Magical Box Bakery

Came across the Magical Box food truck randomly at the Newark Farmer's market.I tried their seasonal menu which had a blueberry cobbler matcha. They advertise that the blueberry cobbler syrup is homemade and I have to say it was out of this world! A nice flavor that you can't find at your standard coffee shop would come back for this alone.I also got a Nutella banana bread and it was delicious! Glad to see this at the farmers market will definitely stop by here again!

I was on Yelp late at night and saw Magical Box Bakery on my feed again. My mouth started to water remembering the last time I got cookies from here. Unfortunately preorders were closed, so on a whim messaged her on Facebook to check if their farmers market stand had walk-in purchases.I woke up early on a Sunday and went to the Newark Farmers market at the Newpark Mall next to the AMC. I probably bought way too much for myself. I got a box of Snicker doodles, kerfuffles, and Pumpkin chocolate chip cookies. They were all so good! Moist and flavorful without being too sweet. I also got the brownies she was selling. Delicious. I sort of wish she had an assortment cookie box which had all the flavors, so I could try everything without having to get a full box of each. I only say this as I'm getting chubby eating all these cookies

I got the s'mores bar and I was so disappointed. And I loves s'mores everything! It's literally just a chunk of marshmallow. Graham cracker layer was literally just crumbs. I wish it was thicker. The marshmallow wasn't really toasted, it was just for the color I guess. Picture on IG makes it look hella good. I took a star off for the taste and another star off for the price. I really wanted to like it so I wanted to warn others. Hard pass for me. I purchased 2. Took a bit and threw both away. It was so disappointing that I drove me to write a review.

AMAZING COOKIES! These are better than Christina Tocci cookies and the best thing is you are supporting a local family with serious baking skills. Magical Box is available at Farmers Markets and also do delivery and pickup, you can preorder on their website. We found them at Newarks Farmers Market and it's been one of the best unplanned discoveries we've had in awhile. You can't beat fresh-baked cookies, the taste and texture at the most optimal.S'mores Sandwich Cookie, an evolved version of the Little Debbie Oatmeal Creme Pies. Soft cake-like batter melts gently in your mouth, sandwiching a cloud-like marshmellow layer. It's very balanced and not too sweet, every bite I had I kept asking myself "why is this so good".Salted Chocolate Chip, crunchy layer on bottom with a soft bite-through. Salt and chocolate a great mix of sweet and savory.We got a single Bougie-Cookie which is not pictured, its a great oatmeal cookie based on the urban-legend $250 NM cookie recipe.

The easiest transaction ever, and the Red Stars are totally deserving! Heather was able to accommodate my last minute order of 5 dozen cookies for my son's graduation party and each cookie flavor did not disappoint!Salted Chocolate Chip - Amazing!Kerfuffle with customized M&M colors - So cute and yummy!Bougie Cookie - Delish!Snickerdoodle - Soo good!And the pièce de ré·sis·tance - Magic Swirl! I packaged each cookie in its own bag so guests wouldn't be touching the cookies but Heather packaged each dozen in brown boxes with red and white twine. Each box was labeled with the cookie flavor inside, and she also included instructions on how to keep the cookies and how to warm them up if we choose to.I was definitely pleased with the cookies we got from Magical Box and I look forward to ordering from her again!

I was referred by a family member, and I am so happy I ordered cookies from here. If you want to sample some flavors before ordering, Heather (the owner and baker) is occasionally at the Newark farmer's market on Sundays. I ordered 6 different flavors for my coworkers, and the fan favorites were the magic swirls, s'mores and cookies n cream. Everything was delicious and it was a very easy transaction. Heather replies quickly on Yelp and you can pay via venmo. Once they're done, you pick them up outside of her house. For larger orders, she prefers a week's notice. I am happy to support this home bakery and will definitely order again in the future!

OMG the Magical Swirl cookies! They were so soft and melt in your mouth. The packaging is so well done: simple and matching the cookies. The Magic Maker (baker) is always baking new, amazing goods so make sure to follow her on Facebook or Instagram for the latest creations!! Next on my list: Butterbeer cookies, Bougie Chip, Star Brioche loafs!

I preordered a batch of the Magic Swirl cookies. They're so good! I love red velvet cake so this was right up my alley. Ordering is super easy and so is pickup. I'm definitely looking forward to trying all their flavors!

Magical Box Bakery's Cinnamon Brioche for a holiday buffet table disappeared in a magical minute. Beautiful on display and delicious on the palate. I was tempted to claim it as homemade; instead I will say I highly recommend baked goods from Magical Box Bakery. You will not be disappointed.

The absolute best I could have ever hoped for!Great communication, great service and great products. All of the wedding guests loved the flavors from our treat table provided entirely by Magical Box Bakery. I handed out her IG account to at least a dozen people wanting to know who the baking master was, it's Heather!If you're reading through reviews to pick a bakery, stop looking! You've found that bakery with Magical Box Bakery.