Nine Pies Pizzeria

I do not particularly enjoy pizzas and I never have in my life, that is, until yesterday!!! I got the Siluro (pizza bianca topped w/pancetta, yukon gold potatoes, onions) and I would happily shell out $$ to get it again. Nine Pies, thanks for making me believe in pizza again.

This place is about the atmosphere and Oscar. He greeted me when I came in and talked me through their wines, food and tap. I had an absolutely delightful time killing an hour here and he upsold me without even trying. The establishment is friendly, charming, clean and all around just a fun hang. The meatballs are gluten free - this isn't a big deal other than they are actually made of meat. So many places fill their meatballs with bread filler. It was simply a delight to enjoy them with their well balanced tomato sauce. I do think they need a bit more fat in them, but that's just my opinion. They were pretty pricey at $18 so I wouldn't necessarily suggest they are a must order. The calzone felt much more like a pizza folded in half. I took it to go and thought it tasted great - especially the high quality ingredients. That said, i think it's probably best eaten fresh from the oven there. Next time for take out I would get a pizza. Since the venue is owned by Long Shadows, they are selling wines with a tiny markup - both bottles and glasses. So to enjoy a good bottle of wine with a meal and not be gauged, this is the place to go! Delightful place with good quality food, great staff and well priced wine. Enjoy!

This place is amazing. Ocean is a fantastic host. Spent time talking with us and getting to know each other. Food was perfect. One of the best pizza I have had anywhere. Paired with the local wines and you have a winner. Given the nice weather we were able to sit outside really enhancing the dinning experience. If you are looking for outstanding unique pizza this is it. Sorry Ocean, hope I don't ruin your secret.

We came for a tasting and my people wanted pizza. It was a nice day so we camped out under umbrellas and played with the wine dog while we contemplated. I decided to get some bolognese, whilst my friends grabbed a pizza. I cleaned my plate and would opt for the pasta again. My friends ended up taking some of the pizza home, so I guess I know who the cochon was. Good scores.

The customer service here is amazing and they have built in parking in this plaza. The waiter was very approachable and customized our pizza to be half/half. The pizza was crunchy and thin slices. We ordered pasta which they customized for a vegetarian.The ambience of the location is very relaxing and welcoming.Reasons for Rating:+1 Excellent location and parking+1 Food taste really good+1 Customer service+1 Interior/atmosphere+1 Would return/recommend others

Slices! You don't see slices anymore. Love this place. The pizza is good - even my friend from NYC says so - although, I'm tired of east coast people turning their nose up at what I consider to be good pizza. I mean, come on, Pag's is good. Or at least, I like it, so keep your snooty opinions to yourself. Love it or leave it! Just kidding.

Food was amazing. Very family friendly and relaxing. Amazing service and very attentive staff. 10/10 would highly recommend!

As an Italian from the East Coast, I can be very picky about Italian cuisine, especially claims of New York style pizza. I also love to be surprised when PNW restaurants get it right!Nine Pies is an upscale restaurant that's also accessible in a non-bougie, casual kinda way. That's the best way to describe it. We were immediately greeted by our server (owner?) and seated. I ordered the puttanesca; a dish I truly love, yet rarely get to enjoy. I asked the waiter for a good red wine choice and came through with a good Sangiovese. The dish was flavorful with just the right amount of salty goodness. My hubby is easier to please and enjoyed the pepperoni pizza. I of course had to sample it. Yes, it was a quality pie, cooked to perfection; just slightly charred on the bottom. We split a ceasar salad. It was fresh, lightly dressed with a nice crunch to it. It was a delicious dinner with an upbeat, casual vibe. We hope to come back next time we are in town!

Oh gosh, so not good.We went for slices, walked in and saw the slices in the case.. the cheese was a layer of rubber and the crust an undercooked pale yellow. Pretty similar to how pictures look online.I'm looking for nice browning on the crust and brown spots on an oily/gooey/stringy mess of cheese swirling around tomato sauce.So we knew the pizza wasn't for us and went with calzone instead. When they arrived, they were pale yellow and undercooked, like the pizzas. No taste to the dough and a dry texture.They were stuffed with ridiculous amounts of cheese and really poor quality meats. The accompanying marinara had a strong taste of tomato paste/ketchup.Went down like cement. Clean restaurant. Super friendly service!! Sorry we didn't like it. Try aging your dough?

Finally!! I have found great NY pizza in Seattle. I had to grab a last minute meal for my son on a Tuesday night. I walked in 8 minutes before closing and they said "sure, we can still make you a pizza". It was so good. Perfect NY crust. The toppings were also great, super fresh. We will be back!!