NY Pie
NY Pie
My the biggest meat lover pizza
Margarita pizza with pepperoni
NY Cheese Pizza
Meat lover
Yummy
Pepperoni & Sausage
Menu - pan Pizza, Strombolis, Calazones and Toppings
Menu- Appetizers
Menu Salads, Drinks & Dessert
Menu - Pies
Pepperoni slice
Pepperoni and Grandmas
XL 18" NY Veggie with extra cheese yall
Large pizza pie!! NY Style.
Hawaiian
Slice of NY Cheese Pizza
Margherita
Pepperoni slice
Margherita
Pepperoni and sausage
food, pizza
It's the half NY Cheese Pizza and the NY white
Half NY Cheese Pizza and NY White..
Felice A.
Jul 16, 2024
Can't remember the last time I had pizza and legit NY Pizza ... it's been years. I saw someone try this pizza joint on Tik Tok and it looked like the real think so I was like I gotta try this. So while running errands I ventured over to #nypienashville @nypienashville First off like the NY Pizzerias they sell #slices they had 10 different #pizzas to chose from I figured I would try 4 to go for today and tomorrow. #pepperoni and #sausage the sausage is very tasty. Also one they call #grandmas I believe it is #margarita plain pepperoni and #pizzabianca white pizza. The #sauce is good. Pepperoni not too spicy. The #crust #thin #crispy. They had other varieties which I will need to try. I was told the #sarachi #chicken is a must try. Also they have #cannolis and #tiramisu and of course #nycheesecake Service was polite and helpful. The restaurant is inviting, clean but I could see it filling up very quickly. Looks like I got a new go to pizza parlor. Yum
Read More
Coti H.
Aug 7, 2024
We recently ordered delivery from NY Pie on Charlotte and were pretty impressed with their pizza! We got a half n half pepperoni and cheese NY style and it was loaded with cheese and perfectly foldable. We also got the garlic knots, which were just ok, but the marinara they were served with was fantastic! Will definitely eat here again!
Read More
Tommy B.
Jun 3, 2023
I've been to this location (west) 1 time before and felt myself starting to get hangry so I needed something quick. The first time, I didn't care for the food. The second time, I can say I had a much better experience. I ordered 2 slices of pep, and they came out fresh just a few minutes after I ordered. I can only speak this truth: I will return to get pizza here again, but only for the cheese and pep slice. I don't trust a lot of pizzerias with anything but the basic slice. But this slice was great. My suggestion: dress it up with seasoning, parm, and crushed red pep. Bonus: customer service is 10/10. I walked in wearing a buffalo bills hat and the guy behind the counter wearing a 49ers hat put on the Bills shout song (IYKYK). A great guy, good experience, good food.
Read More
Dustin H.
Jan 29, 2024
This is a pretty good to almost great pizza carryout spot. We were doing a monthly Costco run with the intent of grabbing a pepperoni pie from there to go only to discover their food court (as of January 2024) was out of commission (horrors!). So thanks to Yelp, I quickly discover we're 2 minutes away from NY Pie. I call them and order a large meat pizza and an order of garlic knots. Picked it up and it was ready right when they said it would be, got it home and feasted. There was enough left over for us to get another entire meal out of it and everything heated up perfectly in the oven.The slices are HUGE, NY style. Great crust, great toppings. Everything cooked well. The garlic knots are like giant rolls, and pretty good as well.Pricewise, we definitely spent more than we would have with the prices stuck 40 years ago menu from Costco, but the pizza is of much better quality. With tip, $40+ for all of the above. A loyalty program via your phone that seems cool. Friendly, funny service at the counter by folks who seem to like what they do. Not a top 5 Nashville pizza joint, but a better than solid one and I'll be back.
Read More
Kristin J.
Jul 14, 2024
As a native New Yorker, I have been looking for pizza that's like home!! This place had surpassed my expectations! Authentic NYC pizza in Nashville! We've been here several times and will keep coming back! Great pizza, great service!!
Read More
Edward S.
Mar 2, 2024
Great correct proportioned Pizza Pies. Some places add too much sauce or cheese because they don't know any better, NY Pie does! This is the closest to my NY Bronx Pizza I grew up with.
Read More
Joseph N.
May 10, 2024
My go to pizza in Nashville. Delicious slices and pies. The calzones are NY authentic. Filled with gooey deliciousness. I put this pizza against all the others. It is a genuine NY slice. Dough is crispy, sauce is tasty and the cheese perfect. I love the meat slice, so good. Make this your next pizza experience.
Read More
Nicole A.
Oct 11, 2024
I was recently bummed out just looking for pizza in Nashville until I discovered NY PIE! I ordered a huge XL NY style veggie and extra cheese pizza recently and had my hubby pick it up. It was so delicious and was enough to feed 10 haha! Service was quick, they def hooked us up with the extra cheese we requested. Love the location as well, it's clean and great for a dine in or take out:)
Read More
Emma S.
Oct 14, 2024
Pies are excellent, as are meatballs and their salads. Highly recommend!! They have never let us down.
Read More
Rebecca T.
Sep 15, 2024
Yum! The staff is very friendly and helpful and the pizza is quite tasty. Big, foldable slices. Very good.
Read More
