New York Giant Pizza

Trying pizza from a pizza place without a rating is a risky proposition. I took one for the team and tried New York Giants Pizza. This is 2.5 star pizza overall so I'll spare the long-winded analogies and descriptions this time. I gave them a half star bonus due to the fast turn-around time for delivery. The pizza tastes much like hand-tossed style from pizza hut; I swear the sauce is the same too. That may not be a bad thing for some people. Taste-wise this was mediocre. I ordered through Yelp and the pizza arrived within about 25 minutes. I ordered a 14inch with one topping and it came out to 11.99$ Sadly, I ordered a piece of carrot cake and they brought red velvet by mistake--it was a disappointing little square, totally not worth the 2.99$ I mean, look at the picture I posted it was roughly similar in size to a packet of splenda! Yikes!With New York Pizza as a delivery option in Hayward, I think this was a one-time thing.

Tried them from word of someone else... so found them on google search. Went to their website and placed an order online to be picked up. Placed order with something called slice. Order said it went thru... checked a few minutes later and seen order didn't go thru. So I called the pizza place and spoke to a man who tells me they don't do their orders thru slice anymore cause they closed down or something?? I told him they should post that on their website which he then says it is... but it's not. So I asked him if we can place an order thru him and we will pick up. So we placed an order with him. A few minutes later he calls me back and asked if I placed an order with him and if I canceled... I said no I just placed my order a few minutes ago. He then goes on to tell me that someone canceled their order and he's not making anymore pizza. So my card charged with no order then placed an order on the phone and pizza canceled by the man on the phone ‍ horrible service. Horrible communication. Maybe it was a bad day... but seriously. Won't even bother with this place.

Probably will never get to try them. Ordered on GrubHub through Yelp. Card charged. Went to pickup and lady working liquor store counter said pizza was on break and to come back in 10 minutes. When I came back, the guy said he had no GrubHub orders. He made it seem like he was not open. He asked me to call GrubHub. I did so and they called him to confirm he was not going to be making my order.

I ordered via GrubHub on a whim when I did not feel like cooking one night. I thought surely the ratings might be a little dramatic but no, I have never felt sicker from eating pizza.I ordered two large pizzas and asked for white sauce instead of red sauce. The sauce was actually missing from the pizza I ordered which of course made the entire experience gross from the jump. Our order also arrived late, which was not a dealbreaker for us on this day but for someone else who might have hungry kiddos, this could be a serious issues. It was sub-par at best.

These guys have been around a long time and they make really good pizza I haven't had anything else they make but their prices are very reasonable I don't know why it has two dollar signs and the pizza is always consistent and good go there you'll love it

On a mission to find the best pizza in the area, so gave this place a try. Ordered a pizza to go and it was so good. Not quite New York, but a few steps up from Dominos/Pizza Hut. One of their pizzas offer unlimited toppings. The garlic was great! The place is inside a small convenience store, so I wasn't expecting high quality when I got inside. However, it definitely exceeded my expectations.

I ordered delivery based on their free delivery charge, most places charge now. Delivery time was quicker than the estimated time and the driver was very nice. I got a small combination for $12, that is super cheap for a combo pizza. And I got mozzarella sticks. The pizza was nothing special. In fact I only had 1 slice and the rest is just sitting. The mozzarella sticks tasted freezer burnt, big bummer because you can't really go wrong with mozzarella sticks. I'm big on trying new places, especially places with few reviews and hope to boost their business. But that won't be happening here.

Pretty sure it's just frozen pizza they heat up but it's cheap for big portion and quick service

I like the pizza and the crust isn't to hard or to soft its perfect and they are very respectful

Amazing place good customer service pizza taste good respectful place come atleast 2 times a week for a slice