NY Pie
NY Pie
a slice of pizza on a paper plate
Artisan pepperoni pizza
Menu
lunch special monday -fri
a slice of pepperoni pizza and french fries
slices ready to eat
Classic Pepperoni Pie; Classic Meatball Parmesan Sub
"Gourmet pizza". Abysmal.
Half cheese half pepperoni pizza
a menu for a pizza restaurant
chicken Chicken, Bacon and Ranch Pie Slice
Artisan pepperoni pizza
Italian Sub
Packed rollup. Delicious and massive.
food, pizza
sushi and sashimi, menu
food, pasta dish, pasta
Build your own w/pepperoni, jalapeños, n half pineapple
wraps, burritos and wraps, food, burrito
menu
Menu
food, pizza
greek salad
#1 Pizza in Waltham!
Lizzie Y.
May 16, 2024
Decided to come here for a quick bite before hitting the highway back home. They had a couple different topping ready to eat slices available and I tried the ranch chicken bacon slice. I asked for sides of garlic powder and pepper flakes. They added great extra flavor to the slice and I am glad I tried the chicken bacon ranch. Super delicious! I am not a huge pizza person, but NY Pie seems to make great pizza... probably one of the better pizzas I have tried in a long time.
Read More
Sophie T.
Sep 5, 2023
I call this "I just moved and we lost track of time from unpacking everything but we're starving at 10pm and what pizza place can come in clutch right now". That is NY Pie for ya. Delicious, huge slices of pizza, huge pieces of pepperoni slapped on top of cheese, and OPEN LATE!This is exactly what we needed after a long day (and weekend) of moving, and it was a struggle finding some place open so late. Alas, NY Pie was open AND was delicious. There's also a small parking lot next to it which makes it super easy to pull in and park since it's on a busy street. The inside is small but super cute and has everything so no complaints here (chips, sodas/waters/gatorade, and a bar height table to eat along a window). Classic pizza joint. Will remember this place as the hero of our moving weekend!!
Read More
Shay S.
Sep 4, 2023
This place does pizza right always. It is very close to pizza from back home (Brooklyn NY). We love this spot and always travel for a slice or a pie to go. Great service. Nice and friendly staff. The smell of the sauce alone is intoxicating. Thanks you!
Read More
Jenn V.
Feb 15, 2024
This is real ny pizza in waltham. Truly the best in the area. You can taste the flavor in the dough- good sauce and good quality cheese. They do pies and slices and have some seating indoors (not great for large groups). They also have outdoor seating for when the weather is warm.
Read More
Nick C.
Mar 21, 2024
We go here every day for lunch break, I have yet to get something that I haven't thoroughly enjoyed. Pizza is unreal with so many different types of toppings, but the regular cheese pizza is still the best I've ever had.The service is great. The owner is there every day making pizzas with the employees. You can tell he is a good man. The spot is nice, with its own parking lot as well.
Read More
Michael T.
Sep 28, 2022
In the interest of full disclosure, my reason for stopping in here wasn't so much that I had heard anything good, bad, or indifferent, but it was 11:15 pm, I was craving pizza, and every other kitchen in Waltham was closed. It was clear the owner was finishing up for the night, but he graciously offered to make me something anyway.(*Side note: I intentionally used the word "graciously", because it exactly sums up his demeanor. I even said, "I know the sign says 11, so if you're trying to get out of here, I totally understand". Nevertheless, he offered to cook for me, and was so genuine about it, that I accepted)Now, let's be honest. When you're shopping for pizza at 11pm, there isn't a high probability you're going to do much better than average if you're lucky. In fact, at that hour in Waltham you'll be hard-pressed to find anything that fulfills the concept of "pizza" in even the most basic definition of the word. NY Pie is definitely the exception. I got a large Hawaiian, and it was absolutely as good as I wanted it to be. The toppings were generous, and everything was cooked perfectly. For a guy who, 10 minutes earlier, was about to close up shop, and could have been forgiven if he just threw something together to get me out the door, the owner really made a point of preparing something delicious.Good service is as important to me as good food, and in this case I really appreciated both. The owner when out of his way, and I couldn't have been happier with the food. I drive by here regularly, and after only stopping in for the first time recently, I'm now looking forward to returning to check out the rest of their gigantic menu.
Read More
H K.
May 28, 2024
The food here is terrible . I've gone here three or four times in the past two years and every time there's an issue with the quality of food. I ordered a specialty pizza off their menu recently and when I received it, it didn't have the toppings that they claimed to have. Their "staten island" pizza is supposed to have Fried chicken, grated parmesan, marinara, provolone cheese, mozzarella, parsley, and drizzle of ranch dressing. It was a plain cheese pizza with a couple chunks of chicken, no parm, no provolone, no basil, no ranch. I contacted them and got no response. The sauce wasn't spread throughout the pizza as well more like a ring of sauce with barely any cheese and almost 2" crust. There are better options all over Waltham. This place is a HARD PASS!
Read More
Chris C.
May 27, 2024
Great food and GREAT service. Perfect neighborhood spot and excellent for both family and individual dinner. They're the best pizza place in town.
Read More
Samantha M.
Aug 30, 2024
good pizza, good mozz sticks. service real good, quick! the pizzeria looks like some from back home (new york lol) and it lived up to the way it looked!
Read More
D P.
Sep 8, 2023
Save your money and go elsewhere, $13 Italian sub was basically a sub roll and some lettuce
Read More
