Evelyn's Big Italian Pizzeria & Ristorante
Evelyn's Big Italian Pizzeria & Ristorante
Baked Ziti
Baked Ziti Alla Evelyn
Alfredo Pasta.
New York Slice of Pizza and true Italian cooking
Creamy Alfredo Pasta Chicken Fettuccini
So many boxes! They must be doing something right, to get so much business!
Outside signage
Cooks working assembly line.
Outside of Evelyn's Pizza.
Outdoor seating
Decor in entry way
Baked Ravioli with Meatballs
Decor
outside
Even a dang national pizza chain like round table knows the assignment. Look how crispy the dough looks. In New York pizza looks like this!
I'm getting it
Seafood Pasta
interior, donuts
Pepperoni Pizza
New York combo
Jazzi M.
Feb 17, 2025
My daughter and I decided to stop for dinner after running errands and decided to dine in. The restaurant was only half full so we decided to dine in. Staff was busy but friendly and we were seated within 5 minutes. I ordered the all you can eat spaghetti and meatballs (comes with bread and salad) and my daughter ordered the lasagna. We also split a slice of pizza. Our salads came within 10-15 minutes and the main course shortly after. The ambiance was cozy and intimate. Spaghetti was okay, lasagna and pizza were amazing. They serve huge slices of traditional New York pie, the best you can find in this area. The customer service was excellent, friendly, and we didn't feel rushed. It's not often I find quality food and great customer service in the same place. Prices were very reasonable as well. Needless to say, I would recommend to anyone looking for a great dining experience. I will be back soon!
Read More
Mary L.
Jan 24, 2025
Great food. Tasty and great service Eggplant is a favorite with but I also enjoy shrimp and clams, It was warm and delicious My husband and I have eaten pizza and other Italian food. Evelyn is it. It is an excellent place to stop and visit with the staff and have a wonderful meal. 5 stars +++++Tasty and deliciousPizza is to die for Eggplant is wonderful Lovely restaurant and wait staff Spaghetti w egg with meat balls is excellent Clean and delicious
Read More
Liz D.
Jan 21, 2025
The food was amazing!!Came during lunch and had the meat ravioli with rose sauce. It is a rare find to see a rose sauce on the menu!My friend had the lasagna and that was equally amazing! Good ol fashion Italian food!The service was also great, very attentive and friendly. Wish I lived closer.
Read More
Ashley S.
Jan 25, 2025
I love this place. Which is saying a lot since I'm not a huge pizza person. The size you get for the price is unmatched and the staff is super friendly. The inside is cute and there's also a nice outdoor area. I highly recommend at least trying this place once if you're ever in or near downtown Fairfield.
Read More
Jessika Y.
Feb 22, 2025
The food was not good, unfortunately and very expensive for what we got. We all had tummy issues. I was so excited to try this place and it disappointed. Pizza dough was not good. No flavor in the bruschetta and smashed up tomatoes. Not fresh tasting. Gnocchi and rose sauce was not good at all. Went on a Friday night. Just a bummer. $119
Read More
E T.
Jan 9, 2025
Still nasty ! A cook dropped a pizza onto the floor in the kitchen area then picked it up and placed it in a to-go box for a customer.They tell certain people that they cannot use their restrooms and to go around the corner to use another business restroom which is very unprofessional and prejudiced.Some nice servers & some nasty rude ones too. They make their money off of the people from the courthouses across the street & the military so they don't care about the locals & they treat them very rudely. Not recommended don't spend your money here go somewhere that it's appreciated and that they don't pick food up off the floor and serve it to you which is disgustingly nasty !
Read More
Jonathan L.
Feb 17, 2025
Been getting pizza from Pierre since Parry's pizza in American canyon. And I know for a fact t he pizza here is bomb. The huge bambino I recommend having a large vehicle if you plan on taking it home.
Read More
Joanna M.
Dec 7, 2024
We love Evelyn's but watching the boys cook during busy down town Christmas tree lighting was a whole new experience. Food is always amazing and fresh. Customer service has always been top tier. The gentlemen were busying prepping, and baking pizzas non stop for hours without loosing track of orders and customers names. I was amazed at the chaos happening but they were so organized. No one hit in the way of each other, communication was key and they were joking and having fun. Owner and management are doing amazing job! Giant slices of pizza are super affordable and tasty. If you haven't had the chance to stop by, you're missing out!
Read More
Jody W.
Jan 15, 2025
Great customer service at counter and at table as we ate inside. Does offer outside seating. We ordered the "Pizza By The Slice," option. It was $15 n change. Couldn't eat it all!!! Seet red sauce, lots of toppins, and we definitely plan to return.
Read More
Rita K.
Oct 30, 2023
Huge portion sizes for price and friendly service. A lot of sitting areas and could honestly see someone hosting a large party/event here. Lots of options for food. Seems like a great place for locals. Food was ok. Nothing great, nothing awful. Worst part was the seafood in the pasta dish was over cooked and considering it was $47 made it not worth it. Pizza was nice and crispy as requested. Calamari was perfectly cooked and side salad was a good portion and quality. Best thing was the free bread which was baked perfectly, fluffy and perfect for the pastas or oil/balsamic dip they provided. Would stop by for a pizza slice, probably wouldn't come back for a sit down dinner.
Read More
