROOMS & this is the crap I get! I see more cheese on this damn thing. There is extra cheese though! When I pull I slice off, the f*ckin' whole thing of cheese just slides off. There are parts of the pizza were you can see the bottom layer. It doesn't stay on the pizza!! WTF?! They got cheap! They're Rude! BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE!! I was a loyal customer with this place, but they just lost a customer, because they couldn't even offer to fix this issue. SMH! I didn't want to give this place any stars BTW....

The worst experience at a pizza place EVER! The person answering the phone had a thick accent and I thought they were going to screw up my order, and they did. I ordered half pineapple and half mushroom. They put all the toppings on one side.I asked for a salad with ranch, they only brought ranch. The driver called from the street asking me to come down and get it, but someone from the pizza joint left a coupon on my door so they know how to get it. Forgot my salad.And the pizza tasted bad. I'm back charging it and never will go back, hopefully this review will save ppl from a horrible experience

Bay Area, listen up!!!!! Stop playing with me.... The best New York Pizza you're ever going to get, period point blank, is in my HOMETOWN HAYWARD! A st New York pizza has been putting it down since I was 19 yrs old, lol. 21 years later and they are still putting it down. The original New York Pizza aside from NY! I know I know, some will argue and say Tennyson New York pizza was the original but to me these guys are the original bc they have the best tasting toppings and they've been consistent for decades. You get what you pay for no doubt. While everyone else is being cheap with their toppings super skimpy, This place gives you exactly what you ask for. I drove literally an hour from the South Bay just to pick up a pizza from Hayward. Shame on the rest of you pizza parlors! None of you guys are even competing with these guys. Even funnier, they're under new ownership. Paul's family sold it, but guess what? The new owners didn't change a thing. The pizza is still amazing. Especially their ground beef and beef pepperoni. My fiance and I are Muslim, I don't eat pork, so this place has everything beef, which is so nice since everyone else always has pork. They have great customer service, and the people running it are sweethearts. I'm going to post close-up pictures of the pizza. I'm never going to go anywhere else when craving pizza. I guess I'm going to have to drive an hour to get to my old school pizza joint. Thanks, guys, for keeping it original. See you guys again.

Just wanted to note that I am still upset about this pizza delivery Mew yorl.pizza should be ashamed of themselves I been.patronizing their business since 2012 & they would even grant Mr 5.00 off? I should been asking

I have a tip for you. The phone number appears to be 510-5 82-3333. The one on the wall on the side of the building does not answer. You can order pizza by the slice and they have a veggie pizza for $5.99. Basically, they make it fresh. So, order ahead of time even for a slice. Then go over to the dollar store. Grab a 16 fluid ounce Coca-Cola including 0 cal for $1.25. Put in for a super lotto quick pick because you just saved yourself over a dollar in soda price at the liquor store. The crust was exceptional. I'd come here again. It's a shame that the outdoor seating in the back is not used for café seating as a restaurant. We could use an outdoor seating spot like this as a restaurant café with this good parking. All these new developments happening and this outdoor seating café is underutilized as a liquor store and a pizza place in the back. No seating all pick up and delivery. Hayward city, see if you can talk him into making this a café. Offer them a great deal on grants for upgrading this brick building into something that's more earthquake. Friendly if that's the problem. It's a great addition to the urban scene downtown. Lots of potential! Higher return than the little café at the library. And turn the Lucky into a Trader Joe's!

We love the pizza here! Consistently solid. And everyone who works here is really nice!

Call ahead or order online to get a quick bite.Not too bad.Not a dine in pizza joint it's in a liquor store so if you want beer with your pizza to go than this is the spot.

I order a pizza from them all the time. There customers service is very bad. The clerk will be on the phone all the time and makes you wait unnecessarily long. Then the quality of the food isn't that good. We usually get sausage, basil, and spinach. The quality of their sausage and vegetables were terrible. I highly recommend going somewhere else with your time.

Amazingg Pizza place, loved it!! Just the way I like it! Great staff and great customer service. Take away service and delivery available. Inside a liquor store, great bright inside.

Pizza is really good. I love how they offer beef pepperoni since I don't eat pork. Everyone's really nice here and there and always consistent.